9 Christmas Dishes Rarely Seen Anymore, From Jell-O Ribbon Salad to Creamed Pearl Onions, Food Republic Says

Somewhere at the far end of a holiday buffet, a wobbly red-and-green dish used to sit beside the rolls, and nobody questioned it. Many tables now skip it, and a few other once-standard dishes with it.

Food Republic’s Sophie Morelli looked at 9 Christmas dishes rarely seen anymore in a list dated December 1, 2025, from Jell-O ribbon salad to creamed pearl onions. Here is each dish, with some background from other sources on why it slipped off the table.

A roast goose on a serving platter
Jürgen Howaldt – CC BY-SA 2.0 de/Wikimedia Commons

Jell-O Ribbon Salad

The layered red, green and white gelatin salad was popular in the 1950s and 1960s, according to Food Republic, before fading from menus. Cooks once built the layers one at a time, letting each set before pouring the next, a patient process that suited the era. Jell-O itself dates to 1897, when Pearle Bixby Wait trademarked it in LeRoy, New York, and Wikipedia’s history of the brand notes that by the Jazz Age nearly a third of salad recipes in an average cookbook were gelatin-based.

Roast Goose

Roast goose was once the holiday centerpiece, the bird that anchored the table long before a turkey became the default, as much a part of an old-fashioned holiday as the vintage Christmas decorations that still come out of attic boxes. It lost ground to turkey and ham because it seemed hard to cook well, Food Republic reports. In Germany it remains a staple of Christmas Day meals, and Wikipedia’s roast goose entry notes that turkey generally replaces goose in the United States.

Holiday Ham Balls

Sweet-glazed baked meatballs made from ground ham were born in Iowa and were once common at church potlucks, according to Food Republic. The dish is a reminder of the era when a covered dish and a serving spoon were all a gathering needed, the way children once looked forward to the 5 things kids did with the Sears Wish Book before Christmas, much like the 11 things nearly every 1960s kitchen had.

Cranberry Fluff Salad

This Midwestern dessert combines Cool Whip, cranberries and marshmallows, and it could be made ahead, so it could wait in the refrigerator while the rest of dinner came together. Make-ahead recipes were prized when the oven was busy with the main course, a problem still familiar to home cooks who lean on easy-to-use helpers at home or read a list of clever kitchen tricks before a big dinner.

Potato Candy

Potato candy is a Depression-era sweet of mashed potatoes, powdered sugar and peanut butter, valued for its cheap ingredients, per Food Republic. The candy used what a pantry already held, and a few spoonfuls of peanut butter made it feel like a holiday sweet. Wikipedia calls it a no-bake, rolled confection from the Appalachian region, chilled to firm up and rolled into a swirled log, and says it seems popular only in the United States.

A molded cranberry gelatin salad
Shadle – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons

Creamed Pearl Onions

A nutmeg-spiced cream sauce over tiny onions was once a fancy English and New England holiday side. It fell out of favor because the onions are hard to peel, Food Republic says. Pearl onions are small and sweeter than common onions, and they are mostly used for pickling, which helps explain why peeling dozens of them for one side dish feels like a lot of work.

Oyster Stew

The simple East Coast Christmas Eve dish of oysters, milk, butter and spices declined as oysters became less plentiful, according to Food Republic. Wikipedia’s oyster stew page offers two explanations for the Southern tradition: cold weather needed for shipping was not reliable until December, so oysters reached inland markets around Christmas Eve, or Irish Catholic immigrants adapted a Christmas Eve ling stew.

Chestnut Stuffing

Stuffing made with chestnuts disappeared after a fungus wiped out the American chestnut tree, Food Republic notes. The chestnut blight was first found in the United States around 1905 and is estimated to have killed about four billion trees, leaving the nuts scarce for kitchens. For stuffing, that meant cooks turned to bread, sausage, herbs and apples instead, and the chestnut version slipped from family recipe cards.

Rutabaga Mash

This winter root vegetable, mashed with cream and butter, was overshadowed by the potato. The rutabaga hasn’t vanished everywhere, though. Wikipedia lists rutabaga dishes at Finnish and Norwegian Christmas tables, including Finland’s lanttulaatikko casserole, and neeps and tatties at Scotland’s Burns supper.

Why dishes fade from the holiday table

Looked at together, each of the nine disappeared for its own reason: a hard-to-find ingredient, a fussy technique, a changing taste or a smaller crowd. Families that still serve one of them often say the dish stays because someone remembers it from a grandparent’s table, and the same pull keeps vintage ornaments alive.

Readers who still serve one of these dishes are in good company, and the oldest recipes tend to survive in a handful of families. Menus vary by region and household, and some of these dishes remain standards in certain families. As of November 18, 2026, the list reflects Food Republic’s 2025 reporting rather than a new survey of home cooks.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Myotus – CC BY 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *