The covered dish that comes home from a Friendsgiving potluck is usually the one nobody planned to see again. It is half a bowl of macaroni salad, a serving spoon still standing in it, wrapped in foil on the back seat.
The question that follows is how long that bowl stays worth eating. According to the cold food storage chart on FoodSafety.gov, egg, chicken, ham, tuna and macaroni salads keep 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator, and the same chart says they do not freeze well.

Egg Salad: The Sandwich Filling With a Short Clock
Counting 3 to 4 days from the day a salad is made or bought is the simplest habit, rather than from the day the lid comes off. A tub bought on Monday is on its last day by Thursday, which matters for anyone planning the long Thanksgiving week of shared dishes and half-eaten trays, a week with its own share of strange Thanksgiving traditions.
Egg salad is a simple mix of chopped hard-boiled eggs, mayonnaise and mustard, often with celery and onion, according to Wikipedia’s entry on the dish. One of the earliest printed egg salad sandwich recipes appeared in the 1896 edition of Fannie Farmer’s Boston Cooking-School Cook Book, per the same entry.
More than a century later, the handling rule is the one on the federal chart: 3 to 4 days cold, and no freezer. Mayonnaise-bound salads commonly turn watery once frozen and thawed, a texture problem more than a time limit. Anyone who wants a sandwich later in the week can keep the boiled eggs whole and chop a fresh batch. A nostalgic list of things that were in nearly every 1980s kitchen makes a fun detour while the leftovers chill.
Chicken Salad and Ham Salad Run on the Same Clock
Chicken salad and ham salad share the egg salad window. FoodSafety.gov lists both at 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator and gives the same answer on freezing. A tub of chicken salad from a grocery deli on a Sunday should be finished or tossed by Wednesday or Thursday at the latest.
The simplest way to keep track is a strip of masking tape on the lid with the date it was made. A short zodiac list of signs said to be great at cooking for others is a lighthearted nod to the person who always packs the leftovers, and that person usually owns the masking tape. Holiday kitchens fill fast, and a plain label saves the guessing game when three containers look alike. A roundup of clever storage hacks offers more ideas for squeezing a crowded refrigerator into order.
USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service adds a general rule in its leftovers guidance: perishable food should be refrigerated within 2 hours of cooking, and cold food should be kept at 40°F or below. A salad that sat on a buffet table through an entire football game is past that line.

Tuna Salad: Cheap Pantry Cans, Short Fridge Life
Tuna salad starts with a shelf-stable can and ends up one of the shortest-lived items in the refrigerator. Wikipedia’s entry on tuna salad traces the first written reference to Russia in 1876 and notes that dozens of recipes were in print by 1893, helped along by the convenience of canned tuna.
The canned fish itself can sit in the pantry for a long stretch. Once the tuna is mixed with mayonnaise, the clock resets to the same 3 to 4 days as every other salad on the chart. Shoppers watching the grocery bill may want to make a week of lunches from one batch, and a few frugal living tips make the same point about planning portions so that nothing gets tossed.
A practical approach is to mix only what will be eaten in 3 days and leave the rest of the can, still unopened, for next week.
Macaroni Salad: The Deli Staple That Travels Badly
Macaroni salad is the dish most likely to ride in a car for an hour and then sit on a counter. Wikipedia describes it as a deli staple, usually elbow macaroni with mayonnaise, onion, pickles and celery, and dates an early recipe to a 1916 cookbook, Salads, Sandwiches and Chafing Dish Recipes, as cited on its macaroni salad page.
The same page notes plenty of regional spins. Hawaiian plate lunches pair it with soft-cooked macaroni and grated onion, while in the Philippines a sweet version with fruit and cheese turns up at Christmas and New Year’s parties. Whatever the style, the federal chart handles all of them alike: 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator.
A potluck host who wants to send guests home with leftovers can portion the salad into small lidded containers while it is still cold. Small containers chill faster, and the 2-hour clock keeps running on any bowl left out on a table.
Why the Freezer Is the Wrong Place for All 5
The chart says it plainly for the whole salad group: does not freeze well. FoodSafety.gov notes elsewhere on the page that freezer times are for quality only, since food held at 0°F stays safe indefinitely, so the note on salads reads as a quality call rather than a safety deadline. Mayonnaise, cooked pasta and chopped egg rarely come back from the freezer the way they went in.
That makes the plan for leftover salad simple. Eat it within 3 to 4 days, send it home in small containers, or skip making the extra batch. A spoonful of the old filling can go into a fresh sandwich on day 2 or 3, but a half-empty bowl found at the back of the shelf on day 5 belongs in the trash.
With Thanksgiving on November 26, the 3 to 4 day count is worth writing on the lid of every bowl that comes into the house.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: 些細な日常 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons