Most families have a dish that only appears once a year, carried in on the same platter by the same relative. For some, it is a sweet potato casserole. For others, it is a tin of rum balls or a fruitcake that has been soaking since October.
One such family tradition is now at the center of a holiday standoff. In a Dear Abby column published November 16, 2026, a home cook who brings brandy-soaked fruit and desserts to family holidays wrote that one relative wants the dish off the table, and columnist Abigail Van Buren suggested a simple fix: make a nonalcoholic version too.

The Letter: Brandied Fruit Kept Out of Reach
The reader, who signed the letter “ADULTS ONLY,” told Dear Abby about a love of making holiday desserts and fruit soaked in brandy for family gatherings. According to the column, as carried by Arcamax, the desserts are a hit with the adults and are kept well out of the children’s reach.
The problem is one relative. That person has asked the reader not to bring the brandied fruit at all, saying their children keep asking why they cannot have any and that they feel uncomfortable explaining it. The relative’s view, as the reader described it, is that nothing on the table should be off-limits to the kids.
The reader disagrees, recalling that while growing up, there was always an adult punch and a few other things children simply did not get, and sees adult-only desserts as a normal part of family life. The letter also says the hosts seem anxious to avoid a rift, and it asks Abby whether to go along with the request or use it as a teaching moment for the children.
Disagreements like this one tend to surface around holiday meals, when several households share one table. A list of ways couples keep holiday disagreements from turning into big arguments covers some of the same ground.
Dear Abby’s Answer: Make a Second Version
Abby’s reply was practical. She wrote that the simplest solution would be to prepare a nonalcoholic version of the dish and serve it to any minors, or adults who do not drink, who show an interest. That way, the children get something that looks like what the grown-ups are eating, and nobody has to explain why one bowl is off-limits.
She also added a lighthearted line suggesting that the objecting parent might be well placed to explain modern social norms to their own children. The Chicago Sun-Times ran the same column on November 16, 2026, under the headline “Holiday desserts for grown-ups spark controversy.”
Dear Abby has handled holiday etiquette questions like this one for decades. According to the Dear Abby Wikipedia entry, the column was founded in 1956 by Pauline Phillips under the pen name Abigail Van Buren and is now written by her daughter, Jeanne Phillips. It is distributed by Andrews McMeel Syndication, according to Arcamax. For hosts bracing for a full house, a few home checks to finish before holiday houseguests arrive can make the day run more smoothly.
Both Sides of the Holiday Table
The reader’s position has deep roots in holiday cooking. Fruit preserved in brandy, rum or other spirits has long been part of winter baking, and the fruitcake Wikipedia entry notes that many fruitcakes are soaked in spirits such as brandy. Brandy itself, as the brandy Wikipedia entry explains, is distilled from wine and has a long history in desserts, sauces and preserved fruit. To the reader, a bowl of brandied fruit for the grown-ups is no different from the adult punch of years past.
The relative’s position is also easy to recognize. Parents of young children often find that a dish the kids cannot have becomes the only dish they want, and repeated questions at a crowded table can wear thin. For that parent, removing the dish may feel simpler than answering the same question every year.
Abby’s middle path keeps the tradition while giving the children something of their own. Families looking for more ways to keep the peace with a full house can find ideas in a list of simple etiquette tips for being the perfect houseguest.

How a Nonalcoholic Version Works in the Kitchen
For cooks who want to follow Abby’s advice, a kid-friendly batch is not hard to make alongside the original. Dried and fresh fruit can be steeped in apple cider, orange juice, grape juice or a spiced syrup instead of brandy, which keeps the plump, glossy look of the adult dish. A splash of vanilla or a cinnamon stick can add some of the warmth that the spirit would normally bring.
Clear labeling helps too. Serving the two versions in different bowls, or marking them with small cards, means guests can tell them apart at a glance. Some families set the adult version on a separate dessert board, the same way a punch bowl for grown-ups was once set apart from the children’s drinks. Hosts planning the rest of the evening might add a few Christmas party games so the kids have something else to focus on.
Dishes like this are often the ones that carry the most family memory, much like the foods from the 1960s that many boomers still love. Keeping the original recipe while adding a version for the kids lets the tradition continue for another generation, and it may spare the hosts the rift they are hoping to avoid.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Globetrotter19 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons