Costco’s 2-Gallon Milk Packs and 25-Pound Flour Bags Make The Takeout’s List of Bulk Buys Not Worth the Price

Costco’s giant packs are built for big households, but not every bulk grocery buy pays off. The food site The Takeout put Costco’s 2-gallon milk packs and 25-pound bags of all-purpose flour on its list of grocery products that are not worth the price, because both can go stale or spoil before a typical family finishes them.

The list, written by Caroline Lefelhoc and published in December 2024, still lines up with how food storage works today. With holiday baking and big family meals ahead, it is a useful check before loading a cart.

Several plastic gallon jugs of milk lined up in a row
ChildofMidnight – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons

Why the 2-Gallon Milk Pack Made the List

Costco sells milk in 2-gallon packs. In its roundup of Costco grocery products that aren’t worth the price, The Takeout notes that milk stays fresh only about a week after opening. For a small household, the second gallon can sour before anyone gets to it.

The date stamped on a jug does not settle the question either. The USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service explains in its guide to food product dating that “Sell-By” and “Best if Used By” labels are about quality and store inventory, not safety, and that product dating is generally not required by federal rules. Signs such as an off smell or texture are the better guide.

Fridge space is the other limit. A 2-gallon pack also takes up shelf space that holiday hosts often need for other staples, the kind covered in a list of essential items to store in the refrigerator.

The 25-Pound Flour Bag and Big Spice Jars

Costco’s 25-pound bags of all-purpose flour look like a bargain for bakers. The Takeout says all-purpose flour lasts three to eight months at most at room temperature, so a household that bakes only around the holidays may not finish a bag that size in time. Flour past its prime can pick up a stale or sour smell that carries into breads and cookies.

Spices follow the same pattern. The Takeout notes that most dried herbs and ground spices start losing flavor after about one year, while whole spices such as peppercorns, allspice and caraway stay potent for about three to four years. Basil, oregano, rosemary and most seasoning blends fall into the one-year group. The two exceptions it names as worth buying in bulk are vanilla extract and salt.

Anyone who does buy the big bag needs a plan for it. Airtight bins and labeled containers help, and ideas from roundups of clever storage hacks and best practices for seasonal storage can make room in a small pantry. For kitchens with open shelving, designers’ advice on things that should not sit on open kitchen shelves is worth a look before lining up bulk bins.

A paper sack of all-purpose flour
Kenneth C. Zirkel – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Deli Meat, Olive Oil and Other Bulk Traps

Prepackaged deli turkey and ham are another item The Takeout says to skip in bulk. Once a package is opened, it says, the clock starts on a three-to-five-day window. The FoodSafety.gov cold storage chart gives the same range: opened or deli-sliced luncheon meat keeps 3 to 5 days in the refrigerator, while unopened packages keep 2 weeks. Both can be frozen for 1 to 2 months, which is one way to save a multipack.

Olive oil made the list for flavor reasons. The Takeout lists a per-liter price of about $13 and notes that extra virgin olive oil starts losing quality within about six months of opening. A huge bottle opened in November may taste flat by spring.

Other items on the list include bulk produce such as spinach and avocados, which can spoil within days; muffins sold in two packs of six, which go stale after about two days; and coffee. The Takeout puts Kirkland’s 100% Colombian coffee at about $5.66 per pound against about $5.19 per pound for Aldi’s Beaumont Classic Roast, and says opened beans can lose peak flavor within a few weeks.

What Still Makes Sense at the Warehouse

The list is not a case against Costco. The Takeout calls the 32-ounce Duke’s Mayonnaise a smart buy for dedicated fans, and it says Kirkland Signature products often match name-brand quality for less. According to Wikipedia’s Costco entry, Kirkland Signature launched in 1995 and accounts for nearly one-third of the chain’s sales, and Costco ran 634 US warehouses as of November 2025.

Canned goods are a closer call. They keep a long time, and the USDA says low-acid canned foods such as meats and vegetables hold their best quality for two to five years, while high-acid foods such as tomatoes and fruit last 12 to 18 months. The Takeout’s point is that local stores often run sales on canned items, sometimes as low as 50 cents a can, and a giant flat takes up a lot of pantry space.

A Quick Rule for Bulk Grocery Buys

The simple test is whether a household will use the whole package before it loses quality. Milk, flour, ground spices, opened deli meat and olive oil all have short windows once opened. Salt, vanilla extract and many canned goods have long ones.

Planning around those windows saves money and keeps food out of the trash. Cleaning out the fridge before a big shop also helps, and small kitchen habits matter too, such as knowing which kitchen items should never go in a dishwasher when it is time to wash the storage containers.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Jacob Blanck – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

  • Emma Flavia

    Emma Flavia is a lifestyle and entertainment writer who dives into the ways people live, think, and connect in a world shaped by trends and technology. She has written for high-profile platforms such as MSN and NewsBreak, covering mental wellness, relationships, digital culture, and the latest social phenomena with insight and flair. Passionate about the human experience, Emma also finds inspiration in nature walks, minimalist digital art, experimenting with color palettes, and documentaries that explore behavior and design.

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *