Kentucky Derby Pie, Indiana Sugar Cream, New York Concord Grape: State Thanksgiving Pies and Puddings Named in Regional Food Guides

Every Thanksgiving table has a pie, and in a lot of kitchens the one that matters most is not pumpkin. It is the dessert that only the family’s home state seems to bake, the one out-of-town guests have never heard of.

Regional food guides keep naming those local favorites. Lonely Planet’s regional Thanksgiving guide, originally published in November 2012 and updated in November 2020, and a handful of state and regional sources point to Kentucky Derby pie, Indiana sugar cream pie and New York Concord grape pie, along with puddings, custards and molasses pies from other corners of the country. Here is what each one is, according to those guides.

A whole pecan pie on a blue plate
Mshuang2 – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

Kentucky Derby Pie

Families planning a holiday dessert table can start with Thanksgiving dinner costs by state in 2026 to see how the bill varies. Lonely Planet describes Derby pie as a pecan-pie style pie with chocolate and bourbon added. Wikipedia’s entry says it was created in 1954 at the Melrose Inn in Prospect, Kentucky, by Walter and Leaudra Kern, and that “Derby pie” is a registered trademark of Kern’s Kitchen.

Indiana Sugar Cream Pie

Anyone curious how food customs differ from place to place can browse laws and rules about food in other countries. Lonely Planet calls it a white flour and cream pie, a pecan-free cousin of pecan pie. Wikipedia adds that it is also called Hoosier pie, is made with cream, sugar and cornstarch, and is unofficially recognized as Indiana’s state pie. Its pantry-staple ingredients earned it the nickname “desperation pie.”

Indiana Persimmon Pudding

Oven space is tight on the holiday, which is why an oven-freeing Thanksgiving guide comes up so often. Lonely Planet describes a steamed pudding made with ripe American persimmons, similar to an English Christmas pudding. Wikipedia calls it chewy and dense, like gingerbread cake, and says it shares billing with sugar cream pie as an iconic Indiana dish, served with ice cream at the Persimmon Festival in Mitchell, Indiana. The Takeout also describes a spongy, eggy cake of pureed persimmons and warm spices, while Lonely Planet notes that California’s version uses Asian hachiya persimmons brought by Japanese immigrants.

A pile of freshly harvested Concord grapes
grongar – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

New York Concord Grape Pie

A pie that has to travel to a relative’s house needs a plan, as in carry-on packing tips for Thanksgiving trips. Lonely Planet says the pie requires removing the skins and seeds from fresh Concord grapes, then cooking and thickening the filling. The Takeout says it became popular during the Depression in upstate New York. Wikipedia traces the grape itself to Ephraim Wales Bull, who developed it in 1849 in Concord, Massachusetts, after evaluating more than 22,000 seedlings.

Pennsylvania Shoofly Pie

Which pie gets cut first is the sort of thing families quietly argue about at Thanksgiving dinner. The Chesapeake Bay Program’s guide to regional food traditions describes a molasses custard base with a brown sugar crumb topping that sinks as it bakes into a cake-like middle layer. It notes that the name’s origin is disputed, with one explanation about shooing flies from sticky molasses. Wikipedia ties the pie to Pennsylvania Dutch cooking and says traditional versions contain no eggs. Bakers make a dry-bottom version, baked until fully set and cake-like throughout, and a wet-bottom version with a stickier, custard-like layer at the base, and the page says the name first appeared in print after the First World War.

Maryland Eastern Shore White Potato Pie

Preservation Maryland’s Thanksgiving article, published November 24, 2022, describes a custard-style pie of mashed white potatoes, half-and-half, eggs and sugar, baked in two 9-inch pastry shells. It says potato pies date back to at least the seventeenth century.

Southern Pecan and Sweet Potato Pie

Pumpkin may be the national standard, but Lonely Planet says the South often prefers sweet potato. Lonely Planet says sweet potato pie is prepared much like pumpkin pie but with a slightly different texture, and that pecan pie is a custard pie that ranges from very custardy to almost pure nut and corn syrup. Food Network’s state-by-state Thanksgiving collection names pecan pie for Mississippi and sweet potato pie for Maryland.

New England Indian Pudding

Lonely Planet describes it as a thick, long-cooked cornmeal porridge with molasses, cinnamon and ginger, sometimes with raisins or nuts. It is a pudding for the table that never needed a crust, and a reminder that not every Thanksgiving dessert is a pie. Lonely Planet places it in New England.

Oklahoma Sopapilla Cheesecake

Food Network lists sopapilla cheesecake bars for Oklahoma in the same collection. It is a handy reminder that state desserts at Thanksgiving include more than pie, and that a regional favorite can be as simple as a baking dish of bars.

Why Regional Pies Hold On

Local desserts tend to follow local harvests and pantries. Grapes in New York, persimmons in the Midwest and molasses in Pennsylvania Dutch kitchens all appear in the guides above, and a recipe carried across state lines can run into ingredients that are tougher to find. Some of these desserts, like the persimmon pudding, are limited by how hard the wild fruit is to prepare, according to Wikipedia.

Whichever pie or pudding lands on the table this year, each one carries a home-state story behind it.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Kimberly Vardeman – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *