Butter keeps 12 months in the freezer, while milk lasts 3 months and yogurt 1 to 2 months, according to University of Illinois Extension’s freezer storage chart. The times apply to a freezer held at 0 F and describe how long each dairy product holds its top quality.
The chart is a handy tool for cutting down on waste, since a block of butter bought on sale or a carton of milk nearing its date does not have to end up in the trash. A few products, though, do not freeze well at all.

Illinois Extension’s Dairy Freezer Times
Butter or margarine tops the list at 12 months, according to University of Illinois Extension. Hard cheeses such as cheddar and Swiss keep 4 to 6 months, and so do processed cheese loaves and slices. The extension suggests shredding or slicing hard cheese into smaller pieces before freezing for the best results.
Milk keeps 3 months, and Illinois Extension recommends putting it into smaller airtight containers with an inch left at the top to allow for expansion. Heavy cream keeps 2 to 4 months, ice cream and sherbet keep 2 months, and yogurt keeps 1 to 2 months.
Ohio State University Extension’s freezer storage fact sheet lines up with the Illinois numbers: butter or margarine about 12 months, milk about 3 months, heavy cream 2 to 4 months, and yogurt 1 to 2 months at 0 F. It lists soft cheeses such as brie and cottage cheese at about 3 months, a point where it differs from the Illinois chart. The same freezer habits carry over to produce, as in this walkthrough on freezing fresh green beans.
Eggs are covered on the same chart. Whole eggs out of the shell keep 12 months, and unopened egg substitutes also keep 12 months. Eggs in the shell should not be frozen, and opened egg substitutes should not be either, the chart says.
Households that already stock the freezer ahead of the holidays can use the chart alongside a pre-Thanksgiving fridge and freezer check to see what needs to be used first, and a list of essential items to keep in the refrigerator offers a second look at what belongs where.
The Dairy Foods That Do Not Freeze Well
Illinois Extension lists a few exceptions. Soft cheeses such as brie and cottage cheese do not freeze well. Lighter cream and half-and-half do not either, which is why only heavy cream gets a freezer time on the chart.
North Dakota State University Extension’s guide to freezing dairy products and eggs reaches a similar conclusion for cultured products. It says sour cream, yogurt and buttermilk lose smoothness, turn grainy and may separate, though they can still be used in cooking. It also says frozen hard cheese turns crumbly and slices poorly, while the flavor holds.
Other Extension Services Give Shorter Times
The Illinois numbers are on the long end. Purdue Extension’s Spotlight on Freezer Storage lists butter at 6 to 9 months and milk at 1 month, and it says yogurt should not be frozen. Mississippi State University Extension’s dairy and eggs freezer feature says properly packaged unsalted butter can last up to 5 months in the freezer and salted butter up to 9 months.
The University of Missouri Extension’s Freezing Basics guide (GH1501, reviewed August 2026) is shorter still on some items: butter 6 to 9 months, natural cheese 6 to 8 weeks, fresh fluid milk 1 month and plain yogurt 1 month, though it lists margarine at 12 months and flavored yogurt at 5 months. It also says reusing cottage cheese, sour cream or milk containers for freezing is “no bargain,” because they are not moisture-vapor-proof.
Freezing is one way to make groceries stretch, in the spirit of the money-saving ideas in this guide to clever frugal living, and shoppers who work from a written list, a habit described in a piece on traits of list-makers, may find fewer surprises in the fridge.
Because the extension services do not agree, any date written on a package should be viewed as a guide to quality rather than a hard stop. Purdue says longer storage is not dangerous, but flavor and texture decline. Illinois Extension makes a related point: properly handled food stored in a freezer at 0 F will always be safe as long as it has not thawed.
Packing and Thawing Dairy
Ohio State’s rule of thumb is to wrap tightly, wrap again and wrap individual portions separately, with each package labeled with its date and contents. Purdue recommends dating packages based on the recommended maximum storage time, using moisture- and vapor-proof wrap or containers and leaving headroom in containers for expansion. Mississippi State says to keep butter in its original wrapping, add plastic wrap and foil or another moisture- and vapor-proof layer, and place it in an airtight container so it does not absorb other flavors.
For milk, Mississippi State also suggests freezing in smaller containers or ice cube trays, and it notes that milk separates as it thaws because the fats and proteins thaw faster than the water. Shaking or whisking the milk recombines it. NDSU says shaking or stirring after thawing can restore smoothness.
Two of the sources agree on thawing. Mississippi State says to thaw milk, cheese and butter in the refrigerator and use them immediately, and it adds that cheese needs 24 to 48 hours to thaw so its moisture can reabsorb. NDSU says to use dairy as fresh after thawing and not to refreeze it.
A quick summary of the Illinois Extension chart: butter 12 months, hard and processed cheese 4 to 6 months, heavy cream 2 to 4 months, milk 3 months, ice cream and sherbet 2 months, and yogurt 1 to 2 months. Everything is measured at 0 F, and the figures describe top quality rather than a hard deadline.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: T.Tseng – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons