9 Thanksgiving Staples Rarely Seen on Tables Anymore: Creamed Onions, Mincemeat Pie, Giblet Gravy, Mashed Turnips and the Relish Tray

On Thanksgiving, someone at the table always asks the same question as the dishes are passed: whatever happened to the creamed onions? The meal changes slowly, but over a few decades whole dishes can slip off the menu without anyone deciding to drop them.

With Thanksgiving on Nov. 26, three outlets have looked at what has faded. Hello! magazine, in a piece by Romy Journee published Nov. 26, 2025, lists 9 Thanksgiving staples from the 1980s that have disappeared from tables. A Fox report carried by Fox 13 Tampa Bay and a Nov. 2, 2024 article by Chloë James at The Takeout add more. All 9 Hello! dishes are covered below, as nostalgia and not as a count of what households actually serve.

A lattice-topped mincemeat pie baked in a foil pan
Valereee – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

Jell-O Salads, Canned Cranberry Sauce and Bisquick

Hello! starts with sweet Jell-O salads, which combined flavored gelatin with canned fruit and Cool Whip. Popular 1980s versions included cottage cheese and Jell-O salads garnished with marshmallows or chopped nuts, the pistachio-based Watergate salad and Lime Jell-O Fluff. The magazine calls them the pineapple on pizza of the holiday menu: some tables banned them and others cherished them. For more on the arguments that follow a holiday dish, see these things families quietly argue about at Thanksgiving dinner.

Canned cranberry sauce, the jellied slices with the ridges still on them, was the standard 1980s side, and Hello! says it has had a resurgence on social media. Bisquick was the all-rounder: it made quick biscuits, thickened gravy and topped casseroles. The brand is still sold, but Hello! says fresh bakery-style breads and instant options have largely taken its place at the holiday meal. Cooks planning this year’s menu may like this list of 15 foods from the 60s that boomers loved.

Oyster Stuffing and Giblet Gravy

Oyster stuffing combined bread cubes, butter, herbs and oysters, and Hello! says it was especially popular on the East Coast and Gulf Coast. Fox reports that it was a staple in the 1800s, when oysters could be bought from refrigerated railcars, and that it fell out of favor in the Northeast as oyster populations declined and tastes shifted to ingredients such as sausage. Hello! says the dish survives in some households, particularly in Creole and Cajun cooking in Louisiana, while the higher cost of oysters nudged it out of wide rotation. Stuffing in general is still a headline act, as in this report that stuffing is the favorite Thanksgiving side in 38 states, and hosts short on oven space can look at this air fryer and toaster oven comparison to free up the oven.

Giblet gravy was made by simmering the turkey’s giblets with aromatics. Fox says the old method faded partly because modern turkeys are sold without giblets and store-bought gravy mixes are more convenient, citing The Daily Meal. Hello! adds that it is now less common outside families preserving classic recipes.

Creamed Onions and Mashed Turnips

Creamed onions, a mid-century classic that carried into the 1980s, were pearl onions simmered in a white sauce, often served in casserole dishes or ramekins. Hello! blames the dish’s tedious prep, since each tiny onion must be peeled, and a modern taste for roasted vegetables. Wikipedia’s entry on the pearl onion describes it as a relative of the leek.

Mashed turnips were a frugal vegetable that mashed well, served alone or mixed with mashed potatoes. Hello! says they have mostly been replaced by sweeter root vegetables such as carrots or sweet potatoes. Fox adds that turnips were once seen as a poor man’s vegetable, and says food experts think the humble root could make a comeback. Readers interested in thrifty foods can see poor people foods that even the wealthy eat.

Small mincemeat tarts baked for the holidays
Jengod – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Mincemeat Pie

Hello! describes mincemeat pie as a divisive dish carried over from earlier decades, filled with dried fruit, apples and spices and often featuring suet or finely diced meat. It tended to win over adults more than children, and it has largely ceded its spot to pumpkin, pecan and apple pies. Wikipedia’s page on mincemeat defines it as a mixture of chopped apples and dried fruit, spirits or vinegar and spices, with beef suet optional.

The Takeout says mincemeat disappeared from Thanksgiving tables a long time ago, and quotes culinary historian Linda Pelaccio on why: once there was less need to preserve meat, there was less need to make mincemeat. Both outlets agree on the outcome, even if they disagree on when the dish left.

The Relish Tray

Before charcuterie boards took over, the relish tray was the standard 1980s appetizer, with pickles, peppers and other vegetables arranged on a platter as a light opener before richer dishes. Hello! says charcuterie and cheese boards have mostly replaced it, though pickles and relishes still appear beside them. Wikipedia’s entry on crudités covers a similar idea, French appetizers of raw vegetables served with dipping sauces.

More Dishes From Fox and The Takeout

Fox also names ambrosia salad, corn pudding and cranberry fluff among dishes that have faded. The Takeout says ambrosia took off in the 1920s after Stephen F. Whitman & Son paid food columnists to promote its marshmallow whip, and that Campbell’s home economist Dorcas Reilly created green bean casserole in the 1950s, a dish that did stay on the table. Wikipedia’s page on Thanksgiving dinner describes it as a large meal generally centered on a roasted turkey.

These lists are about memory and taste, so every dish here still turns up somewhere. Any of them can return with a family recipe and a willing cook.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Paulo O – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *