After a big holiday breakfast, the cast iron skillet often ends up at the bottom of the sink under a pile of plates, filling with warm water while everyone heads for the couch. By morning, a ring of orange rust is waiting.
Cast iron maker Lodge lists 6 habits on its care pages that lead to rust or sticky pans, from soaking the skillet in the sink to letting it air dry. With Thanksgiving cooking about to put every pan to work, here is what the manufacturer says to skip and what to do instead.

1. Soaking the Skillet in the Sink
This is the big one. On its cast iron cleaning page, Lodge answers the soaking question with a flat no, calling it “a recipe for rust.” Bare iron left sitting in water starts to oxidize, and a long soak can loosen the seasoning layer that keeps food from sticking.
The better move is to clean the pan while it is still warm. Lodge suggests a nylon brush or a pan scraper for stuck-on bits, followed by warm, soapy water. The point is to keep the pan’s time in water as short as possible. A few other clever kitchen tricks for home cooks follow the same idea of cleaning while things are warm.
2. Running It Through the Dishwasher
Lodge says its cast iron should be washed by hand, because a dishwasher “will remove the seasoning and likely cause rust.” The long hot cycle, the strong detergent and the steam all work against the oil layer baked onto the surface.
Appliance makers agree. In its guide to what is and is not dishwasher safe, Whirlpool says cast iron and enameled cast iron should never go in the dishwasher. Skillets belong with the other everyday kitchen items that should never go in a dishwasher. For anyone whose machine already smells a bit off from holiday loads, there is a guide to cleaning a dishwasher to cut smells and dirt.
One myth Lodge clears up along the way: dish soap is fine. The company says modern dish soap is no longer strong enough to strip seasoning from cast iron, so a squirt of soap in warm water is part of its standard wash.
3. Letting It Air Dry
A skillet left on the rack to drip dry is one of the four rust causes Lodge names on its cast iron troubleshooting page. The others are soaking, the dishwasher and damp storage. Even a thin film of water left on the surface can leave spots by the next day.
Lodge’s fix is to dry the pan right away and completely with a paper towel or lint-free cloth. The care routine on the Lodge cast iron care overview boils down to three steps: wash, dry and rub with oil.

4. Storing It in a Moisture-Prone Spot
Lodge lists cookware “left in moisture-prone environments” as another path to rust. In many kitchens that means the cabinet under the sink, a shelf next to the dishwasher vent, or a stack of pans in a humid pantry or basement. Holiday weeks add extra steam from simmering pots, which makes a damp cabinet even damper.
A dry cabinet away from the sink and the dishwasher is a safer home. Some cooks tuck a paper towel between stacked skillets so air can move and moisture does not get trapped. That kind of shelf planning fits right in with the oven and counter prep many households do in late November, including the oven checks to make before the turkey goes in, and it pairs well with moving a few sides to countertop appliances to free up the oven this Thanksgiving.
5. Using Too Much Oil
Oil protects cast iron, but more is not better. Lodge says a sticky or gummy surface is “a sign of excess oil built up” on the pan. The goal after each wash is a thin layer spread over the whole surface with a paper towel, and Lodge says the oil should not run or drip when the skillet is tilted.
There is food science behind that rule. According to the Wikipedia entry on cookware seasoning, seasoning is a layer of fat that has polymerized and hardened under heat, and it builds best in very thin coats. That is why Lodge ties a tacky surface to excess oil rather than to too little. To fix a sticky pan, Lodge says to bake it upside down on the top oven rack at 450 to 500°F for one hour.
6. Scrubbing With Steel Wool Every Day
Steel wool and metal scrubbers have a place, but Lodge does not recommend them for daily cleanup. Used every night, they can wear away the seasoning that took months of cooking to build. For regular washing, Lodge points to a stiff-bristled brush, a scrubbing pad or a pan scraper.
The heavy tools come out only for rust. Lodge says it is fine to use steel wool to scrub away rust spots, then wash, dry completely and coat the pan inside and out with a very thin layer of cooking oil. After that, the pan goes upside down in a 450 to 500°F oven for one hour and cools in the oven. Rust on the surface rarely means a pan is ruined, and the Wikipedia overview of cast-iron cookware describes the same cycle of seasoning and reseasoning that keeps old skillets in use.
The best upkeep, Lodge says, is simply to keep cooking in it. Every batch of cornbread, seared steak or fried potatoes adds to the seasoning, and a skillet that gets a quick wash, a full dry and a light coat of oil should be ready for the next holiday meal.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Taylorderek – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons