A grocery bag is unpacked, a reservation is on the calendar and the phone stays quiet. A California couple wrote to Dear Abby about that familiar wait: a niece who says she will arrive at one time and shows up hours later, sometimes days later.
In the column published Nov. 1, 2026, Dear Abby told the couple to stop catering to the delays. The niece should cancel if she cannot come on the agreed date, and the couple should not sit home when she is hours late. For the niece’s parents, who keep the couple waiting too, Abby set a limit of 30 minutes.

A Niece Who Is Hours Late, and a Couple With a Full Fridge
As laid out in the Nov. 1 Dear Abby column in The Philadelphia Inquirer, the letter comes from a couple who signed it On Schedule in California. They live 500 miles from their nearest relatives, but a niece attends a university about 50 miles away, so she often visits on holidays and weekends.
The trouble is timing. According to the letter, the niece frequently shows up hours after the time she gave, and once she arrived two days late. Because the couple sets aside their regular activities for her visits, shops for special meals and makes reservations, a late arrival leaves them sitting at home with plans already canceled.
A weekend with a student relative is a kind of hosting, and hosting runs on a clock. Food shopped for Friday night has to be cooked at some point, and a table booked for a certain hour does not wait. A recent piece on etiquette blunders to avoid at a steakhouse touches on why a reservation time matters to a restaurant too.
Holiday weeks make the timing harder. A recent report on AAA’s Thanksgiving travel forecast shows how crowded the roads and airports get, and a list of carry-on suitcases for Thanksgiving trips is a reminder that a traveler is often juggling bags, rides and schedules. Anyone expecting a guest on the road can ask for a text when the guest is an hour out. A checklist of home checks before houseguests arrive for Thanksgiving adds a practical side, and a list of etiquette tips for being a good houseguest covers the guest’s side.
The niece is not the only relative in the letter. Her parents also change plans, the writers say, and they arrive late. When the couple travels to see them, the parents rarely adjust their own schedules, and the couple sometimes waits hours for them to come home.
When the parents visit the couple’s area, the days fill up with so many activities that stops at special places get pushed to the end of the day, and the couple has to rush before closing. The parents also ask the couple to travel to meet them and then keep changing the plan.
The couple closes by explaining the dilemma. They feel used, and they do not know how to raise the issue without alienating family members they want to keep close.

Abby’s Reply: Say It Plainly and Set a Limit
Dear Abby opens bluntly, calling the relatives “boorish, disrespectful” in her first line, and says the couple has been catering to them. She tells the writers they are overdue for a conversation with the niece.
The message to the niece is simple. If she cannot arrive on the agreed date, she should cancel rather than leave the couple waiting, and the couple should make clear that they will not stay home for someone who shows up hours late.
The parents get the same message. In the section addressed to them, Abby says that if the couple is left waiting more than 30 minutes, they should carry on without them or go home. She adds that she considers 30 minutes generous.
The advice does not call for a fight. It asks the couple to say what they will do in advance, so the plan stays kind and clear, and the decision about whether to wait is theirs.
What Etiquette Guides Say About Arrival Times
The Emily Post Institute’s party etiquette tips for hosts and guests say guests should arrive at the stated time or a short while after, generally within about 15 minutes, and should not arrive early. A guest who will be significantly late is expected to phone the host with an estimated arrival time.
The same page says hosts should have the meal prepped and the table set well before guests arrive, and that clear timing details in an invitation help everyone.
When Dinner Waits Longer Than the Guest Said It Would
Hours of waiting matter for the food as well. According to USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service, in its guidance on leftovers and food safety, perishable food that has been out at room temperature for more than 2 hours should be discarded, and the limit drops to 1 hour when the temperature is above 90°F. Cold perishable food should stay at 40°F or below.
That means a dinner cooked for a 6 p.m. arrival is on a clock of its own. A host who keeps a roast on the counter for a guest who is four hours late is making a different decision from one who cooks when the guest is actually at the door.
The USDA page also says leftovers should be refrigerated within 2 hours of cooking and can be kept in the refrigerator for 3 to 4 days, which is a reason to plan smaller portions or a flexible menu when arrival times are uncertain.
What Dear Abby’s Column Is
Dear Abby has been running since 1956, when Pauline Phillips began it under the name Abigail Van Buren, according to Wikipedia’s entry on the column. Her daughter Jeanne Phillips announced her retirement on July 27, 2026. Recent columns are listed on the Inquirer’s Dear Abby author page.
A reply is one columnist’s take on one letter. Here, the take is practical: say when dinner will be served, and cook on time.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Silar – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons