North Carolina Furniture Owner Charged After Business Partner Is Killed Following Court Dispute

Willard Gary Black, an 85-year-old North Carolina furniture company owner, remains under a $2.5 million secured bond after being charged with second-degree murder in the fatal shooting of his business partner, Robert Roger Arguelles.

The shooting happened on Wednesday, June 17, inside Old Hickory Tannery in Newton, North Carolina. Police said Arguelles, 59, was shot during an altercation at the business, only hours after a judge ruled against Black in a contract dispute.

Black Held After First Court Appearance

Photo Credit: Catawba County News And Weather /Facebook

Black appeared in court on Thursday after his arrest at the Newton furniture business. A judge set Black’s secured bond at $2.5 million, with his next court date scheduled for July 9.

The charge against Black is an allegation. He has not been convicted, and the case remains in the early stages of the criminal process.

Police said Black was taken into custody after officers arrived at Old Hickory Tannery. Investigators said a weapon was recovered at the scene.

Police Say Shooting Followed Altercation

Newton police said officers were called to the business shortly after 3 p.m. Wednesday. When they arrived, they found Arguelles inside an office area with gunshot wounds. Officers and emergency responders attempted life-saving measures. Arguelles was pronounced dead at the scene.

Investigators said Black and Arguelles had been involved in an altercation before the shooting. Police have not publicly released a full account of what was said before the gunfire. Authorities have also not confirmed whether surveillance footage, employee statements, or other evidence will be presented in court. The investigation remains active.

Court Fight Centered on More Than $310,000

The shooting happened the same day a judge ruled on a civil dispute involving Black, Arguelles, and Old Hickory Tannery. Records tied to the case show Black had been ordered to pay $310,882.74. The civil case involved money Arguelles said he had loaned in connection with the company. According to filings, only a smaller portion of the alleged loan had been repaid.

The ownership dispute placed both men on opposite sides of a company to which they were tied financially. Arguelles’ company held 49.9 percent of Old Hickory Tannery, while Black held 50.1 percent.

The dispute had moved through court before Wednesday’s shooting. Court records show both sides had reached a settlement, but Black later attempted to withdraw his consent.

Judge Enforced Settlement Terms

A judge denied Black’s request to withdraw from the settlement. The same ruling required him to comply with the agreement and pay the amount listed in the court record. The civil court filings show the dispute included ownership, repayment, and control of the company. Those details are part of the civil record, not a criminal finding.

The settlement reportedly went beyond the payment itself. It also included terms connected to Black’s role at the company and the future control of the business. The settlement terms also included provisions requiring Black to give up shares, resign from leadership roles, and provide company records. The court also addressed what could happen if those terms were not followed.

Police have not said the ruling was the motive for the shooting. Prosecutors may later decide whether the civil dispute becomes part of the criminal case.

Arguelles Was a School Board Member

Photo Credit: Murder_and_its_victims/Facebook

Arguelles lived in Taylorsville and served on the Alexander County Board of Education. He had been a board member since 2022. School officials remembered him as a husband, father, and public servant who supported the district. The district also asked the public to respect the family’s privacy.

Arguelles’ death now reaches beyond the business dispute. He served on the school board during a period when local education leaders were handling budget, policy, and classroom issues. His role made him known to families, educators, and public officials outside the furniture industry. His death left both the business community and the school community responding to the same loss.

Old Hickory Tannery Has Long Local Roots

Old Hickory Tannery is a Newton-based furniture manufacturer known for custom upholstered furniture. The company has operated for decades and has been tied to high-end furniture production. Black has been connected to the company for many years. State business records and industry records have listed him in leadership roles.

Arguelles became connected to the company through his ownership stake and business investment. The later court dispute showed how the business relationship had deteriorated. The company’s future may now be affected by both the civil dispute and the criminal case. Court records already show the business had been at the center of a fight over debt, ownership, and control.

Civil Case Could Become Key Background

The criminal charge against Black will focus on what prosecutors can prove happened during the shooting. The civil case may still become an important background. Prosecutors could use the court dispute to explain the relationship between the two men. Defense attorneys may challenge that framing or argue that the civil fight does not prove intent.

Second-degree murder generally does not require prosecutors to prove the same level of planning required for first-degree murder. The state must still prove the legal elements beyond a reasonable doubt.

Evidence in the case could include witness statements, police reports, forensic findings, medical evidence, and any available video. Investigators have not released all the evidence publicly.

Investigation Remains Active

Newton police said the investigation is ongoing. Authorities asked anyone with information to contact investigators. Black remains charged with second-degree murder. His next scheduled court appearance is July 9.

The case now involves two separate records: a criminal case tied to Arguelles’ death and a civil dispute involving Old Hickory Tannery. Officials have not announced additional charges.

For now, the latest known status is that Black remains under bond, Arguelles’ family and community are mourning, and investigators are continuing to review what happened inside the Newton furniture business on June 17.

Author

  • Eliud

    I am a writer with a passion for creating clear, engaging, and informative content. I write on a wide range of topics and focus on delivering accurate, well-researched articles that provide value to readers. My goal is to produce content that informs, educates, and connects with audiences across different platforms.

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *