The first hard frost has a way of arriving overnight. One evening the basil by the garden gate looks fine, and by morning the leaves are limp and dark, while the chives next to them stand up as if nothing happened.
That split is the point of a guide from North Carolina State Extension. Its herb table shows chives, mints, sage and thyme among the hardy herbs, and says annuals such as basil, dill and lemongrass are killed by the first hard frost. That makes 4 kitchen herbs worth leaving in the ground through a cold November, and several that are done once the freeze arrives.

1. Chives
NC State Extension’s Winterizing the Herb Garden was first published on Jan. 31, 1999 and last revised on Dec. 13, 2024. It says that mulch alone protects mint, chives and fennel, “providing protection to minus 20°F.” Chives sit in the hardy part of its table, alongside garlic chives. According to Wikipedia’s entry on chives, the plant is a perennial that is widespread across much of Eurasia and North America, and the only Allium species native to both the New World and the Old World.
The University of Georgia’s Mulch Improves Herbs’ Winter Survival, by horticulturist Wayne McLaurin, repeats the minus 20 degree figure for organic mulch such as pine straw, hardwood bark or a bark-sawdust mix. The article is dated Nov. 20, 2000 and was last modified on Oct. 23, 2025, so its advice has been on the books for a long time.
2. Mint
Mint shares the same minus 20°F mulch protection in both guides, and NC State lists mints among the hardy herbs for the Mountains, Piedmont and Coastal Plain regions. A 2-to-3-inch layer of mulch during the growing season is the starting point, according to the NC State page, with 3 to 6 inches added after the first hard freeze.
Illinois Extension’s Garden Scoop blog, in a Nov. 2, 2019 post, adds that mint, parsley, sage, thyme, oregano and rosemary have some cold tolerance and can still be harvested after the first frost. That post is about central Illinois, where it puts the median first frost in mid-October and a hard freeze below 28°F around Nov. 1, so timing will differ elsewhere.
Anyone planning a winter patch might also browse elevated garden beds for fall greens and herbs, which looks at growing into the cold months, and how to grow lavender from seed for another hardy herb.
3. Sage
Sage (Salvia officinalis) appears in the NC State table as hardy in all three North Carolina regions, with the comment “Lightly mulch; provide wind protection.” The page also gives a timing rule for cutting. In western North Carolina, the last severe cutting on sage, lavender or oregano should come before early September, and the University of Georgia guide gives the same early-September cutoff for north Georgia.
Illinois Extension calls sage a perennial and recommends limiting fall cutting, since heavy harvesting late in the season can weaken the plant for winter. It suggests sage cuttings of 6 to 8 inches. The practical takeaway is to leave late-fall sage mostly alone, with a few leaves picked for the stuffing pan rather than a hard haircut. 13 worst garden pests and how to get rid of them covers another end-of-season gardening topic.
Garden chores often stack up this time of year, and 5 steps to get a lawn mower ready for winter storage covers another seasonal task, while an Italian farmer’s attic seeds that grew a wheat plant with 7 ears is a reminder that gardens can surprise.

4. Thyme
Thyme is the fourth hardy herb on the list, and the NC State table shows it hardy in the same three regions. The same page warns that after a severe winter, some outdoor plants, including rue, sage, thyme and southernwood, may look brown and dead, so a tired-looking plant in January is not always finished.
The University of Georgia article says silver and lemon thyme foliage can be protected from drying out with evergreen boughs. It also says cooks should avoid fertilizing herbs after early August and should not severely prune woody plants within 4 to 6 weeks of the first severe freeze.
What does not make it: basil, dill and lemongrass
NC State’s page is blunt about the other side of the ledger. Annual herbs “will be killed with the first hard frost in the fall,” and its table lists basil, coriander, dill and lemongrass among the tender annuals. Wikipedia’s entry on basil calls it a tender plant that is sensitive to cold and says it grows best in hot, dry conditions, which is why seedlings are usually planted out only after the chance of frost has passed.
The Illinois post makes a similar point about timing, noting that basil left unharvested by then is “certainly too late.” Wikipedia adds that basil can also be grown indoors in a pot, doing best on a sun-facing windowsill kept away from cold drafts.
Some herbs sit in the middle. NC State lists rosemary, marjoram, hyssop and lemon verbena as tender perennials, hardy only in some regions, and the University of Georgia says rosemary and lemon verbena are not reliably winter-hardy north of Atlanta. Illinois Extension suggests potting rosemary and moving it to a bright, cool indoor spot before freezing temperatures arrive.
Before the next freeze
All three extension sources agree on mulch. NC State advises 3 to 6 inches of winter mulch after the first hard freeze, with 4 to 5 inches for rosemary and lemon verbena, and a hardware cloth or chicken wire cage about 12 inches wider than the plant for extra holding power. The University of Georgia adds that mulching too heavily before cold weather can keep soil warmer and may reduce winter hardiness, so the heavy layer belongs after the first hard freeze.
The ratings come from southern and midwestern extension sources, and local conditions vary by county, elevation and microclimate. A gardener in a colder region should check the local extension office for its own frost dates and hardiness zone before counting on any herb to last the winter. The sources here describe general guidance, and the dates of the pages are shown above so readers can judge how current each one is.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Syrio – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons