A muffin batter is half mixed, the bowl of dry ingredients is waiting, and the butter dish turns out to be empty. A bottle of vegetable oil sits two feet away, and the question is whether it can step in.
According to Bob’s Red Mill, the answer depends on how the butter is used. Oil replaces melted butter at about 3/4 the amount (three-quarters), but butter that is creamed with sugar is a different job, and the company says oil cannot take it over.

The 3/4 Rule for Melted Butter
Bob’s Red Mill says home bakers can typically use about 3/4 of the butter amount called for when swapping in oil. Its own example is a recipe that asks for 10 tablespoons of butter, which becomes about 7 1/2 tablespoons of oil.
The same math works for smaller amounts. A single stick of butter is 8 tablespoons, so the 3/4 rule lands at 6 tablespoons of oil. A full cup of butter is 16 tablespoons, which becomes 12.
The company adds that melted butter alone is the best case. When a recipe calls for melted butter and nothing else, it says there is a better chance of similar results with oil.
Food director Jenna Helwig of Real Simple said much the same in a Good Morning America roundup of baking swaps published in December 2022. For melted butter, she said, “it’s totally okay to use oil,” but the swap “won’t work as well” when a recipe wants room-temperature, solid butter.
Why Creamed Butter and Sugar Is the Exception
Creaming is the step where soft butter and sugar are beaten together until the mixture turns pale and fluffy. According to Wikipedia’s entry on the creaming method, the fat holds tiny air bubbles worked in during beating, and those bubbles expand in the oven and act as leavening for cake batter, cookie dough and buttercream.
Bob’s Red Mill puts the problem plainly: oil “does not carry the air bubbles” needed for that creamy texture, so a recipe built on creaming should keep its butter. A cookie dough or a pound cake that begins with creamed butter and sugar is counting on those bubbles for lift and structure.
The physical difference is easy to see on the counter. Butter stays firm in the refrigerator and softens to a spreadable texture around 60°F, according to Wikipedia’s butter article, which also notes that American butter must be at least 80% butterfat. Oil is liquid at every kitchen temperature, so there is nothing to whip.
Even a pastry chef who often swaps oil for butter keeps structure in mind. Former White House executive pastry chef Bill Yosses told the same Good Morning America piece that he often replaces butter with olive oil or a neutral oil such as grapeseed or safflower, and that some sugar is still needed for structure.
Kitchens change around the people who use them. A lighthearted look at 7 things that were in nearly every 1980s kitchen is a nostalgic trip through the baking gear of that decade, and a feature on 3 zodiac signs said to be naturally great at cooking for others is a fun read for the hosts who end up covering holiday baking.
Picking a Bottle for the Swap
Flavor is the other half of the decision. Bob’s Red Mill notes that a little more vegetable oil can be used than olive oil, depending on the type of oil a baker prefers.
Helwig’s list in the roundup includes canola oil, melted coconut oil and even olive oil when the flavor suits the recipe, a reminder that olive oil has a taste that shows up in a plain vanilla muffin.
Baking days also tend to crowd the kitchen. A recent look at air fryer toaster ovens for small batches covers one way to free the main oven, and a Thanksgiving comparison of countertop ovens goes further on the same theme. A guide to kitchen remodel ideas on a shoestring budget may help bakers who dream of more counter space.
A neutral bottle is the safe choice for a batch of blueberry muffins, where the fruit should be the star. A stronger oil can make sense where the flavor fits, such as an olive oil cake with citrus.

Quick Breads and Muffins as Natural Candidates
Bob’s Red Mill names quick breads and muffins as good places to try oil. Wikipedia’s muffin article describes the American quick-bread muffin as flour and baking soda with fat, eggs and flavorings added.
Bob’s Red Mill does not describe the mixing method for those batters, but the pattern in its advice is clear. Batters that begin with melted fat have no creaming step to lose, so oil has an easier time standing in.
Home cooks planning holiday baking can think of the recipe card as a sorting tool. If the method says “melt the butter,” oil at 3/4 the amount is a reasonable experiment. If the method says “cream the butter and sugar,” the butter stays.
Oil Outside the Mixing Bowl
The company also lists jobs beyond the batter. For greasing pans, it says vegetable oil is a common swap that “works just as well” as butter as a nonstick layer.
For bread, brushing oil on the loaf gives it a shiny finish, and the company says to brush it on and bake for a few minutes. It also advises bakers to pay attention to how a dough or batter normally looks, so a change in the swap is easy to spot.
That last tip is the real safety net. A cook who knows what a favorite batter looks like at the point of mixing will notice right away if it turns too loose or too oily.
The rule of thumb that comes out of the Bob’s Red Mill guidance is short. Melted butter gets about 3/4 the amount in oil, and creamed butter stays butter.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: DrCruse – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons