The narrow ledge at the back of a range looks like the perfect home for a row of spice jars, close at hand and out of the way. McCormick, the company behind many of the jars in American cupboards, says it is one of the worst spots in the kitchen for them. Its storage advice adds 4 more rules about light, containers, dates and drawers that help a spice rack keep its color and aroma longer.

Spices are dried seeds, fruits, roots, bark and other plant parts used for flavor, color and aroma, according to standard reference definitions. Much of that flavor comes from aromatic oils that fade over time, and the rules below are all about slowing that fade.
Rule 1: Keep Spices Off the Ledge Above the Stove
In its guide to how long spices last, McCormick tells home cooks to avoid that little ledge at the top of the stove. The company’s reasoning is simple: repeated heat wears down spices, whole and ground alike. Every time the burners or oven run, the jars on that shelf warm up and cool down again.
There is one exception. McCormick says salt can sit on the ledge, and that it is the only thing that belongs there. Salt is a mineral, while spices are dried plant parts whose aroma comes from delicate oils, so salt has nothing fragile to lose.
Other kitchen authorities agree on the stove. Penn State Extension’s guide to storing staple ingredients in the kitchen warns that placing the spice rack above the stove quickly reduces the quality of those flavorings. The same spot is a poor choice for other reasons too, and craftingyourhome.com keeps a list of things never to leave within 3 feet of the stove during busy holiday cooking.
The stove is not the only warm or damp spot to skip. The McCormick gourmet FAQ page says to avoid storing herbs and spices over the stove, the dishwasher or the sink, or near a window. A dishwasher releases steam and heat at the end of every cycle, the same conditions that put certain tools on lists of kitchen items that should never go in a dishwasher.
Rule 2: Pick a Spot Away From Direct Sunlight
Light is the second enemy. McCormick suggests that a wall shelf made for spices can work well, as long as it is mounted away from direct sunlight and away from the stove. The company adds that spices last longer in a dark cabinet.
McCormick also offers a practical note. If keeping jars out in the open means a household reaches for them more often, the spices may get used up long before shelf life becomes a concern. A sunny windowsill full of glass jars may look charming, but a closed cabinet near the prep area keeps colors brighter. For kitchens short on cabinet space, frenzhub.com rounds up clever storage hacks to maximize every inch of space, and its list of kitchen remodel ideas on a shoestring budget includes low-cost ways to add shelving.
Rules 3 and 4: Original Bottles, Tight Caps and a Dated Lid
McCormick says storing its products in their original containers is key, because a well-sealed bottle locks out the air and humidity that break down a spice’s oils over time. Its FAQ page puts it plainly: store herbs and spices in a tightly capped container. A loose lid or a bag left open lets moisture creep in, and moisture is what turns ground spices into hard clumps.
.jpg?width=1600)
The fourth rule takes a few seconds. McCormick recommends using a permanent marker to write the date a new jar was opened. That date makes it easy to see later which jars have been around the longest. The company also prints a best-by date on the lids of its bottles, and its FAQ says products without a printed date are past the recommended shelf life.
Today’s Timeless Dishes shelf-life guide covers the full chart. As a single reference point, McCormick lists ground spices at about 2 to 4 years and whole spices at about 3 to 4 years, with proper storage. North Carolina State Extension notes in its guide to cooking with herbs and spices that light, heat and moisture shorten storage life further, and it suggests a quick sniff: if a jar still smells strong, it is still worth using.
Rule 5: Lay the Jars Flat in a Drawer With Dividers
For cooks with a spare drawer near the stove (but not under the burners), McCormick suggests storing jars lying flat. Dividers made for this setup keep the bottles from rolling around, and the company says this is preferable to storing them with the lids up. A flat drawer keeps every label visible at a glance and keeps the jars in the dark, which covers Rule 2 at the same time.
McCormick also points out that whole spices have a longer shelf life than ground ones. Penn State Extension agrees, noting that whole cloves, nutmeg and cinnamon sticks keep their quality beyond two years, and it suggests checking ground spices and dried herbs for aroma after about six months.
Where the Experts Differ: The Fridge and Freezer
Cold storage is one place where the advice splits. McCormick’s FAQ says members of the red pepper family, including paprika and chili powder, keep their color best in the refrigerator. The company does not recommend freezing dried herbs and spices, saying it does not extend their shelf life.
Penn State Extension takes a different view and says spices and herbs can be frozen. It adds an important step: let the container come to room temperature before opening it, so condensation does not form inside. Cooks who grow their own herbs in elevated garden beds for fall greens and herbs may find that drying and storing them in sealed jars, away from the stove and the sun, keeps them flavorful through the winter.
For most kitchens the short version is easy to remember. Salt can stay on the ledge above the stove. Everything else belongs in a tightly capped bottle with an opening date on the lid, tucked into a dark cabinet or a flat drawer, away from heat, steam and sunlight.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Jeremy Segrott – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons