For plenty of families, the first real sign of the holidays is not a falling leaf or a pumpkin pie. It is the phone call that starts with a casual question about Thanksgiving plans and ends with somebody feeling left out.
That tug-of-war is at the center of a Dear Annie column published Nov. 4, 2026, from a wife who signed her letter “Torn Between Two Turkeys.” She and her husband have been married 12 years, have two children ages 7 and 10, and, she wrote, start arguing every October over whose family gets them for Thanksgiving dinner.

Two grandparent households, one turkey dinner
According to the Dear Annie column on ArcaMax, both sets of grandparents live about an hour away, and both expect the family at their table on Thanksgiving. The letter writer’s mother starts asking about plans weeks ahead, cooks a huge dinner and genuinely loves having the grandchildren around. When the family does not come, the writer said, her mother lets the hurt show with remarks about having a quiet holiday without the kids.
Her husband’s side feels just as strongly. His mother sees Thanksgiving as the one holiday when the whole family gathers, and his father recently reminded him that the grandparents will not be around forever.
Holiday food traditions run deep in families, which helps explain why the stakes feel so high. A recent look at stuffing as the favorite Thanksgiving side in 38 states shows how attached people are to the dishes they grew up with, and many families have rituals that seem perfectly normal at home, as Frenz Hub’s list of Thanksgiving traditions everyone pretends are not weird points out.
The lunch-and-dinner plan that backfired
The couple has tried the usual fixes. Alternating years left whichever side was not hosting feeling cheated, the letter said. Splitting the day, with Thanksgiving lunch at one house and dinner at the other, turned into what the writer described as a marathon of driving, too much food and cranky children. Last year, the youngest child cried in the car because she was tired of rushing from one house to the next.
The disagreement has started to spill into the marriage itself. The writer said her husband thinks she gives in too easily to her mother’s guilt trips, while she believes he gives in just as easily to his parents. A conversation about turkey, she wrote, ends up as an argument over whose family comes first.
She was clear that she loves both families and knows the children are lucky to have grandparents who want them around. Still, she admitted to dreading a holiday meant to be about gratitude, and to sometimes daydreaming about staying home in pajamas, ordering pizza and watching the parade. That would be the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade, a fixture of the holiday morning for more than a century.
Families who do hit the road for the holiday know how much the travel itself can wear on everyone. Frenz Hub’s guide to carry-on suitcases for Thanksgiving trips is one way to make the trip a little lighter.

Both sides of the family have understandable reasons for wanting the day. For the grandparents, a full table on Thanksgiving is often the payoff for weeks of shopping, brining and baking. For the younger couple, the day is also about giving their own children a holiday that feels relaxed rather than rushed. Whoever ends up hosting, a few of the basics in Frenz Hub’s etiquette tips for being a good houseguest can make the visiting side easier on everyone.
Annie Lane’s answer: decide as a couple
Annie Lane, whose column is distributed by Creators Syndicate, started with sympathy for the grandparents. It makes sense that both sides want time with their grandchildren, she wrote, and as grandparents get older, those gatherings become even more precious.
But Lane was firm that nobody can make everyone happy, especially at the cost of the couple’s own family peace. Her advice, as published on Creators.com, was for the wife and her husband to sit down together and agree on a plan, whether that means alternating years, hosting everyone or starting a tradition of their own. Hosting comes with its own to-do list, and a guide to fridge and freezer checks before the big Thanksgiving grocery run is a good place for a first-time host to start.
Once the plan is set, Lane said, the couple should be “loving but firm” with the grandparents and remind them they are cherished even in a year when the family is not at their table. The holiday, she concluded, is about being thankful for family, not keeping score over who gets the turkey.
Other families have landed on similar fixes
The column’s advice echoes what family experts have told AARP. In an AARP article on juggling family holiday traditions, psychotherapist Deanna Brann said parents of grown children cannot assume long-standing holiday routines will continue, and that adult children have the right to create their own traditions.
The same article described a mother of four grown sons whose family starts planning the holidays in October and gathers in different combinations at different homes, so the celebration stretches across the season instead of hinging on a single day.
For a couple caught between two loving, insistent families, a turkey of their own, with both sets of grandparents invited and the parade on in the background, might be the compromise that finally ends the October argument.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Mark Miller – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons