For some Christians, faith has always been about more than Sunday services, Bible study, and familiar hymns. It is also about how people treat one another, how they respond to suffering, and whether their actions reflect the values they preach.
But what happens when the people you once worshipped alongside begin supporting political figures whose behavior seems to clash with everything you were taught about Christianity?
That is the difficult question behind a personal essay by Tiffany Torres Williams, published in HuffPost on November 10, 2026. After years of feeling disconnected from fellow Christians because of their enthusiasm for Donald Trump and the MAGA movement, Williams says one night unexpectedly gave her a reason to feel hopeful again.
And it was not a church service or religious gathering. It was election night.
When Christianity Started Feeling Different

Williams describes growing up in the Texas Hill Country in a predominantly white evangelical church. Christianity was a major part of her childhood. She attended regular services, participated in Bible studies, went to church camps, and eventually built a churchgoing family of her own.
Faith was not something she simply practised occasionally. It was part of her everyday identity.
However, the 2016 presidential election changed how she viewed the Christian community around her.
She was disturbed by the enthusiasm some of her fellow Christians showed toward Trump. For someone who understood Christianity through teachings about compassion, humility, love, and caring for neighbors, the political support was difficult to reconcile with what she believed.
Over time, the disconnect became harder to ignore.
Williams began feeling increasingly uncomfortable around people she had once considered part of her spiritual community. Eventually, she stopped attending church.
Importantly, she did not say she had stopped believing in God. Instead, she found herself separating her personal faith from the religious community that had once helped shape it.
Nature and quiet moments became more central to her spiritual life.
Why Trump’s Support Among Evangelicals Became So Divisive

Williams’ experience reflects a much wider conversation about religion and politics in America.
The relationship between conservative Christianity and Republican politics did not begin with Trump. It has roots stretching back several decades.
In 1979, evangelical leader Jerry Falwell Sr. founded the Moral Majority, an organization that helped bring conservative Christians into Republican political organizing. Its priorities included abortion, religious freedom, cultural issues, and opposition to certain social changes.
Trump later strengthened this relationship by appealing to evangelical voters through promises involving Supreme Court appointments, abortion policy, and religious liberty.
For many supporters, his political decisions mattered more than whether they personally considered him a model Christian.
A February 2026 Pew Research Center survey found that 69% of white evangelical Protestants approved of Trump’s job performance. However, only 40% expressed strong confidence that he acted ethically in office.
That difference highlights an important distinction: supporting a politician’s policies does not necessarily mean viewing that person as a moral or religious example.
Still, the political relationship has created tension among Christians who disagree about what their faith should look like in public life.
The November Night That Brought Back Some Hope
On November 3, 2026, Americans went to the polls for the midterm elections.
For Williams, watching the results brought an unexpected emotional response.
Two victories particularly caught her attention: James Talarico in Texas and Adam Hamilton in Kansas.
Both candidates were openly connected to Christianity, but their political messages offered a different picture of how religious beliefs could influence public service.
Talarico, a Presbyterian seminarian and Texas state representative, defeated Republican Ken Paxton in the Texas Senate race.
During his victory speech, he spoke about his Baptist-preacher grandfather and referenced Jesus’ teachings about loving God and one’s neighbor. He also emphasized treating people with dignity, including those who do not look, pray, or vote like you.
Hamilton, a United Methodist pastor, defeated Republican incumbent Roger Marshall in Kansas.
His message focused heavily on kindness, decency, and the Golden Rule. He reminded voters of the familiar Christian teaching about treating others the way they would want to be treated.
For Williams, these victories represented something she had struggled to see for years: Christians participating in politics without making religious identity synonymous with one political movement.
Her reaction was not about suddenly agreeing with every political position the candidates held. It was about recognizing that Christianity could have a different public voice.
Christianity Has Never Had Just One Political Voice
One important detail often gets lost in conversations about American Christianity: Christians do not all share the same political beliefs.
Although white evangelical voters have strongly supported Trump, other Christian communities have maintained different political traditions.
Black Protestant churches, for example, have a long history of involvement in Democratic politics, civil rights activism, and community organizing.
Some evangelical leaders have also publicly criticized Trump.
In December 2019, Christianity Today published an editorial by then-editor-in-chief Mark Galli arguing that Trump should be removed from office. The editorial showed that opposition to Trump existed within evangelical Christianity itself.
Similarly, religious organizations such as the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty have challenged Christian nationalism through their Christians Against Christian Nationalism campaign, launched in 2019.
Christian nationalism is not the same thing as Christianity. Researchers Andrew Whitehead and Samuel Perry describe it as an ideology that closely links American national identity with Christianity.
This distinction matters because someone can be deeply religious, politically conservative, and still believe that government should not favor one religion over others.
The Numbers Tell a More Complicated Story
While the 2026 election victories offered Williams hope, they should not be mistaken for evidence that evangelical Christians have suddenly abandoned Trump or MAGA politics.
Pew Research Center’s analysis of the 2024 election found that 81% of white evangelical Protestant voters supported Trump. That was slightly lower than the 83% recorded in 2020.
Meanwhile, a February 2026 study by the Public Religion Research Institute found that 11% of American adults qualified as Christian nationalism adherents and another 21% as sympathizers under its measurement system.
These findings show that Christian nationalism remains an important part of America’s political conversation. However, PRRI also reported that the overall proportions in these categories had remained broadly stable since late 2022.
The 2026 election results also had several possible explanations, including economic concerns, candidate appeal, and dissatisfaction with the Republican administration. They do not prove that voters supported Talarico and Hamilton primarily because of their Christian identities.
That distinction matters when interpreting the results.
Hope Does Not Always Mean Going Back
Perhaps the most interesting part of Williams’ experience is what she says did not happen.
She did not suddenly regain her faith in God because of two election victories. She explains that she had never lost that faith in the first place.
What changed was her belief that Christians could represent their religion differently in public life.
And that is a meaningful difference.
For people who have become uncomfortable with religious communities because of political divisions, seeing individuals express faith through kindness, compassion, and respect can be encouraging.
It does not mean everyone must agree politically or that churches will suddenly become places without disagreements.
It simply shows that Christianity cannot be reduced to one political identity.
Williams has not declared that she is ready to return to church. Her renewed hope is more personal than that.
But after years of feeling disappointed by the direction some fellow Christians had taken, November 3 reminded her that faith can be practiced and represented in other ways.
Sometimes, hope does not come from finding your way back to an old community. It comes from discovering that the values you believed in all along still live on in other people.