Every family has one cook whose holiday dish is a tradition and whose recipe nobody else is allowed to touch. Now and then, a relative asks that cook to leave one particular item at home, and the kitchen gets quiet.
That is the situation in a Dear Abby column that ran Nov. 16, 2026, where a reader signing as “Adults Only” brings brandy-soaked desserts and fruit to family holiday gatherings. A relative asked the baker to stop, and Dear Abby suggested a middle path: a nonalcoholic batch for the children.

What the Reader Described
According to the Chicago Sun-Times version of the column, the writer loves making different sweets, including desserts and fruit soaked in brandy, and brings them to family holiday gatherings. The writer says the sweets are kept out of the children’s reach.
The same letter appears in the Arcamax Dear Abby column dated Nov. 16, 2026. Brandy is a spirit distilled from wine or other fruit, as the Wikipedia entry on brandy explains, and it has long been used to soak dried fruit and cakes for the holidays.
Why a Relative Objected
One relative asked the baker to stop bringing the sweets. That person’s children keep asking why they cannot have the fruit, and the parent is uncomfortable explaining it.
It is a small kitchen-table dilemma with a familiar shape. A sister site’s list of 6 things families quietly argue about at Thanksgiving dinner shows how often holiday food becomes the stage for a family disagreement. Hosts planning the day can also use that site’s checklist of 7 things to check in the kitchen before Thanksgiving dinner on Nov. 26.
Frenz Hub’s tips for being the perfect houseguest and its list of dining blunders to avoid offer more etiquette ideas for the holiday table, and its roundup of odd American traditions shows how many family customs are really just habits that one household never questioned.
A note on holiday pace and routines from Uncle Jo Living can also help hosts plan a season without overload, which is when small disagreements tend to boil over.
The Baker’s View of Adult-Only Sweets
The writer sees adult-only items as perfectly normal, recalling “adult punch” from their own childhood, and asks whether to comply with the request or use the moment to teach the kids a lesson about what is for grown-ups.
That framing has a long history in holiday baking. The Wikipedia page on fruitcake covers the traditional cake, and the entry on rum cake covers a close cousin, both known for their alcohol-soaked variations.
The question the writer asks is a fair one for any holiday cook: when a family member asks for a change, is the right response to give in, or to hold the line and explain? Dear Abby’s answer avoids choosing between the two.

The disagreement is not about the recipe so much as about who decides what is on the table when several households share one meal. Both sides have a point: the baker’s sweets are a family tradition, and the parent has the right to set the rules for the children. Neither position requires anyone to be a villain, which is why a compromise on the dish itself tends to work better than a ruling on who is right.
What Dear Abby Answered
Abby’s advice, as reported by the Philadelphia Inquirer’s column page, is to make a nonalcoholic version of the dish for children and for any adults who do not drink. She also joked that a parent who finds it hard to explain the rules would be well suited to explain the rules of modern society to the kids.
The answer sidesteps a standoff. The baker keeps the tradition for the adults, and the relative’s children get a version they can eat without a conversation.
How a Second Batch Could Work
A second batch is more practical than it sounds. Dried fruit can soak in apple juice, white grape juice or cider instead of brandy, and a cake can be brushed with the same liquid in place of spirits. Keeping the two batches in clearly labeled containers, or on separate plates, removes any guesswork at the table.
Dear Abby’s two-batch idea also shows how a recipe can adapt. A dessert built on dried fruit, spice and a little syrup can taste festive with a different soaking liquid, and many bakers keep a family recipe card with notes on each version. Adding a small card beside each plate, naming what is in it, is a simple courtesy that spares hosts from answering the same question repeatedly.
A Table That Works for Everyone
The dispute comes down to whose rules apply at a shared meal. A host usually sets the tone, and a guest bringing a dish does well to ask first. The Wikipedia overview of etiquette describes how such customs vary between families and cultures.
Dear Abby’s column is advice, not a rule, and each family can decide for itself. For the “Adults Only” baker, the suggestion keeps the recipe on the holiday table and keeps the peace with a relative, and the children get their own dessert to ask about. The column ran Nov. 16, 2026, and it reflects a single reader’s letter and one columnist’s reply, not a rule for every household.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Wikimedia Commons – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wikimedia Commons