A birthday cake recipe calls for cake flour, the pantry shelf holds only a bag of all-purpose, and the store is closed for the night. That small kitchen standoff has a tested answer. According to King Arthur Baking, a baker can whisk 3/4 cup plus 2 tablespoons (105 g) of all-purpose flour with 2 tablespoons (14 g) of cornstarch and use the mix in place of cake flour.
The reverse swap gets a firmer warning. King Arthur advises against dropping cake flour into a recipe written for all-purpose flour on a 1 for 1 basis, and the King Arthur cake flour guide explains why. The two directions are not mirror images, and the numbers show it.
.jpg?width=1600)
The 105 Grams and 14 Grams That Stand In for Cake Flour
The recipe is short. Measure 3/4 cup plus 2 tablespoons of all-purpose flour, which King Arthur lists as 105 g, and add 2 tablespoons of cornstarch, listed as 14 g. Whisk the two together until the color is even, then use the blend in place of cake flour by equal weight or volume.
The weights matter more than the spoons. A flour scoop packed tight can hold noticeably more than one lightly spooned, so bakers who own a kitchen scale have an easy advantage here. Home cooks who like to keep a tidy pantry can see more tricks in a roundup of clever kitchen tricks for home cooks, which covers a few other quick fixes. Home bakers have been improvising with the pantry for generations, as a look back at kitchen staples of the 1970s shows.
Why Cornstarch Lowers the Protein in the Bowl
Flour types differ mainly by protein, the part that builds gluten when batter is mixed. King Arthur lists its unbleached cake flour at 10% protein and its all-purpose flour at 11.7%. Wikipedia describes cake flour as a finely milled soft-wheat flour with a protein range of 8% to 10%, the lowest of the American flour types it describes, which is why the cake flour entry points to soft-textured cakes and cookies as its natural use.
Replacing 2 tablespoons of the flour with cornstarch dilutes the mixture. In King Arthur’s words, the cornstarch adds tenderness and lowers the overall protein content of the mixture to mimic that of cake flour.
All-purpose alone is usually an acceptable swap too, according to the same guide. The cake may come out with a slightly coarser crumb and less tenderness. King Arthur notes that its Traditional Angel Food Cake recipe allows either flour, and that cake flour gives a taller, more tender angel food cake.
What Happens When Cake Flour Goes Into an All-Purpose Recipe
A recipe built around all-purpose flour counts on that 11.7% protein for structure. Cake flour at 10% supplies less of it. King Arthur quotes baker Molly Marzalek-Kelly saying that swapping cake flour 1 for 1 into a recipe developed for all-purpose flour might result in sunken cake or bars.
A recipe that asks for all-purpose flour has already done its math, and the bake can sag in the middle when that math changes. Oven temperature matters too, and an oven check ahead of the turkey can rule out a pan that bakes unevenly before flour gets the blame, while a comparison of air fryers and toaster ovens for Thanksgiving looks at ways to free up the main oven. Anyone who keeps both flours around may want a labeled bin for each, and a feature on 16 kitchen organization ideas offers storage layouts that make this easy.

Bread Flour and Self-Rising Flour Sit at Opposite Ends
The same page of numbers helps with the other swaps. According to King Arthur’s bread flour substitution test, its bread flour is 12.7% protein against 11.7% for all-purpose, and the two can trade places in a pinch at the same quantity. Bread flour absorbs slightly more liquid, so the dough runs stiffer. King Arthur says to add a little water if the dough seems dry.
Self-rising flour is a different story. King Arthur’s self-rising flour article lists it at 8.5% protein and says it does not recommend using self-rising flour and bread flour as substitutes for each other. Self-rising flour already carries baking powder and salt, which Wikipedia notes in its entry on self-raising flour, so swapping it in changes the leavening as well as the protein.
Put side by side, the King Arthur figures line up like this: self-rising at 8.5%, cake flour at 10%, all-purpose at 11.7% and bread flour at 12.7%. Moving one step along that ladder is usually forgiving. Moving farther along it is where King Arthur’s warnings begin.
A Swap Worth Keeping for the Holiday Baking Week
Thanksgiving falls on Nov. 26 this year, and the days before it fill with baking. Pie crusts, dinner rolls and a cake or two often all start from the same few bags of flour. A pantry stocked with all-purpose and a box of cornstarch covers the cake flour gap without another store run.
The takeaway from King Arthur is practical and compact. All-purpose plus 2 tablespoons of cornstarch stands in for cake flour. Cake flour for all-purpose at 1 for 1 is the swap to skip, and bread flour and self-rising flour should not be traded for each other. When a recipe names a flour, the flour in the recipe has usually earned its place, and the figures above show how far from it a baker can stray.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: congerdesign – CC0/Wikimedia Commons