Mayonnaise Gets 8 Hours Above 50°F After a Power Outage, While Peanut Butter, Ketchup and Mustard Can Stay

After a power outage, opened mayonnaise gets a longer window than most refrigerated food: it should be discarded only if it has been above 50°F for more than 8 hours, according to the FoodSafety.gov outage chart. Tartar sauce and horseradish follow the same 8-hour rule.

The same chart says peanut butter, ketchup and mustard can stay in the refrigerator, along with jelly, relish, olives, pickles and several bottled sauces. Most other refrigerated food is on a stricter clock of 2 hours at 40°F or above.

Jars of mayonnaise in a store refrigerator case
Eric Fischer – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

The Mayonnaise Exception: 8 Hours Above 50°F

FoodSafety.gov, the federal food safety site, last reviewed the page on August 8, 2024. Its rule for most refrigerated food is to discard anything exposed to temperatures of 40°F or above for more than 2 hours. Opened mayonnaise, tartar sauce and horseradish are called out as a special case: they go only if they were above 50°F for more than 8 hours.

The Red Cross power outage page gives the general rule to throw out food that has been warmer than 40°F, so a reader who wants a single conservative line can use that number for everything, mayonnaise included.

The chart’s standing advice applies too: “When in Doubt, Throw it Out!” It also says never to taste food to judge whether it is safe. An opened jar that sat out through a long outage, with no thermometer reading, is a case for that rule.

Keeping the refrigerator door shut is what makes any of these windows hold. The Red Cross says an unopened refrigerator keeps foods cold for about 4 hours. Anyone reorganizing the door shelves after an outage may find ideas in a roundup of clever storage hacks.

The Keep Shelf: Peanut Butter, Ketchup, Mustard and More

The keep list on the chart is long. It names peanut butter, jelly, relish, taco sauce, mustard, ketchup, olives and pickles. It adds Worcestershire, soy, barbecue and hoisin sauces, plus opened vinegar-based dressings.

Wikipedia’s entry on mustard says its acidity means it does not need refrigeration for safety, though long storage can dry it out, darken it or make it bitter. The same entry says stirring fixes separation. Tomato ketchup, the ketchup entry says, is typically made from tomatoes, sugar and vinegar, with salt, spices and seasonings such as onion, garlic and cloves.

Bottles that stay on a counter or shelf are a separate question from the refrigerator, and designers’ advice on what not to display on open kitchen shelves covers that side. A look back at 31 forgotten household items from the past shows how many kitchen items have come and gone.

Condiment bottles set out on a counter
Ser Amantio di Nicolao – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

The Discard Shelf: Creamy Dressings, Spaghetti Sauce and Fish Sauce

Not every jar gets the same pass. The chart puts opened creamy dressings, opened spaghetti sauce, fish sauce and oyster sauce on the discard list once they have been at 40°F or above for more than 2 hours.

Opened vinegar-based dressings are on the keep list, while opened creamy dressings are not. The chart does not explain the split, so the label type, creamy or vinegar-based, is the practical guide.

Opened spaghetti sauce sits on the discard side with other cooked and prepared foods, including gravy, broth, casseroles, soups and stews. Cheesecake, cream-filled pastries and pies with egg or milk fillings are also on it. A kitchen with a large Thanksgiving menu in the refrigerator has more to sort than one with only condiments, and five fridge and freezer checks before the big grocery run covers the planning side, while a comparison of air fryers and a toaster oven that free up the oven this Thanksgiving speaks to the cooking side.

Where Mayonnaise, Ketchup and Mustard Came From

Wikipedia describes mayonnaise as an emulsion of oil, egg yolk and an acid such as vinegar or lemon juice. Most hypotheses place its origin in Mahón on Menorca, during the French occupation. The Duke of Richelieu took Mahón in 1756, and one theory says his cook adopted a local sauce. The French term appears in 1806, and the English word is attested in 1815.

Commercial jarred mayonnaise began in Philadelphia in 1907, when Amelia Schlorer started selling her family’s recipe, the entry says. Richard Hellmann’s New York delicatessen featured his wife’s recipe, it was mass-marketed in 1912, and it was trademarked as Hellmann’s Blue Ribbon Mayonnaise in 1926. Kewpie, Japan’s most popular brand, was started in 1925 by Tochiro Nakashima and is typically made with rice vinegar.

The ketchup entry says James Mease published the first known tomato ketchup recipe in 1812, and Jonas Yerkes is credited as the first American to sell it in a bottle, distributing it nationally by 1837. Mustard goes back further: Romans mixed ground mustard seed with grape must, Dijon was a recognized mustard center by the 13th century, and the hot dog pairing is said to have debuted at the 1904 St. Louis World’s Fair with French’s mustard.

For a household sorting jars after an outage, the practical numbers are the ones on the chart: 8 hours above 50°F for opened mayonnaise, tartar sauce and horseradish, and 2 hours at 40°F or above for most of the rest.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: jules – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *