Texas Roadhouse Says a Customer’s Steak Mix-Up ‘Was Made Right’ After His TikTok Passed 31,000 Views

A steak dinner is supposed to be the easy part of a night out. Order the cut, get the cut, cut into it. For one Illinois diner, the plate that arrived in front of him did not match the menu, and by his account that happened more than once.

Kenneth Card posted a TikTok video on Oct. 5 about his experience at the Texas Roadhouse in Forsyth, Illinois, and by the time Complex reported on it on Oct. 27, the clip had passed 31,000 views. The chain’s response, given to the press, was that the mix-up “was made right.”

Exterior of a Texas Roadhouse restaurant building
Rick Obst – CC BY 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

The Order Card Says Went Wrong

According to Complex, Card said he ordered an eight-ounce Dallas Filet but was served a sirloin. Citing the restaurant’s online menu, the outlet listed the filet at $29.99 and the sirloin at $19.49, a gap of $10.50 on a single plate.

Card described three separate visits. On the first, he said, staff replaced the steak. On the third, he asked for a manager, and a server rechecked the plate and confirmed it was a sirloin. The correct filet was then boxed for him to take home. A former restaurant cook, Card told the outlet he spotted the swap by the texture of the meat.

The video count is a snapshot, not a final tally. The 31,000 figure is the number Complex reported as of its Oct. 27 story, and Card’s account of three visits is his own telling of events.

What Texas Roadhouse Said in Response

A company spokesperson, quoted in the Complex story and in People’s report on the same video, confirmed one wrong steak at the Forsyth location. The statement said the company cannot confirm the mix-up happened on multiple occasions, and that once Mr. Card raised it, the order “was made right.”

The company added that it has processes in place to double-check food for quality and accuracy before it leaves the kitchen. For guests who receive the wrong item or an incorrect charge, the spokesperson said, the chain encourages them to tell a team member so the problem can be fixed.

The two accounts agree on the core fact, a sirloin served in place of a filet, and differ on how often it happened. The chain framed it as a single kitchen error at one restaurant.

Why Filet and Sirloin Look Different on a Plate

The two cuts come from different parts of the animal, which is why a trained eye can sometimes tell. According to Wikipedia’s entry on filet mignon, the cut comes from the smaller end of the beef tenderloin, has a mild flavor, and is generally among the most expensive cuts because only a small amount can be butchered from each animal.

Sirloin sits behind the short loin, where strip steaks come from. As Wikipedia’s sirloin steak page explains, the more heavily worked muscles in the bottom sirloin are firmer and more flavorful. That difference in texture is what Card, a former restaurant cook, says gave the plate away.

Price gaps like the one on this menu also explain why an order check matters. At an everyday chain, a $10 difference on one plate adds up across a table, and diners who order a premium cut often compare the plate to the menu name before the first bite.

Many families plan a restaurant night as carefully as a grocery run. A roundup of frugal living ideas, a list of wallet-friendly everyday habits and a Thanksgiving comparison of air fryers and toaster ovens for freeing up the oven all come from the same instinct, which is to know what a dollar buys before ordering or cooking.

Kitchens run on habit as much as menus do. A look back at what nearly every 1980s kitchen held and a note on items that stay off the kitchen counter show how much of cooking runs on routine.

A cooked steak on a plate with chips and sauce
Socket0 – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

A Chain Built Around Steak

Texas Roadhouse is a large name in casual dining. According to Wikipedia, founder W. Kent Taylor opened the first restaurant in Clarksville, Indiana, in 1993, and the company is based in Louisville, Kentucky. The same entry lists 872 locations as of November 2025 and says the chain became the largest casual-dining restaurant chain in the U.S. in April 2025, according to Technomic data.

The same entry notes that steaks are the core of the menu and gives the mission statement as “Legendary Food, Legendary Service.” For a chain that leans that hard on steak, a swapped cut is the kind of mistake that travels quickly once a diner films it.

Wikipedia also lists a few details that make the brand easy to recognize: the company went public on Nasdaq in 2004 under the symbol TXRH, its first international location opened in Dubai in September 2011, and restaurants feature line dancing performed by staff. Singer Willie Nelson became an official partner in 2002, and the mascot is an armadillo named Andy.

Checking the Plate Before the First Bite

The Forsyth story is a reminder of a simple restaurant habit: confirm what was ordered when the plate lands. Diners who catch a problem early give the kitchen the easiest chance to fix it, and a manager can replace a dish while the table is still seated.

Both sides of the story reach readers through Complex: Card’s video describes three visits, while the company confirms one wrong steak. The prices come from the restaurant’s online menu as cited by Complex, and the view count is as of Oct. 27.

For now, the facts on record are narrow. A diner ordered a $29.99 filet, received a $19.49 sirloin at least once, and the chain says the order was corrected and its kitchen checks food before it goes out.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Chris Light – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

  • Emma Flavia

    Emma Flavia is a lifestyle and entertainment writer who dives into the ways people live, think, and connect in a world shaped by trends and technology. She has written for high-profile platforms such as MSN and NewsBreak, covering mental wellness, relationships, digital culture, and the latest social phenomena with insight and flair. Passionate about the human experience, Emma also finds inspiration in nature walks, minimalist digital art, experimenting with color palettes, and documentaries that explore behavior and design.

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *