Wine, Chocolates and Jam Make Good Host Gifts, but Emily Post Says the Host Decides Whether to Serve Them

A bottle of wine, a box of chocolates or a jar of homemade jam is a safe bet for a guest heading to a holiday dinner. The Emily Post Institute calls consumables like these great host gifts, with one important catch. The guest should not expect them to be opened that night, because “it’s up to the host to decide.”

A bottle of red wine and glasses on a table
Jez Timms – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

With Thanksgiving on Thursday, November 26, and holiday parties close behind, the question of what to bring, and whether to bring anything at all, comes up in many households. The institute’s guidance covers both.

Why the Host Gets the Final Word

The advice comes from “Etiquette Today: All About Hosting Gifts,” a July 10, 2025, post on the Emily Post Institute’s Substack, signed by Lizzie and Dan. The post lists wine, Champagne, chocolates, jams, jellies and spreads as “all great ideas,” then cautions guests not to expect the host to serve them that evening, because “it’s up to the host to decide.”

The reasoning is practical. A host has usually planned the menu, chosen the wines and set out dessert well before the doorbell rings. A gift that has to be opened and served on the spot can throw off that plan. Seeing it as something for the host to enjoy later keeps the evening on track and makes the gift a true gesture of thanks.

That idea of a gift as thanks, not payment, runs through the whole post. The institute says a host gift is always something small and easy for the host to receive, and that it should always be within the guest’s means. It also recalls a point from Emily Post’s 1938 radio show: a guest should not insult a host by suggesting that the hospitality needs a bribe.

Plenty of older manners have faded over the years, as a list of old-school etiquette rules that have disappeared shows, but the host gift has held on, along with the basics in a list of the most common dining etiquette mistakes.

When a Host Gift Is Expected

The institute lays out a few situations where a small gift is the norm:

  • A first visit to someone’s home. A small gift marks the occasion.
  • An overnight stay. Houseguests should bring or send a gift, unless the host is immediate family, and the post says the gift should come with a handwritten note of thanks.
  • A dinner party. Guests often bring a host gift, unless they are close friends who dine together often.

Overnight guests have a longer list of things to keep in mind, from tidying up to helping in the kitchen. A guide to simple etiquette tips for being the perfect houseguest covers many of them. On the other side, hosts getting ready for a full house can run through a list of home checks to finish before Thanksgiving houseguests arrive.

An open box of assorted chocolates
M0tty – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons

When a Gift Is Not Needed

The post is just as clear about when guests can skip it. According to the institute:

  • Casual dinners especially do not warrant a host gift.
  • Gifts are not usually taken to large, formal dinners, especially when the guest does not know the host well.
  • Close friends can skip the gift altogether or save it for special occasions.
  • Adult birthday parties typically do not require gifts, though a card is always appreciated.
  • A housewarming gift is not required, and hosts should not set up a registry or post a wish list.

Gift cards are a popular fallback for some of these occasions, but they come with their own pitfalls, as a list of things never to do with a gift card during the holiday season explains.

Flowers, Plants and Other Choices

Flowers are a classic choice, but the institute suggests bringing a bouquet in a vase or a mason jar when possible. That small step saves the host from hunting for a vase and trimming stems while guests are arriving. Potted plants work well, too, especially when there is something to look at, such as blooms.

For a guest of honor, the institute suggests a different approach: sending flowers ahead of the party, then following up with a handwritten note of thanks afterward, written personally rather than through a note service.

Food gifts remain the easiest option for most holiday gatherings. A bottle of wine, a box of good chocolates, a jar of jam or a small tin of homemade cookies can be set aside and enjoyed later without any work for the host.

A Long Tradition of Table Manners

Emily Post published her first etiquette book in 1922, under the title Etiquette in Society, in Business, in Politics, and at Home, according to the Wikipedia entry on Emily Post. The Emily Post Institute was founded in 1946 and is still run by her family, now in its fifth generation. The broader subject of etiquette covers the expected social behavior of a group, and dinners and visits have always been at the center of it.

The institute’s advice for the table itself is just as down to earth. Its post on 10 things not to do at the table warns against seasoning food before tasting it, noting that doing so can be insulting to the cook or host. It also advises keeping devices away from the table unless they add to the conversation.

For a holiday dinner this season, the institute’s guidance comes down to a simple rule: bring something small that the host can enjoy whenever they choose, and leave the decision about serving it to the host.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Agne27 – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

  • Emma Flavia

    Emma Flavia is a lifestyle and entertainment writer who dives into the ways people live, think, and connect in a world shaped by trends and technology. She has written for high-profile platforms such as MSN and NewsBreak, covering mental wellness, relationships, digital culture, and the latest social phenomena with insight and flair. Passionate about the human experience, Emma also finds inspiration in nature walks, minimalist digital art, experimenting with color palettes, and documentaries that explore behavior and design.

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *