The cart is nearly full, the line at the registers is long, and a giant tray of something frozen sits at the end of the aisle, tempting a shopper who has already spent a lot. Costco rewards bulk buyers, but a big package is a bigger regret when the food inside disappoints.
Tasting Table published a list on May 23, 2026, of 9 groceries that Costco customers say are not worth the money. The list is built on shopper opinion from Reddit threads and Costco’s own reviews, not on lab tests or prices, so it is best read as a skip list drawn from complaints. The 9 items are below, from orange chicken to cold brew.

Crazy Cuizine Mandarin Orange Chicken
Orange chicken is a Chinese-American classic. According to Wikipedia, Panda Express says its executive chef Andy Kao developed the original recipe around 1987. Tasting Table says many customers now think shoppers are better off with Trader Joe’s or Panda Express than with Costco’s Crazy Cuizine version.
One Redditor quoted by Tasting Table wrote that the quality “has definitely decreased over the years,” and another said it is “mostly breading” now. Some commenters guessed shrinkflation, a term Wikipedia defines as a reduction in package size or quantity while prices stay the same.
Kirkland Signature Breakfast Sandwich
The Kirkland Signature Breakfast Sandwich has long been one of the store’s popular items, per Tasting Table. Recent complaints are about a croissant described as dense and chewy, thinner bacon and less of it, and a slim slice of cheese. One Redditor said the sandwich is smaller, “so small that my air fryer now blows the two halves around.”
Shoppers who love a quick morning routine can pair a frozen sandwich with ideas from this breakfast station roundup, or look at the coffee bar ideas that make a rushed morning feel less rushed.
Tamales
A tamale is a traditional Mesoamerican dish made of masa, a dough from nixtamalized corn, steamed in a corn husk or banana leaves. Tasting Table says Costco carries pork, beef and chicken tamales from Texas Tamale Co., and that customers call them dry and lacking in flavor.
A Redditor in a comment with more than 370 upvotes said they used to be much better years ago and are now “80% masa corn.” Costco also stocks Del Real Foods tamales, which one website reviewer called grainy. Tasting Table’s advice: try a Mexican restaurant, or make them from scratch.
Magic Spoon Cereal
Tasting Table says the problem with Magic Spoon is texture and value. Some customers say it sticks to their teeth, others call it overpriced (a worry for households sharing a grocery budget, as in these steps for a joint budget meeting), and one Redditor described it as “cereal made by people who hate cereal.” A Tasting Table taste tester also ranked the Grain-Free Cinnamon Roll flavor last among 13 cereals in a 2023 ranking, citing a chemical-like flavor and a “disturbingly soft” texture.

Bananas
Bananas seem the same everywhere, but Tasting Table cites a Reddit comment with nearly 180 upvotes saying Costco bananas “go straight from dark green to brown.” Others agreed they had seen the same pattern. Some shoppers blunt the problem by freezing the fruit for smoothies or baking banana bread, though that does not help someone who wants a fresh banana snack.
Bulk produce is a classic place for waste, and shoppers sorting out what is worth buying can compare this list of grocery items not worth buying with these frugal living tips.
Snapdragon Chicken Pad Thai
Pad thai is typically made with rice noodles, shrimp, peanuts, green onions, egg, sugar and bean sprouts, per Wikipedia. Tasting Table reports that customers say Costco’s Snapdragon Chicken Pad Thai lacks peanuts, has no spice and tastes bland.
One Redditor called it “probably the worst rendition” of the dish seen, in a comment with more than 620 upvotes. A separate, more colorful comment drew nearly 2,000 upvotes, which Tasting Table took as a sign the opinion is common.
Anything From Kevin’s Natural Foods
Tasting Table says customers name Kevin’s Natural Foods as the one refrigerated meal brand to avoid, describing the food as bland and flavorless. One Redditor wrote that they could not make the Korean BBQ-style beef edible, and joked that even the dog looked disappointed with the second package.
Kirkland Signature Cold Brew
Tasting Table notes that many Americans prefer their coffee iced and that cold brew can be made at home, but Tasting Table says customers do not rate Kirkland Signature’s canned version. People describe it as watery with an acidic taste. One Redditor, in a comment with more than 420 upvotes, wrote that boiling hot battery acid would be preferable to another can. Others were milder but still called it drinkable at best.
Anything From Realgood Foods Co.
The last item is another prepared-meal brand. Customers quoted by Tasting Table say the nuggets are woody and the flavor is chemical-like, and one Redditor reported having to spit out a burrito from the brand. Tasting Table’s own reviewers have been mixed: a frozen Chinese-food ranking in February 2025 placed the Orange Chicken Bowl seventh, while another frozen dinner ranking placed it third of eight.
The same article says taste is subjective and that readers may disagree. Costco, per Wikipedia, is a membership-only warehouse club, so the cost of a disappointing purchase includes the size of the package.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: BrokenSphere – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons