Anyone who chased an ice cream truck down the block in the 1980s remembers the agony of the choice: something on a stick, something in a cone, or something shaped like a taco. Today a lot of those freezer-case favorites have quietly vanished, replaced by new flavors and new names.
Three of the most missed are the Choco Taco, Jell-O Pudding Pops and the Eskimo Pie. One was cut in 2022, one faded out of grocery stores around 2010 and 2011, and one still exists but under a different name since 2021. Here is what happened to each of the 3, based on company statements and food-history reporting.

1. The Choco Taco, a Philadelphia Invention From 1983
The Choco Taco started as a street-vendor idea. According to the Wikipedia history of the Choco Taco, Alan Drazen, who managed mobile vendors for the Jack and Jill Ice Cream Company, came up with it in Philadelphia in 1983. It reached ice cream trucks in the spring of 1984 at a suggested price of 89 cents.
The build was simple and hard to beat: a taco-shaped waffle shell filled with ice cream and finished with a chocolate coating, easy to eat straight from the wrapper. By 1985 it was sold in 30 states as “The Original Ice Cream Taco.” Unilever picked up the brand in 1989 when it bought Gold Bond, and it eventually landed under the Klondike name. For years it even showed up at some Taco Bell restaurants, which Food Network reported kept it on the menu until 2015.
Then, in July 2022, Klondike pulled it. A Food Republic report from Oct. 21, 2024 notes that the company called it a business decision and pointed to an “unprecedented spike in demand” across its other products. Fans pushed back loudly online, and Klondike later left the door open to a return, but the original has not come back.
The closest thing on the market has been a tribute. Salt & Straw and Taco Bell teamed up on an ice cream taco in the summer of 2024, and in October 2025 Salt & Straw sold its “Tacolate,” a waffle shell filled with cinnamon ancho chili ice cream, in shops and in six-packs listed at $65, according to Food Network. For more on the snacks a generation grew up on, Frenz Hub has a roundup of foods from the ’60s that boomers loved.
2. Jell-O Pudding Pops, Frozen Pudding on a Stick
Jell-O Pudding Pops took the familiar boxed dessert and froze it. The Wikipedia entry on Pudding Pops says the idea first appeared in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, in the 1970s, and General Foods sold them under the Jell-O name with a TV campaign starring comedian Bill Cosby, who was Jell-O’s spokesman at the time.
The pops sold well. Wikipedia credits them with about $100 million in sales in their first year and roughly $300 million a year after five years. The classic box mixed chocolate, vanilla and swirled pops, and the texture was the selling point: creamier and softer than an icy popsicle, closer to a spoonful of pudding than to ice cream.
Keeping them in freezers was another story. A Chowhound feature published Dec. 9, 2025 explains that Jell-O had little experience making frozen products, which pushed up production costs, and the pops cost more than other options in the case. The brand later moved to Popsicle, which brought the pops back to grocery stores in 2004 with a changed recipe. Fans said they never tasted quite the same. Chowhound dates the end of the Popsicle version to 2010, while Wikipedia says stores began pulling them around 2011.
Today the closest option is homemade. Chowhound notes that Kraft Heinz shares a recipe and that some stores, including Kroger, have sold kits with molds and pudding mix. Households sorting out freezer space before the holidays can first run through a handy list of fridge and freezer checks to make before the big grocery run. Pudding Pops also fit right in with the other things on a nostalgic list of items in nearly every 1980s kitchen.

3. The Eskimo Pie, America’s First Chocolate-Coated Ice Cream Bar
The Eskimo Pie is the oldest of the 3 and, in a way, the only survivor. According to the Wikipedia history of the Eskimo Pie, Christian Kent Nelson, a schoolteacher and candy store owner in Onawa, Iowa, came up with the idea in 1920 after a boy in his shop could not decide between ice cream and a chocolate bar. He filed for a patent in 1921, sold it at first under a different name, and partnered with chocolate maker Russell C. Stover to produce it on a large scale.
A Tasting Table article from Nov. 10, 2024 describes it as the first chocolate-coated ice cream bar on the market, arriving a year before the Klondike Bar. Its foil wrapper became part of its identity, and for decades the bar was a familiar summer pick, about as classic as the drinks on Frenz Hub’s classic lemonade recipe page.
The name is what disappeared. In 2020, Dreyer’s, the brand’s owner, announced it would retire the Eskimo Pie name, calling it derogatory; many Inuit, Yupik and Aleut people consider the word offensive. The bar returned in 2021 as Edy’s Pie, honoring Dreyer’s co-founder Joseph Edy. The packaging also dropped the old illustration of a boy in Indigenous clothing. Dreyer’s is now part of Froneri, according to Wikipedia.
So anyone searching the freezer case for the old foil wrapper will not find it, but the chocolate-covered vanilla bar itself is still there under its new label. For a summer day out that might include an ice cream stop, Frenz Hub has a list of U.S. theme parks for summertime.
Why These Freezer Favorites Still Draw a Crowd
All 3 had something in common: they turned an everyday dessert into a novelty that fit in one hand. The Choco Taco borrowed the shape of a taco, Pudding Pops froze a pantry staple, and the Eskimo Pie wrapped ice cream in a candy-bar coating more than a century ago.
Their stories also show how a freezer-case product can disappear for very different reasons. The Choco Taco lost out to production priorities, Pudding Pops struggled with cost and a recipe change, and the Eskimo Pie kept its recipe but lost its name. For shoppers who miss them, the options today are a tribute version, a homemade batch or a box with a new label.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Stephanie from Austin TX – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons