5 Pantry Swaps for Holiday Baking: Pumpkin Pie Spice, Allspice, Buttermilk, Unsweetened Chocolate and Lemon Juice

When a holiday baking recipe calls for an ingredient the pantry lacks, five common swaps can fill the gap using things most kitchens already hold. They are pumpkin pie spice, allspice, buttermilk, unsweetened chocolate and lemon juice, and the amounts come from university extension services.

Thanksgiving is November 26. The substitutions below are drawn from Utah State University Extension and North Dakota State University Extension lists, with a note from the University of Illinois Extension on buttermilk.

A jar of ground pumpkin pie spice
Robert Dell – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Pumpkin Pie Spice From Four Jar Spices

Utah State University Extension’s list of ingredient substitutions says 1 teaspoon of pumpkin pie spice can be replaced with 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon, 1/4 teaspoon ginger, 1/8 teaspoon allspice and 1/8 teaspoon nutmeg. North Dakota State University Extension’s publication on substitutions gives the same amounts.

The swap works because the blend is a mix of familiar spices. According to Wikipedia’s entry on pumpkin pie spice, it typically contains ground cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and cloves, sometimes with allspice, and it does not contain pumpkin. The same entry says McCormick introduced the blended product commercially in 1934. A cook who measures the four spices separately is making a close cousin of what the jar sells. Before the baking starts, a set of Thanksgiving oven checks covers the equipment side.

Allspice From Cinnamon and Cloves

For 1 teaspoon of allspice, both extension lists call for 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon and 1/2 teaspoon ground cloves. That is a useful fallback when a recipe for spice cake, gingerbread or a pie filling lists allspice and the jar is empty.

Wikipedia’s entry on allspice explains why the combination makes sense. Allspice is the dried, unripe berry of the Pimenta dioica tree, and it tastes like a blend of cinnamon, nutmeg and clove even though it is a single spice. The English named it in 1621 for that reason, and Jamaica remains the leading source. Cooks who plan ahead for the holidays can find ideas for the rest of the kitchen in a roundup on freeing up the oven on Thanksgiving. Households that like to keep herbs and greens on hand through the cold months might look at ideas for growing herbs and greens into winter.

Whole dried allspice berries
Ryan Snyder – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Buttermilk From Milk and an Acid

The buttermilk swap is the best known. University of Illinois Extension’s recipe substitutions page says each cup of buttermilk can be replaced with 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or vinegar plus enough regular milk to make 1 cup, left to sit for 5 minutes. Utah State gives the same method and also lists two other options: 1 3/4 teaspoons of cream of tartar plus 1 cup of milk, or 1 cup of plain yogurt.

North Dakota State’s version uses 1 cup minus 1 tablespoon of sweet milk plus 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or vinegar, left to stand 5 to 10 minutes. The longer wait is consistent with Wikipedia’s entry on buttermilk, which describes about 15 milliliters of acid in 200 to 250 milliliters of milk, left for about 10 minutes until it curdles, and says whole milk is usually preferred for baking.

The reason the acid matters is chemistry. The same entry says buttermilk’s acid reacts with baking soda to release carbon dioxide, which makes baked goods such as soda bread rise. A recipe that pairs buttermilk with baking soda depends on that reaction, so the stirred-up substitute should include a real acid rather than plain milk. Shoppers building a Thanksgiving list can start from a written shopping list and mark which of these swaps replace a store trip.

Swapping instead of buying also fits a budget, and a set of frugal living tips covers more ways to save on groceries.

Unsweetened Chocolate From Cocoa and Butter

For 1 ounce of unsweetened chocolate, North Dakota State Extension lists 3 tablespoons of cocoa plus 1 tablespoon of butter or margarine. Utah State’s list gives the same ratio for 1 ounce of chocolate: 3 tablespoons of cocoa plus 1 tablespoon of fat.

Wikipedia’s entry on baking chocolate describes the unsweetened type as containing no sugar and about 99% chocolate liquor, or cocoa solids. Recipes built around it, the entry says, generally call for plenty of added sugar. That explains why a cocoa-and-fat substitute still leaves the recipe’s own sugar in place.

Lemon Juice From Vinegar, and a Caution for All Five

The simplest swap on the list is for lemon juice: 1 teaspoon can be replaced with 1/2 teaspoon of vinegar, according to both Utah State and North Dakota State. The vinegar amount is half the lemon juice amount.

Lemon juice also appears in the buttermilk swap above, where the Illinois list uses 1 tablespoon of it per cup, so a cook short on lemons can reach for vinegar in either place.

None of these swaps is a perfect match. North Dakota State’s publication says substitutions may alter the taste, color, moisture content or texture of the product, and it recommends using them only in unexpected situations. That is a fair reading for holiday baking: a cinnamon-and-cloves allspice or a vinegar-and-milk buttermilk will work, but a recipe that depends on a single ingredient, such as a chocolate cake built on unsweetened chocolate, may come out slightly different.

The five swaps, again, in the amounts the extension lists give: for 1 teaspoon of pumpkin pie spice, 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon, 1/4 teaspoon ginger, 1/8 teaspoon allspice and 1/8 teaspoon nutmeg; for 1 teaspoon of allspice, 1/2 teaspoon each of cinnamon and ground cloves; for 1 cup of buttermilk, 1 tablespoon of vinegar or lemon juice plus milk to make 1 cup, left 5 minutes; for 1 ounce of unsweetened chocolate, 3 tablespoons of cocoa plus 1 tablespoon of butter; and for 1 teaspoon of lemon juice, 1/2 teaspoon of vinegar.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Cindy – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *