Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26, 2026, and the federal food safety site FoodSafety.gov has a clear answer for what happens to the table if the power goes out. Refrigerated gravy, stuffing, broth, casseroles, soups and stews should be discarded after more than 2 hours at 40°F or above.
Custard pies are on the same list, along with other pies that have egg or milk fillings. Fruit pies and bread can stay, according to the chart, which was last reviewed on August 8, 2024.

The Discard Side: Gravy, Stuffing and Custard Pies
The chart’s refrigerated-food list sets one rule for most items: if the food has been exposed to temperatures of 40°F or above for more than 2 hours, it goes. Gravy, stuffing and broth are named outright, along with casseroles, soups and stews.
The holiday pies come next. The chart lists custards, puddings and quiche, plus cream-filled pastries and pies with egg or milk fillings, and cheesecake. Cooked pasta, rice and potatoes, potato salad and cut fresh fruit or vegetables are also on the discard list.
The Red Cross sets a similar bar on its power outage page: throw out food that has been warmer than 40°F. It adds that an unopened refrigerator keeps foods cold for about 4 hours and a full freezer for about 48 hours, or 24 hours if half full, with the door closed.
A kitchen with a crowded refrigerator in the holiday week has more at stake than usual, and five oven checks to make before the turkey goes in covers the cooking side of the same planning. A different way to take pressure off the oven appears in a comparison of air fryers and a toaster oven that free up the oven this Thanksgiving.
The Keep Side: Fruit Pies and Bread
The same chart names what can stay. Fruit pies are on the keep list, with uncut fresh fruit, opened fruit juice, dried fruit and opened canned fruit. Bread, rolls, cakes, muffins, quick breads and tortillas are also there, along with breakfast foods such as waffles, pancakes and bagels.
Butter and margarine, hard cheeses, and condiments such as peanut butter, jelly, mustard and ketchup stay on the keep side too. Opened mayonnaise is a special case, discarded only after more than 8 hours above 50°F.
That split puts a fruit pie and a custard pie on different sides of the chart. Pies with egg or milk fillings are covered by the discard rule, while a fruit pie is not. Holiday tables carry plenty of other habits, some of which turn up in 14 strange Thanksgiving traditions that everyone pretends aren’t weird.

What Custard Is, and Why It Counts as a Filling
Wikipedia’s entry on custard defines it as sweetened milk, cream or cheese thickened by cooking with egg or egg yolk, sometimes with flour, cornstarch or gelatin. Custard begins setting around 158°F, and a fully cooked one should not exceed 176°F or it may curdle, the entry says. Savory versions such as quiche are custards too, which fits the chart’s grouping of quiche with puddings and pies.
The English word comes from the French croustade, meaning tart crust, and custard tarts were popular in the Middle Ages, according to the same entry.
Guests staying through the holiday weekend may bring dessert of their own, and five home checks to finish before houseguests arrive covers the hosting side. For those who travel to the table, a roundup of five carry-on suitcases worth packing for Thanksgiving speaks to the trip.
Where Gravy and Stuffing Come From
Wikipedia’s gravy entry describes gravy as a sauce made from the meat and vegetable juices that run during cooking, often thickened. The word comes from an Old French term for meat or fish broth, which appears as gravé or grané in 14th-century manuscripts. One of the earliest recorded English mentions is in The Forme of Cury, a 14th-century recipe book. Brown gravy is made from roasted meat drippings and thickened with flour or cornstarch, and giblet gravy uses turkey or chicken giblets or a stock made from them.
The entry notes that in North America gravy is a popular accompaniment to Thanksgiving and Christmas foods such as turkey, potatoes and stuffing.
The stuffing entry traces the dish back to a Roman cookbook attributed to Apicius. Earlier English names include farce, around 1390, stuffing in 1538 and forcemeat in 1688, while dressing is the more recent U.S. name. Poultry stuffing often includes breadcrumbs, onion, celery, spices, sage and giblets.
The entry also relays USDA guidance for turkey: cook stuffing separately, and do not buy pre-stuffed birds, because stuffing cooked inside the bird can hold bacteria even when the meat reaches a safe temperature.
What the Chart Says About Frozen Pies and Bread
Frozen food gets a separate set of checks on the FoodSafety.gov chart. For frozen cakes, pies and pastries with custard or cheese filling, the chart says to refreeze if ice crystals remain and to discard if the food warmed. Frozen casseroles and pasta- or rice-based entrees follow the same rule.
Breads, rolls, muffins and cakes without custard can be refrozen in either case, as can pie crusts and bread dough, with some loss of quality. Ice cream and frozen yogurt are discarded either way, the chart says.
Wikipedia puts the holiday date in context: a 1941 law signed by President Roosevelt on December 26, 1941, fixed Thanksgiving on the fourth Thursday of November, after it had generally fallen on the last Thursday since 1863. In 2026, that Thursday is November 26. The chart’s central numbers are simple to hold in mind for the week: 2 hours at 40°F or above for gravy, stuffing and custard pies, and 4 hours as the refrigerator window in an outage.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.