For years, the plan was simple. Everyone came home, the same roast went into the same oven, and the same chairs were pulled up to the same table. Then the kids grew up, got married and started families of their own, and suddenly the holiday meal had to be negotiated across two or three households.
Clinical psychotherapist Deanna Brann, author of the book Reluctantly Related, has 5 rules for parents in exactly that spot. In advice published by AARP, she tells parents to drop old assumptions, ask early and, when in doubt about an invitation, ask the open-ended question: “What day works best?”

Rule 1: Don’t Assume the Old Traditions Will Continue
Brann’s starting point is blunt. “Parents can’t assume that the traditions they’ve always had are going to continue,” she told AARP. Once a grown child marries, there is another family in the picture, with its own recipes, its own schedule and its own expectations about where the holiday meal happens.
Brann has studied this territory for years. According to her Psychwire profile, she is a licensed clinical psychotherapist with more than 30 years in the field, including more than 18 years in private practice, and she focuses on the relationship between mothers-in-law and daughters-in-law, offering coaching to both sides. Her books, listed on AbeBooks, include Reluctantly Related, a guide to getting along across the mother-in-law and daughter-in-law divide, and a follow-up, Reluctantly Related Revisited.
A separate AARP piece on old family dynamics during holiday visits, published in November 2022, makes a similar point about food itself. It notes that an adult son “may no longer eat those peanut-butter-and-jelly sandwiches he loved as a kid,” and encourages parents to get to know their children as the adults they have become. The same goes for the stuffing recipe or the holiday menu everyone once took for granted.
Rule 2: Ask Newlyweds Well in Advance
For couples celebrating their first holidays as a married pair, Brann suggests asking well ahead of time whether they have thought about how they want to spend the holidays together. Parents should expect newlyweds to make their own plans, she told AARP, rather than waiting to be slotted into the old routine.
Asking early also helps with the practical side of a holiday meal: who is cooking, how many seats are needed and whether anyone is traveling. Holiday flights fill quickly, and a look at the busiest Thanksgiving travel days this year shows why a couple juggling two sets of parents may need to lock in plans weeks ahead. Plenty of families are already sorting out luggage for the whole family’s holiday trips or looking for ways to skip the checked-bag fee this Thanksgiving.
AARP described one mother, Debbie, who has four sons in their 30s. Two are married with young children and live hours away, while two unmarried sons live nearby. Her family starts holiday planning in October through group emails and texts, and the celebration stretches across Christmas week, with the family gathering in different combinations rather than all at once.
Rule 3: Ask ‘What Day Works Best?’
Once grandchildren arrive, the question of who hosts the big meal often shifts. When parents are unsure whether they are invited, Brann suggests an open-ended approach: tell the couple how much they would love to come over, then ask, “What day works best?”
The question removes pressure from a specific date. Christmas dinner, as Wikipedia’s entry on the meal notes, can be held anytime from Christmas Eve through the evening of Christmas Day, and many families already stretch the feast across several days. A turkey on the 26th or a ham on the 23rd tastes every bit as good. Guests who travel to a grown child’s home can also brush up on simple etiquette tips for being a good houseguest, since the roles have flipped.
.jpg?width=1600)
Rule 4: Respect Their Right to New Traditions
Brann speaks from experience here. She told AARP that her own son and his wife asked her and the other grandparents to arrive later on Christmas Day so the couple could spend the morning with their children. “Adult children have the right to create their own traditions, and parents need to be respectful of that,” she said.
That may mean a new menu, a new host or a meal at a different hour. It may also mean a grandparent’s role shifts from running the kitchen to bringing a favorite side dish or dessert. Grandparents still have plenty to pass along in that new role, and a list of things grandchildren need to hear from their grandparents is a reminder that the stories told around the table matter as much as who cooked the bird.
Rule 5: Don’t Take a Missed Day Personally
The last rule is the hardest for many parents. Brann’s advice to AARP is not to take it personally when adult children are not there on a specific day. With in-laws, work schedules and young children in the mix, a missed Thanksgiving or Christmas dinner is usually about logistics, not love.
Debbie’s family shows how that can work in practice. According to AARP, she and her husband defer to their children and do not expect everyone to come home on a set day. The table may be set more than once and with different faces each time, but the holiday still happens, one shared meal at a time.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Helena Jacoba – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons