A new national poll is revealing a striking shift in how many Asian American and Pacific Islander adults view the United States, not just as a place of opportunity, but as a place of belonging. For decades, the United States has been described as a country built by immigrants and powered by diversity. But new data from an AP-NORC and AAPI Data survey suggests that for many AAPI adults, that identity feels increasingly uncertain.
Most respondents say the U.S. is no longer a great country for immigrants, marking a sobering reassessment of the American promise. The findings reflect more than opinion. They point to a growing behavioral and emotional shift inside immigrant communities, where legal status, cultural identity, and everyday safety are being quietly re-evaluated in real time.
A growing sense that the promise has changed

According to the poll, about 6 in 10 AAPI adults say the United States used to be a great country for immigrants, but no longer is. Only about 3 in 10 still believe America remains a strong destination for immigrants, while a small share say it never was. That shift is significant because AAPI communities are among the most directly shaped by immigration.
Many respondents were born outside the U.S., while others are first or second-generation Americans navigating layered identities across cultures. What stands out is not just disappointment, but a sense of transition. The American story is not necessarily seen as ending, but as changing shape in ways that feel less welcoming than before.
Every day life is quietly changing.
One of the most telling findings is how immigration concerns are reshaping daily behavior. About half of AAPI adults say they or someone they know has experienced direct disruption in the past year, including detention or deportation within their social circle, carrying proof of legal status or citizenship, or changing travel plans due to immigration concerns. These are not abstract policy reactions.
They are practical adjustments that now define routine life decisions. People are rethinking whether to travel internationally, whether to carry documents at all times, and whether certain movements feel safe even with legal status. In some communities, this has created a new kind of “always prepared” mindset, where passports, green cards, and identification are treated less like occasional documents and more like daily essentials.
Legal status is not feeling as secure as it once did

Perhaps the most revealing emotional shift in the poll is the way legal status is being perceived. Even naturalized citizens and green card holders are reporting increased caution. Some say they feel pressure to carry documentation constantly, not because their status has changed, but because their sense of security has. This creates a quiet paradox. On paper, citizenship and residency remain stable.
In practice, many respondents describe a growing feeling that status must be continually proven, rather than simply held. The poll also shows variation within communities. South Asian adults, for example, are more likely than AAPI adults overall to know someone who has recently begun carrying proof of legal status or citizenship. That detail points to how immigration anxiety is not evenly distributed, but shaped by community experience and background.
Identity feels layered, not singular.
The survey also highlights a deeper cultural reality: many AAPI adults do not see identity as a single category. More than half say their family’s ancestry or country of origin is very important to who they are. Fewer say the same about being American. Even among U.S.-born AAPI adults, a majority still place strong importance on heritage identity.
This does not reflect rejection of American identity. Instead, it reflects a layered sense of belonging where cultural origin and national identity coexist, sometimes uneasily. For many respondents, being American does not replace heritage. It sits beside it. And in some cases, it feels less emotionally central than the cultural roots that shaped their families long before they arrived in the United States.
A country defined by cultural mixing, but with a debated identity.
Despite concerns, AAPI adults are more likely than the general U.S. population to say that cultural mixing is essential to America’s identity. About 73% say the blending of cultures and values from around the world is very or extremely important to what the United States is. That belief reinforces a core idea of America as a multicultural society.
Yet the tension is clear. Many of the same respondents who value diversity also express doubt about whether current conditions still reflect that ideal. It creates a split perception: America as a cultural idea remains strong, but America as a lived experience feels more uncertain.
The emotional weight of “belonging”

Interviews included in the poll show how personal this shift has become. Some respondents describe pride in their families’ immigrant journeys, especially those who built new lives across generations. Others describe a more conflicted feeling, where being American is meaningful but not always fully grounding. For younger AAPI adults in particular, identity often feels dual rather than singular.
They are American, but also deeply connected to ancestral cultures, languages, and histories that remain active in their lives. This duality becomes more complex when immigration policies and public sentiment feel uncertain. Belonging is no longer just about citizenship. It is about comfort, recognition, and how safe people feel moving through everyday life.
A milestone year with mixed emotions
The findings arrive as the United States approaches its 250th anniversary, a moment often associated with reflection and national pride. But for many AAPI adults, that milestone also raises questions. What does it mean to celebrate a country whose meaning feels contested for some of its most diverse communities?
For some, the anniversary is still a moment of appreciation for progress and opportunity. For others, it highlights unresolved tensions between America’s ideals and its current immigration reality.
A shifting national story
Taken together, the poll suggests that immigration is not only a policy issue, but a force reshaping how many AAPI adults experience the United States itself. It influences how people travel, how they identify, and how secure they feel, even when their legal status is unchanged.
The American story has long been defined by reinvention and reintegration. But for many AAPI adults today, that story feels like it is entering a more uncertain chapter, where belonging is still possible, but no longer assumed.