A Host Wanted to Stop In-Laws From Inviting 4 Extra Relatives to Thanksgiving, and Miss Manners Said Extra Guests Are ‘Kinda the Point’

A woman hosting her husband’s family for Thanksgiving for the second year wrote to Miss Manners hoping to stop her in-laws from bringing extra relatives, after they invited 4 of them last year. The etiquette columnist did not take her side, and the column’s title summed up the answer: “Extra Guests At Thanksgiving Are Kinda The Point.”

The column, dated Oct. 27, 2026, lands just weeks before Thanksgiving on Nov. 26, when plenty of hosts are counting chairs and wondering how many people will actually show up.

A whole roast turkey on a platter ready to be carved
Mark Miller – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

What the host asked

According to the Miss Manners column, listed on Oct. 27 in ArcaMax’s Miss Manners archive, the letter writer was preparing to host her husband’s family again. The year before, her brother-in-law and his wife had invited the wife’s parents, the wife’s brother and the brother’s daughter, 4 extra guests in all. The host had met them a few times but did not know them well.

She made room for them, she wrote, but would prefer not to have people she barely knew invited by guests to her home on a holiday. She asked how to make clear, without being rude, that her husband’s brother and his wife were welcome but the invitation did not stretch to the wife’s extended family.

She also shared some background. Her husband’s family often had extra people at holiday meals growing up, and her sister-in-law “does not like to cook,” while the letter writer spends a good deal of time preparing the meal and setting the table.

Many hosts will recognize the feeling. A guest count that grows after the turkey has been bought is one of the classic holiday headaches, along with the checks covered in this list of home checks to finish before Thanksgiving houseguests arrive.

Miss Manners sided with the extra guests

Miss Manners answered with a question of her own, asking whether the host knew the Thanksgiving legend and whether that story was not about “inclusive hospitality.” The column is written by Judith Martin with her children Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin. According to background on Judith Martin, the Miss Manners column began in 1978, and the two younger Martins began sharing the byline in 2013.

The columnist said she was not asking the host to take on a burden she did not want. Had the letter been about the work of feeding so many people, Miss Manners wrote, she would have been sympathetic and would have suggested getting help, starting with the host’s husband, or asking other relatives to take a turn hosting. She also noted that the sister-in-law had apparently been excused from hosting on exactly those grounds. For couples who split on a question like this, there are ways to keep holiday disagreements from turning into big arguments.

But the complaint was about the guests themselves, and that, in the column’s view, is where the host’s argument fell apart. Thanksgiving, Miss Manners concluded, is not the occasion to complain about breaking bread with near-strangers, especially relatives of the host’s own brother-in-law whom she had already met.

The answer fits a long line of etiquette advice about generous hosting, much like these old-school etiquette rules that have quietly disappeared and the other side of the table, covered in these etiquette tips for being a good houseguest.

A family seated around a Thanksgiving dinner table in 1971
Family photos of Infrogmation – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

The original Thanksgiving had extra guests, too

The legend Miss Manners pointed to does include a lot of unexpected company. According to background on the history of Thanksgiving, the Plymouth colonists held a three-day harvest celebration in autumn 1621, and colonist Edward Winslow wrote that the Wampanoag leader Massasoit arrived “with some ninety men.” The meal was cooked by the four adult women who had survived the first winter, along with young daughters and servants.

Thanksgiving now falls on the fourth Thursday of November, a date Congress fixed in federal law in 1941. In 2026, that is Nov. 26.

Planning food for a few more chairs

Whatever a host decides about the guest list, the practical side is the same: more people means more food. The USDA’s turkey roasting guidance suggests planning about 1 pound of turkey per person, or about 1 1/4 pounds per person for a pre-stuffed frozen bird. By that measure, 4 extra guests means roughly 4 more pounds of turkey.

Thawing a larger bird takes longer, too. The USDA says to allow about 24 hours in the refrigerator for every 4 to 5 pounds, so a 16- to 20-pound turkey needs 4 to 5 days. A 12- to 16-pound bird needs 3 to 4 days, and a 20- to 24-pound bird needs 5 to 6. Once thawed, a turkey can stay in the refrigerator for another 1 to 2 days, which gives a host a small cushion if the guest count changes late. The USDA also recommends keeping the bird in its original wrapper on a tray to catch drips while it thaws. The turkey and any stuffing should reach 165 degrees Fahrenheit, and leftovers should be refrigerated within 2 hours and used within 3 to 4 days.

Oven space can get tight with a bigger crowd, and a countertop appliance can help, as this comparison of air fryers and toaster ovens for Thanksgiving shows.

Miss Manners’ bottom line was simple. If the work is the problem, ask for help. If the guests are the problem, Thanksgiving is the wrong holiday to make that case.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Marjory Collins, Farm Security Administration – Public domain/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *