8 Things to Leave on the Shelf at the Grocery Store, From Deeply Dented Cans and Loose Jar Lids to Eggs With Cracks and Frozen Food That Isn’t Solid

Picture a shopper at the end of a canned-goods aisle a week before Thanksgiving, turning a can of pumpkin purée in one hand. A dent runs along the rim, and the price sticker is a few cents lower than the neighbors. Pantry shelves fill fast this time of year, and damaged packaging sneaks into carts more often than anyone admits.

Eight things belong back on the shelf: a deeply dented can, a can dented on a seam, a bulging, leaking or heavily rusted can, a jar with a loose lid, an egg carton with cracked shells, frozen food that is not solid, a package with a tear or hole, and a refrigerated item that does not feel cold. The rules come from the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service, Ready.gov, and university extension guidance, and each one takes only a few seconds at the shelf.

Rows of canned beans lined up on a grocery store shelf
Born to Barnacle – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

Cans With Deep Dents, Seam Dents or Bulges (Skips 1 to 3)

Skip 1: the deeply dented can. USDA’s food safety staff define a deep dent as one a finger can be laid into, and the agency’s advice is blunt: discard deeply dented cans. A small dent on an otherwise sound can is a different matter, according to the same page, which says such food should be fine.

Skip 2: the can dented on a seam. The USDA page says any can with a deep dent on a seam should go. The eatright.org shopping page explains that a sharp dent can damage a seam and let bacteria into the can. The MSU Extension bulletin Keeping Foods Safe Before and During Shopping, written by Laurie Messing and dated October 24, 2022, lists dents on the top or side seam alongside deep dents as cans to leave behind.

Skip 3: the bulging, leaking or heavily rusted can. USDA says not to purchase bulging, rusted, leaking or deeply dented cans, and to discard swollen ones. Light surface rust that rubs off with a finger or paper towel is called minor, while heavy rust is not. Cans that do get discarded should be double-bagged in tightly closed plastic and placed in outdoor trash that is not recycled, per the same agency page.

The emergency-pantry crowd gets the same message from Ready.gov, which says food from swollen, dented or corroded cans should not be eaten even when it looks fine. Shoppers stocking a storm shelf for winter can make the dent test step one. A recent look at seasonal storage habits covers where all those cans end up once they are home, and a roundup of storage hacks for small spaces helps with fitting them into a crowded pantry. A separate post on items not worth buying at the grocery store makes the money side of the same argument.

A Jar With a Loose Lid (Skip 4)

A jar of cranberry sauce or pickles should feel sealed. A shopping-safety page at eatright.org says a loose lid means the vacuum is gone and the product may be contaminated. It also says to pass on any product whose seal looks tampered with or damaged, and to report a defective cap to the store manager.

USDA’s page adds jars with cracks or bulging lids to the list of containers whose food should never be used, and it says not to taste suspect food to check it. The lid test costs nothing, and a jar that fails it goes back. Jars cover the shelf half of stocking up, and a guide to freezing fresh green beans covers the freezer half. A recent list of fridge and freezer checks before the big grocery run covers what to clear out at home first.

Open freezer cabinet stocked with packaged frozen food
Leon Brooks – Public domain/Wikimedia Commons

Egg Cartons With Cracks (Skip 5)

USDA’s shell-egg guidance says to always purchase eggs from a refrigerated case, and never to purchase cracked eggs, because bacteria can enter through cracks in the shell. The eatright.org page adds that the carton should be opened at the shelf to confirm the eggs are clean and not cracked. Thanksgiving baking can call for a dozen eggs in a single weekend, so the check pays off.

USDA says to store eggs immediately in a refrigerator set at 40°F or below. A carton with a cracked shell stays on the shelf.

Frozen Food That Is Not Solid (Skip 6)

The eatright.org page says frozen foods should be solid with no signs of thawing. For frozen seafood, it says to avoid packages with ice crystals, which signal that the product has thawed before. A bag of frozen rolls or pie crusts that feels soft or has shifted into a clump may have been through a warm spell on the way to the case.

MSU Extension’s bulletin suggests saving frozen and refrigerated items for the end of the trip, so they spend the shortest time out of the cold. It says to refrigerate perishables within two hours, or within one hour when the outdoor temperature is above 90°F, and recommends a cooler with ice packs in the car for long drives home.

Torn Packages and Warm Cases (Skips 7 and 8)

Skip 7: the package with a hole, tear or opening. The eatright.org page says there should be no holes, tears or openings in food packages. For raw meat, it says the packaging should be tightly sealed and very cold to the touch, and packaged seafood should be sealed and free of dents and tears.

Skip 8: the refrigerated item that does not feel cold. The same page says refrigerated foods should feel cold, and that dairy cartons and containers should be cold when picked up. A warm milk jug or a tepid package of sliced deli turkey goes back, and the shopper can mention it to a store employee so the case gets checked.

MSU Extension also notes that sell-by and use-by dates are manufacturer quality guidance, not always safety limits. That is why a package that looks fine and carries a good date can still be a skip if it feels warm or has an opening.

Those eight checks take a minute, and a cart that passes them is ready for the checkout lane.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Krzysztof Golik – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *