Holiday Baker Asks Dear Abby Whether to Keep Bringing Brandy-Soaked Desserts and Fruit to Family Gatherings After a Relative Objects

A reader who enjoys baking for the holidays has asked advice columnist Dear Abby whether to keep bringing brandy-soaked desserts and fruit to family gatherings after a relative asked for them to stay home. The column, written by Abigail Van Buren and published Nov. 16, 2026, drew its answer from a simple idea: make a version without alcohol for anyone who wants it.

The exchange appeared in a column titled “Holiday Desserts For Grown-Ups Spark Controversy,” carried by ArcaMax and distributed by Andrews McMeel Syndication. The reader is not named, and nothing in the column identifies the family involved.

A sliced traditional fruitcake studded with dried fruit and nuts
Wikimedia Commons contributor – CC BY-SA 2.0

What the letter described

According to the column, the writer’s family gathers for holidays and the writer likes to make sweets, including desserts and fruit soaked in brandy. The writer says those dishes are kept well away from children. One relative objected and asked the writer not to bring them, saying that the relative’s kids keep asking why they cannot have the brandied fruit and that explaining it feels uncomfortable.

The writer does not see a problem. Growing up, the family always had an adult punch that the kids could not have, so to the writer the answer is straightforward: some things are for adults. The writer also suspects that the hosts are trying to avoid a family rift, and asked whether to go along with the kids’ wishes or use the situation as a teaching moment.

Abby’s answer

Dear Abby’s suggested fix is to prepare a nonalcoholic version of the dish and offer it to any minors or abstaining adults who want some. She also teased the objecting parent, saying that if explaining grown-up rules to children is hard, the writer would be an “excellent candidate for the job.”

The column is brief, and Abby does not weigh in on whether the brandied version should return in later years. The page gives no recipe and no further detail on the dishes, so the specifics of the writer’s brandied fruit remain unknown. What the column does offer is a plain compromise that keeps the baker’s tradition and answers the parent’s concern.

How etiquette guidance approaches the question

Etiquette experts generally frame such disputes around the host’s wishes. The Emily Post Institute’s holiday guidance says guests should offer to bring something but leave the menu to the host, and that a host should expect to be “coordination central.” In AARP’s Modern Manners column, etiquette writer Lizzie Post says guests should ask the host what to bring and should not bring anything beyond what was requested.

By those standards, the relative who asked the baker to leave the brandied desserts at home is making the kind of request that etiquette guidance says hosts can make, and the baker’s other option is to ask what would be welcome in place of the usual dish.

Holiday customs shift from household to household and generation to generation. Frenzhub’s look at odd American traditions shows how quickly family habits can look unusual from outside, and its list of 15 foods from the 60s that boomers loved is a reminder of how dessert tastes have changed. A sister-site report on holiday rituals from midcentury American homes that have faded adds more on how gatherings have changed, and another piece on ways husbands and wives can stay connected through a busy holiday season looks at the pressure that comes with family gatherings.

The retro angle has a fun side too. Frenzhub’s feature on slang from the swinging 60s revisits a decade that many older relatives remember well.

Spirit-soaked desserts have a long history

The tradition the writer describes is an old one. According to Wikipedia’s entry on fruitcake, spirits have been part of the holiday cake for centuries: in 17th-century England, rum and dried fruit helped extend a cake’s shelf life, and heavily soaked cakes can keep for years. Regional versions include the rum-soaked Caribbean black cake, and the entry notes that fruitcakes are most often linked with Christmas and weddings.

Fruit preserved in spirits has its own tradition as well. Wikipedia describes rumtopf, the German word for “rum pot,” as a dessert of mixed fruit preserved in strong rum and sugar that is made in Austria, Germany and Denmark and traditionally eaten around Christmas. Fruit is added to a stoneware pot as each kind comes into season, and the mixture matures for several months. It is usually served as a compote over pound cake, waffles, baked apples or ice cream.

A fruitcake on a plate with candied fruit visible in the slice
Matthew Bietz from Cerritos, USA – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Keeping the tradition and the peace

The column’s answer rests on a simple trade. A nonalcoholic version means the baker can still arrive with something homemade, and it gives children and abstaining adults something to try. It also speaks to the relative’s stated concern, which was the difficulty of explaining to children why one dish is off limits.

Nothing in the column says how the relative or the hosts responded, and the outcome is unknown. The takeaway is a practical one: when a family dish causes friction, a second version of it can keep the tradition alive without leaving anyone out.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: TheMightyGrog – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

  • Emma Flavia

    Emma Flavia is a lifestyle and entertainment writer who dives into the ways people live, think, and connect in a world shaped by trends and technology. She has written for high-profile platforms such as MSN and NewsBreak, covering mental wellness, relationships, digital culture, and the latest social phenomena with insight and flair. Passionate about the human experience, Emma also finds inspiration in nature walks, minimalist digital art, experimenting with color palettes, and documentaries that explore behavior and design.

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *