In homes across Europe and in parts of the United States, the night of December 5 still ends with a row of shoes by the door, the window or the fireplace. By the morning of December 6, Saint Nicholas Day, those shoes are expected to hold chocolate, candy, fruit and small gifts, left by a 4th-century bishop who became one of the most familiar gift-givers of the season.
The custom has many local versions, and a surprising amount of it revolves around food: carrots and hay for the saint’s horse, spiced cookies, chocolate letters and tangerines. Here is how the shoe tradition works from country to country, and what families tend to find inside.
.jpg?width=1600)
Why December 5 and 6 matter
Saint Nicholas Day is observed on December 6, or on its eve, December 5, in Western Christian countries. The date is tied to Nicholas of Myra, remembered for secret gift-giving. Britannica notes that he is believed to have been bishop of Myra in Lycia, near modern Demre in Turkey, in the 4th century, and that in many countries children still receive gifts on December 6. Britannica also points out that no historical document confirms his existence, so much of what is told about him is legend.
The Eastern feast falls on December 19, which is why some Orthodox families mark the day later in the month. For most of Western Europe, though, the evening of December 5 is when the shoes come out. Families who like a long run-up to the holidays often pair the night with simple projects, such as these cozy winter crafts, while waiting for the morning. Others lean on memories of childhood wish lists, like the ones in this look at the Sears Wish Book and kids’ Christmas habits.
The Netherlands and Belgium: a carrot for the horse
The best-known version comes from the Low Countries, where the saint is called Sinterklaas. According to the St. Nicholas Center’s guide to Dutch customs, children place their shoes by a window, a door or the fireplace with a drawing, a wish list, and a carrot or hay for the saint’s horse. Some add a saucer of water. If Sinterklaas has passed by, the shoes may hold chocolate coins or chocolate initial letters, candy, pepernoten and small gifts.
The Dutch main event is pakjesavond on the evening of December 5, a family party where gifts are signed “from Sinterklaas” and often come with a humorous rhyme. Many households decorate for the evening with older family pieces, and this guide to sourcing and decorating with vintage Christmas decorations covers where such finds turn up. The St. Nicholas Center notes that until the 1940s, Dutch children received their gifts on the morning of December 6 instead. Typical foods named for the season include hot chocolate, bishop’s wine, letter banket, speculaas, pepernoten, tangerines and chocolate letters.
A U.S. Army Garrison Benelux feature, written for American families stationed in the region and published December 4, 2023, explains the timing difference between neighbors: Dutch children open gifts on the evening of December 5, while Belgian children receive theirs on the morning of December 6. The same article says children clean their shoes and leave them by the fireplace or on the doorstep, sometimes filled with carrots, hay or sugar cubes for the horse, and may leave milk or beer for the saint and cookies for his helpers.
For American readers, the details can feel unfamiliar, much like the customs in this list of American traditions that confuse the rest of the world look strange from the other direction.

Boots, windowsills and pillows across Central Europe
Germany has its own version. The Saint Nicholas Day entry describes how children in Northern Germany put a Nikolaus-Stiefel, or Nikolaus boot, outside the front door on the night of December 5. Overnight, the boot is filled with gifts and sweets. A child who has misbehaved may find a stick instead. Families who repeat rituals like this every year tend to share certain habits, as this piece on people who keep the same holiday traditions describes.
In Hungary, Croatia and Romania, children leave cleaned boots on the windowsill on the evening before Saint Nicholas Day, and candy and gifts appear by morning. In Poland and Slovakia, children may find candy and small gifts under the pillow, in their shoes or behind the window on the evening of December 5 or the morning of December 6, while a naughty child might get a twig or a lump of coal. In Ukraine, boots go on the windowsill, too.
Not every country uses shoes. In the Czech Republic, Saint Nicholas hands out candy for good deeds, while in France, families bake gingerbread biscuits and mannala, a brioche shaped like the saint. In Bulgaria, the day is marked with ribnik, a carp baked in dough, and ceremonial bread.
Shoes in the foyer in the United States
The custom crossed the Atlantic with immigrants. Some American children leave their shoes in the foyer on Saint Nicholas Eve hoping the saint will place coins on the soles. In cities with strong German roots, including Milwaukee, Cincinnati and Pittsburgh, children set out polished shoes and find them filled with gifts and candy on the morning of December 6.
Britannica traces a bigger legacy as well. Dutch colonists carried Sinterklaas to New Amsterdam, now New York City, in the 17th century, and the figure was later adopted in America as Santa Claus. That makes the humble shoe by the door a distant ancestor of the stocking by the chimney.
What goes in the shoe, and what goes on the table
Across the countries above, the contents named in these accounts are remarkably similar: chocolate, candy, tangerines, spiced cookies and small gifts. In the Netherlands, the chocolate letter, often the first initial of the child’s name, is a fixture. In Germany, a boot filled with sweets is the classic picture. In American homes that keep the older custom, coins on the soles are the traditional find.
The table side of the day is just as rooted in food. Speculaas and pepernoten fill Dutch kitchens through late November and early December, mannala comes out of French ovens, and carp dishes mark the day in Bulgaria and Serbia, where Orthodox fasting rules shape the menu.
For families thinking of starting the custom, the basics are simple: clean shoes set out on the evening of December 5, a carrot for the horse if desired, and a few sweets and a small gift waiting by morning on December 6.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: R.F. (Roel) Jorna – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons