Long before the turkey comes out of the oven, the holiday kitchen can turn into a negotiating table. Who brings which dish, whose recipe counts as the real one and who gets a seat at a crowded table are questions that have tested families for generations.
This November, those questions have been filling the mailbags of the country’s best-known advice columnists. Between Nov. 6 and Nov. 16, 2026, Miss Manners, Dear Annie and Dear Abby fielded at least 5 letters about holiday food and hosting, from a pasta salad that was turned away at the door to a brandy-soaked dessert that one relative wanted off the table. Here is what each letter described and how the columnists answered.

1. The Pasta Salad That Was ‘For a Picnic’
In a Miss Manners column published Nov. 13, a parent described plans to attend Thanksgiving at a daughter’s home, where 12 to 15 people were expected, including six of the son-in-law’s coworkers. According to the letter, the daughter usually asks guests about their dishes roughly 10 days ahead and then often assigns something different.
When the letter writer’s son offered to bring a pasta salad, the daughter replied, “That’s for a picnic,” and told him not to bring it. The son was hurt, and the parent asked whether he should save the dish for another time or skip bringing anything, since he works later that day.
Miss Manners, the column started by Judith Martin in 1978 according to her Wikipedia biography, sided with the second option: the son can skip bringing a dish, especially with work that day. She noted the daughter may still pick a fight, and suggested the family enjoy that pasta salad at an actual picnic another time. Hosts who want to keep the menu under control while keeping guests happy might find a few ideas in these simple etiquette tips for houseguests, which work from both sides of the door.
2. The Sister-in-Law’s Backup Batch
An earlier Miss Manners column on Nov. 6 came from a guest invited to Thanksgiving with a sister-in-law’s extended family. The guest had offered to bring a vegetable side and wondered whether a more flavorful take on potatoes or squash would go over well, or whether plainly boiled vegetables were the safer bet.
The writer also mentioned that the sister-in-law had, in the past, made her own second batch of a promised dish in case the guest forgot it, while admitting that detail might be unrelated. Miss Manners told the writer they were “overthinking this” and called the “mutually suspicious subtext of this relationship” fascinating. Her advice: once a dish is agreed on, bring the best version of it, and the host should trust that it will arrive.
Duplicate dishes are a familiar part of holiday potlucks, and families tend to have their own quirks around them. A list of strange Thanksgiving traditions everyone pretends are normal shows that the backup casserole is far from the oddest habit at the table.
3. One More Chair for a Roommate Named Sasha
In a Miss Manners column dated Nov. 7, a woman hosting Thanksgiving dinner for her sons, sisters and their adult children described a request from her niece to bring a roommate, Sasha, who could not travel home for the holiday. The host called the request “very nervy” and replied that seating in her townhouse was tight and that she would follow up.
According to the letter, the niece forwarded that reply to the host’s sister with the note “Really?!?” The sister then offered to host the dinner at her own home if the townhouse was too small. Miss Manners pointed out that the niece had asked politely and in a holiday spirit, and advised the host to find room for one more guest, both for family harmony and so that controlling is not the lasting impression she leaves.
Making space for someone with nowhere else to go is a long holiday tradition. One Georgia restaurant is doing it on a larger scale, as two Italian-born siblings plan to open on Thanksgiving evening to feed anyone spending the holiday alone. Hosts squeezing in an extra guest may also want to check a few things in the kitchen and guest bathroom before the crowd arrives.

4. A Mother-in-Law Who Insisted on Hosting
A Dear Annie column published Nov. 16, written by Annie Lane, came from a woman married almost 20 years. She wrote that when she suggested hosting Thanksgiving, her mother-in-law insisted it be at her own house, and her husband agreed without asking her. She also said the mother-in-law criticizes her cooking and housekeeping, and that her husband brushes off those comments.
Annie’s answer focused on the marriage rather than the menu. She cautioned the writer against turning the situation into a competition, suggested telling her husband that she admires his devotion to his mother but would like more uninterrupted time as a couple, and reminded her that he can make room for both women in his life. For a host who does get the oven to herself next time, a look at countertop appliances that free up the oven on Thanksgiving could make the big day easier.
5. The Brandy-Soaked Holiday Fruit
The same day, a Dear Abby column came from a home cook who brings desserts and brandy-soaked fruit to family gatherings and keeps the fruit out of children’s reach. One relative asked the cook to stop bringing it, because the relative’s kids keep asking why they cannot have any and the parent does not want to explain.
The cook felt some things are simply for adults, much like the adult punch of years past. Abby, the column founded in 1956 by Pauline Phillips according to Wikipedia, offered an easy fix: make a nonalcoholic version of the dish for children and any adults who do not drink, so everyone gets a taste of the holiday dessert.
Across all 5 letters, the columnists landed in a similar place. The food matters, but the holiday goes best when hosts and guests give each other a little room, whether that means one more chair, one fewer pasta salad or a second batch of fruit without the brandy.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Peachyeung316 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons