The last of the garden potatoes are dug, a net of onions hangs in the garage, and the question is where everything should live until spring. The easy answer is one big bin in the cool corner of the basement. The extension charts say it is not that simple.
Iowa State University Extension lists both potatoes and onions at 5 to 8 months of storage life, yet the two crops want very different conditions. Here is how the charts from Iowa State, the University of Massachusetts and the University of Nebraska-Lincoln compare, with the date of each source.

Potatoes: Condition First, Then Cold and Damp
Iowa State’s winter storage vegetables page, written by Aaron Steil and last reviewed in January 2025, says potatoes should be conditioned for two weeks, which the page calls curing, at 50 to 60 degrees Fahrenheit and 85 to 90 percent relative humidity. They then move to storage at 40 degrees and 90 to 95 percent humidity, where they keep 5 to 8 months.
The page adds two warnings. Potatoes should be kept dark so they do not turn green, and above 50 degrees they may sprout within two to three months. A grower with a spare shelf can find more ideas in this guide to seasonal storage and these storage hacks.
A shopper trying to cut waste at the register can read this list of items not worth buying at the grocery store, and a list of kitchen checks before Thanksgiving dinner helps with the rest of the pantry.
Onions: Condition Longer, Then Cold and Dry
For onions, the same Iowa State page says to dry them down for 2 to 3 weeks in a warm, dry, ventilated spot until the tops and necks are thoroughly dry. Storage is then at 32 to 40 degrees and 65 to 70 percent humidity, again for 5 to 8 months. Thick-necked bulbs should be used first because they do not store well, and mesh bags, baskets or crates give the airflow onions need.
An undated Iowa State Extension fall garden produce note says warm storage causes onions to sprout and damp places cause rot, and tells growers to check stored onions regularly through fall and winter and discard any that are rotting. Gardeners fighting off pests before harvest may like this guide to the worst garden pests.
The Humidity Gap Between the Two Bins
Put the numbers side by side and the gap is clear: potatoes want 90 to 95 percent humidity, while onions want 65 to 70 percent. The Iowa State pages do not give direct advice on storing the two together, so the case for separate bins rests on those numbers. Wikipedia’s onion entry adds that cooking onions can draw moisture from vegetables stored alongside them, which may cause decay, and that they can absorb odors from apples and pears.
That is why separate bins are a sensible plan, though not a rule written in any single extension chart.
What UMass Extension Lists
The University of Massachusetts Amherst vegetable program’s storage conditions fact sheet was written in October 2011 and updated in January 2018, so its numbers are older than the Iowa State page. It lists potatoes at 40 to 45 degrees and 90 percent humidity for 5 to 8 months, and onions at 32 degrees and 65 to 70 percent humidity, with storage life varying by variety. Garlic is listed at 32 degrees and 65 to 70 percent for about 6 to 7 months, and the sheet says garlic dehydrates above 65 degrees and sprouts between 40 and 65.
The same sheet rates both potatoes and onions low for ethylene sensitivity, which matters because apples release the gas. Iowa State says ripening fruit gives off ethylene that promotes sprouting in potatoes, so potatoes belong away from apples and other fruit.
Variety Matters for Onions
The Iowa State fall produce note says some onions are long keepers and some are not. ‘Copra,’ ‘First Edition,’ ‘Stuttgarter’ and ‘Redwing’ can last several months, while ‘Walla Walla’ and ‘Sweet Spanish’ last only a few weeks. The note says storage life depends on variety and conditions, which is why the 5 to 8 month figure is a ceiling for good keepers, not a promise for every bulb.
What a Home Pantry Actually Gets
Most kitchens are not 40 degrees. The University of Nebraska-Lincoln’s food storage chart, which says it was updated in 2026, lists potatoes and onions at about 1 month in a pantry at 50 to 70 degrees. It lists onions at 2 months in the refrigerator and both at 10 to 12 months in the freezer, with times given for quality.
The practical takeaway from the charts is a short checklist. Potatoes get a dark, cold, humid spot below 50 degrees and away from apples. Onions get a cold, dry, airy spot in mesh or a crate, with the thick-necked bulbs eaten first. Both get a regular look through the pile, and Iowa State says to discard onions that are rotting. Anyone storing a large harvest can also pull a few weeks’ worth into the kitchen at a time, so the main stock stays at its cooler, steadier conditions.
None of the pages checked gives a single number that fits both crops, which is the main lesson: the 5 to 8 month figure is the same, but the way to reach it is not.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: ZooFari – Public domain/Wikimedia Commons