The day after a big holiday meal, the microwave becomes the busiest appliance in the house. Plates of turkey, scoops of stuffing and the last of the mashed potatoes go in and out all weekend, often in whatever container was closest to hand.
That last part is where trouble starts. Clemson University’s Home & Garden Information Center, part of Clemson Cooperative Extension, keeps a microwave food safety fact sheet, last updated in June 2026, that flags 8 items to keep out of it. The list runs from reused margarine tubs and paper sacks all the way to a stuffed holiday bird.

Containers and wraps to keep out
A microwave oven heats food by making water molecules vibrate, but the container sits in the same field and has to handle the heat that builds up in the food. Clemson’s list of things not to use covers the ones that cannot. Like many clever kitchen tricks for home cooks, the fix is usually simple: move the food to a better dish before pressing start.
1. Metal pans and aluminum foil containers. Clemson says to skip metal pans and foil containers unless the microwave’s manufacturer specifically approves them. Metal can spark and keeps food from heating evenly.
2. Brown paper bags. The paper sack from the bakery or takeout counter is not made for microwave use, according to Clemson. Microwave-safe paper towels or parchment paper are better choices for covering food.
3. Newspapers. Wrapping food in newspaper to reheat it is out, too. Clemson lists newspapers alongside brown paper bags as materials to keep out of the microwave.
4. Plastic grocery bags. The thin bags that carry groceries home are on the list, as well. They were designed to hold cans and produce, not to sit around hot food.
Anyone who has picked up a microwave with extra cooking modes can find more tips in this guide to using a microwave air fryer combo, but the container rules apply to every model.
Reused tubs and grocery packaging
5. Thin plastic storage bags. Clemson says thin plastic storage bags should not be used in the microwave. Bags sold specifically as microwave cooking bags are a different product and are on the fact sheet’s list of safe choices.
6. Margarine tubs, yogurt containers and whipped topping bowls. These are the classic reuse containers in many kitchens, and they often end up holding leftovers. Clemson says containers like these should stay out of the microwave unless they are labeled microwave-safe. The safe list includes glass or glass-ceramic cookware, ceramic dishes without metallic trim and plastic containers labeled for microwave use. An earlier roundup of everyday items that should never go in a microwave covers a few more household examples.
7. Foam trays and plastic wraps from the grocery store. The foam tray under a package of chicken and the stretchy wrap on top are not made for cooking. Clemson says foam trays and plastic wraps used in grocery packaging may melt or warp when heated. Moving food to a microwave-safe dish before thawing or reheating avoids the problem. Containers that are not safe for the microwave are often not safe for the dishwasher either, as this list of kitchen items that never go in a dishwasher explains.

8. A whole stuffed turkey or chicken
The final item on the list is not a container at all. Clemson’s guidance is direct: do not microwave whole stuffed poultry. The fact sheet explains that the stuffing may not reach a safe temperature before the meat overcooks. The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food Safety and Inspection Service goes further in its turkey roasting guide, saying that for optimum safety, stuffing a turkey is not recommended at all, and suggesting cooking the stuffing in a casserole dish instead. When stuffing is cooked inside the bird, FSIS says it must reach 165°F.
Clemson also advises against partially cooking raw meat in the microwave to finish later. Partly cooked food should go straight to another method, such as the grill or oven. Freeing up oven space on the big day is a common challenge, and this comparison of countertop ovens for Thanksgiving looks at a few options.
Reheating leftovers the right way
Once the right container is in hand, temperature is what matters. FSIS says in its guide to leftovers that reheated leftovers should reach 165°F as measured with a food thermometer, and that food in the microwave should be covered and rotated for even heating. Clemson adds that microwaves can leave cold spots, so food should be stirred or rotated midway and checked in several places with a thermometer.
Clemson’s chart of microwave minimums matches the federal safe minimum internal temperatures: 165°F for poultry, leftovers and casseroles; 160°F for ground meats and egg dishes; and 145°F plus a 3-minute rest for whole cuts of beef, pork, lamb or veal. Letting food stand for a few minutes after the microwave stops helps the heat even out, and a lid or microwave-safe cover holds in moisture.
FSIS also says leftovers can be kept in the refrigerator for 3 to 4 days or frozen for 3 to 4 months. With Thanksgiving on Nov. 26, a quick check of the cabinet for microwave-safe glass dishes now can save a scramble for containers later. Labeling a shelf for microwave-safe glass and ceramic, and keeping the reused tubs for cold storage only, makes the right choice the easy one when a houseful of guests is lining up for second helpings of turkey and stuffing.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: NeoMeesje – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons