Mashed potatoes are one of the simplest dishes on the Thanksgiving table, and one of the easiest to ruin. The culprit is usually not the potato or the butter, but the tool used to mash them.
A food processor’s fast, sharp blades burst the swollen starch granules inside cooked potatoes, releasing a sticky gel that turns the mash gluey. A potato ricer, which presses the potatoes gently through small holes, keeps those granules intact and the texture fluffy, according to testing by America’s Test Kitchen.

What Happens Inside a Cooked Potato
Raw potatoes are packed with starch stored in tiny granules. When potatoes simmer in water, those granules absorb water and swell, a process called starch gelatinization. Heat and water loosen the tightly packed starch molecules, and some of the starch leaks out of the granules into the surrounding liquid.
That swelling is what turns a hard potato soft enough to mash. It also leaves the granules fragile. Handled gently, the swollen cells separate into light, fluffy crumbs. Handled roughly, they rupture and spill their starch, which then binds the mash into something closer to paste.
The America’s Test Kitchen guide to mashing methods puts it plainly: the goal is to use the gentlest touch possible to avoid bursting the potatoes’ swollen starch granules. Once they burst, the released gel makes the potatoes gluey.
A crowded holiday kitchen makes it tempting to reach for whatever gadget is fastest. Cooks juggling oven space can lean on countertop appliances, such as the options in a comparison built to free up the oven this Thanksgiving, but the potatoes are one place where speed works against the cook. Getting the oven ready ahead of time helps too, and a short list of oven checks to make before the turkey goes in keeps the rest of the meal on schedule.
Why the Food Processor Fails
A food processor spins a sharp blade at high speed, and it handles cooked potatoes far too aggressively. America’s Test Kitchen says the vigorous action of a food processor makes potatoes gluey. In a 2019 article in The Irish Times, Aoife McElwain cited the same reasoning from Martha Stewart’s kitchen guidance: never use a food processor, because the sharp blades break down a potato’s starch granules.
Electric mixers fall into the same trap. America’s Test Kitchen calls the electric mixer a real no-no unless gluey potatoes are the goal. Even a hand masher or a spoon can cause trouble if the cook keeps working the potatoes to chase out every lump, because overworking with any tool damages the starch.
Kitchen tools are only helpful when matched to the job, which is the idea behind lists of easy-to-use products that simplify everyday life at home. For mashed potatoes, the simplest tools win. Kitchens with limited drawer space may need to choose, and anyone planning a refresh on a budget can find ideas among these kitchen remodel ideas on a shoestring.
Mashed potatoes share the Thanksgiving plate with a famously popular side. Stuffing is the favorite Thanksgiving side in 38 states, and a bowl of fluffy mashed potatoes usually sits right beside it on the holiday table.
Ricer, Food Mill or Masher
America’s Test Kitchen made two identical batches of fluffy mashed potatoes, pushing one through a ricer and the other through a food mill. Tasters found the riced potatoes slightly fluffier, though also a bit grainy. The food mill batch was almost as fluffy and much smoother, and the guide calls the food mill the more versatile tool.
A potato ricer works like a large garlic press. Cooked potato goes into a hopper, and a plunger forces it through small holes, producing rice-sized strands. Because each piece is pressed through once rather than beaten, the starch granules stay mostly whole.
A food mill uses a hand-turned blade that pushes food through a perforated disc. It handles larger batches and also strains out skins, which is useful for anyone who cooks potatoes unpeeled.
The classic hand masher still has its place. America’s Test Kitchen says it works for a rustic, chunky mash, but it will not produce truly fluffy potatoes, and some lumps are inevitable even with a good workout.
Other Steps for a Better Mash
The tool is only part of the picture. The Irish Times piece suggests starting potatoes in cold water so they cook evenly; potatoes dropped into boiling water can end up overcooked outside and firm in the middle. It also suggests bringing milk and butter to room temperature before adding them to hot, drained potatoes.
Potato choice matters too. The Irish Times piece quotes food writer Susan Chen recommending either a high-starch potato, such as a tough-skinned russet, or a waxy, thin-skinned yellow potato, with Yukon Gold her pick for flavor and consistency. The basic dish is simple, as the Wikipedia entry on mashed potato describes: boiled potatoes mashed with butter and milk or cream, then seasoned. Whatever the variety, gentle handling is what protects the texture.
If a batch does turn gluey, it does not have to go to waste. The Irish Times suggests turning it into the base of a cheesy gratin, where a browned, bubbling top covers the texture. For the main event, though, the lesson from the test kitchen is simple: leave the food processor in the cabinet and reach for the ricer or the food mill.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Famartin – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons