Consumer Reports Found Albertsons Priced 24.8% Above Walmart, Publix 20.3% and Kroger 14.8%, While Costco Ran 21.4% Below

Two shoppers can walk out with the same cart of cereal, chicken and bananas and pay very different totals, depending only on which banner hangs over the door. A widely shared Consumer Reports comparison put numbers on that gap, with Albertsons priced 24.8% above Walmart, Publix 20.3% above and Kroger 14.8% above, while Costco ran 21.4% below.

The figures were recirculated on Nov. 9, 2026, by 24/7 Wall St., but the underlying prices are older: they were collected in late summer 2025 and the results were published in February 2026. That timing matters for anyone using the percentages to plan a shopping trip this week, and it is spelled out below along with what the study measured.

Produce display inside a Walmart with pineapples, citrus and cantaloupes under Everyday Low Price signs
Missvain – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

What the Comparison Found

According to the 24/7 Wall St. report carried on Webull, Consumer Reports priced a national-brand grocery basket at 35 chains in six metro areas, using Walmart as the baseline. Albertsons came in 24.8% higher, Publix 20.3% higher and Kroger 14.8% higher.

The same report lists the chains that came in cheaper than Walmart: Costco at 21.4% lower, BJ’s Wholesale at 21% lower, Lidl at 8.5% lower and Aldi at 8.3% lower. It adds that Aldi’s edge ranged from 4% in Los Angeles to 16.3% in Virginia Beach, so the gap depended on the city.

Who Was Pricier Than Walmart

Other outlets that covered the February release list more chains. International Business Times, in a story dated March 11, 2026, reported national averages of 39.7% higher for Whole Foods, 31.9% for Shaw’s, 30.1% for El Rancho, 29.7% for Jewel-Osco, 26.6% for Vons, 24.8% for Albertsons and 24.6% for Trader Joe’s.

Sporked reported on Feb. 19, 2026, that Food 4 Less ran about 9% above Walmart and that Trader Joe’s ranged from about 15% to 33% higher depending on the metro area. Those spreads show why one national percentage cannot describe every store in every town.

Who Beat Walmart on Price

Sporked reported that Costco was about 21.4% cheaper nationally and 37% cheaper in Boston. It also said the BJ’s figure was based only on that chain’s Boston location, which is worth remembering before using 21% as a national rule. WinCo and H-E-B were described as marginally cheaper, and the International Business Times listed them at 3.3% and 0.2% lower.

Shoppers who track bargains may also enjoy a look at things that are actually getting cheaper, a reminder that price gaps move over time.

Several craftingyourhome.com pieces cover the household side of grocery math, including a rundown of state grocery help in Illinois and Connecticut and a guide to joint household budget meetings. For more ways to trim a weekly total, frugal living tips and a roundup of products Americans overpay for offer starting points.

Exterior of a Kroger grocery store with a snowy parking lot and shopping carts
JBTHEMILKER – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

How the Baskets Were Priced

A Martha Stewart Living report republished by AOL on Feb. 19, 2026, said Strategic Resource Group, a retail and grocery research firm, did the work for Consumer Reports and found a 33% gap between the highest and lowest prices within each city. It also said comparisons were most reliable for mainstream retailers carrying identical national brands, and that Costco was about 37% cheaper than Walmart in Boston but 16.8% cheaper in Virginia Beach.

A Salon summary on Feb. 20, 2026, of the Consumer Reports and Strategic Resource Group study said prices were compared at more than 30 retailers across six metro areas: Boston, Chicago, Dallas-Fort Worth, Denver, Virginia Beach and greater Los Angeles. Data was collected in person in late summer 2025, with each metro’s prices gathered within 48 hours.

Baskets covered packaged goods, produce and meat, and contents varied by store depending on availability. Final prices reflected sale prices and free store loyalty-card discounts, but not manufacturer coupons or app-only savings. A shopper who clips coupons or uses a store app could land at a different total than the study found.

Brian Vines, deputy editor at Consumer Reports, was quoted by the International Business Times saying that a mix of retailers keeps pricing competitive and selections robust for consumers.

What Kroger and Walmart Said About Prices

Kroger’s own comments add context. Grocery Dive reported on May 22, 2026, that CEO Greg Foran, who took the job in February 2026 after leading Walmart’s U.S. grocery business, told Bloomberg that Kroger plans large-scale price cuts. He gave no timing or cost and said the company would test them first.

Foran acknowledged that matching low-price rivals such as Walmart, Costco and Aldi is difficult but that Kroger must narrow the gap, and that the company would import more products directly and use technology to help pay for the cuts. Walmart said on the same day that it had expanded price cuts to more than 7,000 items. Because those moves came after the 2025 price collection, current gaps may differ from the February figures.

Using the Numbers Without Overreading Them

The percentages describe a specific basket in six metros at one point in time, so they work best as a rough ranking rather than a bill prediction. A household buying mostly meat and produce, for example, might see a different spread than one buying mostly packaged goods. Anyone weighing stores can price a repeat list at two nearby banners over a few weeks, then check the result against the study.

The headline numbers are easy to repeat: Albertsons 24.8% above Walmart, Publix 20.3%, Kroger 14.8%, and Costco 21.4% below. The less-quoted details, from Boston-only BJ’s data to the exclusion of coupons and app deals, decide how far those figures travel, and prices at any given store can change from one trip to the next.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Computermusic1999 (Nicholas Osorio) – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

  • Emma Flavia

    Emma Flavia is a lifestyle and entertainment writer who dives into the ways people live, think, and connect in a world shaped by trends and technology. She has written for high-profile platforms such as MSN and NewsBreak, covering mental wellness, relationships, digital culture, and the latest social phenomena with insight and flair. Passionate about the human experience, Emma also finds inspiration in nature walks, minimalist digital art, experimenting with color palettes, and documentaries that explore behavior and design.

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *