Every December, a tub of fluffy, sweet batter shows up in the refrigerator and freezer cases of grocery stores across the Upper Midwest and northern Plains. It is Tom and Jerry batter, the base for a hot, eggnog-style holiday drink, and the pre-made versions sold in regional supermarkets typically come from manufacturers in Wisconsin, Minnesota, the Dakotas and Montana.
Outside that corner of the country, the drink is often unknown, or confused with the cartoon cat and mouse. Inside it, the batter is a seasonal grocery item that appears for the holidays and disappears again after the new year. Here is what the drink is, where the name came from, and how the batter is handled safely at home.

What a Tom and Jerry is
The Tom and Jerry is a traditional Christmas-season cocktail in the United States and a variant of eggnog. It is built from eggs, powdered sugar, brandy, rum, hot milk or hot water, and a dusting of nutmeg, with some recipes adding vanilla. It is served hot, usually in a mug or a bowl, and the mug is the standard vessel.
The texture is what sets it apart. As the Wisconsin Rapids Daily Tribune explained in a roundup of the holiday foods that make Christmas in Wisconsin tick, the egg whites in the batter are beaten repeatedly, which gives the finished drink a light, fluffy body that eggnog does not have. A spoonful of batter goes into a mug, then hot water, rum and brandy are added. For a version without alcohol, the same article suggests warm milk or tea in place of the spirits.
The drink has the same nostalgic pull as the dishes in this list of foods most boomers loved with a passion, and it often sits on the same counter as the slow cookers and casserole dishes in this look at 1970s kitchen staples like the Crock-Pot and Pyrex.
Where the batter comes from
Old holiday routines like this one keep resurfacing, much like the ones in this list of boomer habits making a comeback. Making the batter from scratch means separating eggs, beating the whites until stiff, mixing the yolks with sugar and folding everything together. Pre-made batter skips that work, which is the whole appeal of the seasonal tubs. According to the Tom and Jerry entry, the tubs are typically produced by manufacturers in Wisconsin, Minnesota, the Dakotas and Montana and sold in regional supermarkets during the Christmas season.
Two brands are named there: Connolly’s Tom and Jerry Batter from Superior, Wisconsin, and Mrs. Bowen’s Tom and Jerry Mix, also from Wisconsin. A college food site, Spoon University, likewise describes pre-made batter as a Wisconsin and Minnesota product sold in regional stores, and gives a simple ratio of about 1 tablespoon of batter to 1 cup of hot water with rum or brandy. A non-alcoholic mug can be made with 1 cup of hot milk, hot chocolate or eggnog stirred with the same spoonful of batter.
Milwaukee has a particular attachment to the drink. Bryant’s Cocktail Lounge there sets aside a Tom and Jerry room in December, where the drink is the only thing on the menu. In those northern states, the season brings plenty of cold weather for a hot mug, as these almanac winter outlooks for the Midwest and Great Lakes suggest. The batter is also sold seasonally around Jamestown, New York, an area with strong Swedish roots. Hosts planning a December gathering around a batch of mugs can borrow ideas from these Christmas party games.

A name from 1821 London, and a president’s party
The name has nothing to do with the cartoon. It refers to Pierce Egan, a British writer and boxing journalist whose 1821 book Life in London followed two characters named Tom and Jerry, and to the 1821 stage play based on it. Egan is sometimes credited with inventing the drink in the 1820s to promote the book and play, reportedly by adding half an ounce of brandy to eggnog, though that story is disputed.
The drink later found a fan in the White House. President Warren G. Harding liked it enough to serve it at an annual Christmas party for his closest friends. The two later cartoon duos named Tom and Jerry, including MGM’s cat and mouse, may have borrowed the name as a nod to the drink or to Egan’s characters.
That long history, from a London stage hit to a president’s holiday party to a Milwaukee bar, explains why the drink still carries a sense of occasion. It is a once-a-year mug, made from a once-a-year tub, and that scarcity is a large part of its appeal.
Handling the batter safely
Because traditional batter is built on eggs, food safety is worth a moment. The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food Safety and Inspection Service, in its guide to shell eggs from farm to table, recommends using pasteurized eggs or egg products for recipes that call for raw or undercooked eggs, and says homemade eggnog can be made safely from a cooked egg-milk mixture heated to 160°F. The agency also says eggs belong in a refrigerator set at 40°F or below.
Spoon University adds a point many home bartenders miss: alcohol is not a reliable way to make raw eggs safe. For store-bought tubs, the label’s storage and use-by directions are the guide. Homemade batter is best made with pasteurized eggs or a cooked base, following the FSIS guidance.
Once the tub is open, a Tom and Jerry comes together in a minute: a heaping spoonful of batter in a warm mug, hot water or hot milk poured over it, the spirits if using them, and a pinch of nutmeg on top.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Visitor7 – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons