Picture a long table pushed against a living room wall, twenty-odd chairs, platters of turkey and stuffing moving hand to hand, and a steady hum of talk that never quite reaches the end of the table. One guest sits in the middle of it with a plate and nobody to talk to. That is the scene a single man described in a letter to Dear Abby, and it plays out in plenty of family dining rooms every November.
His question was simple: would it be wrong to decline the Thanksgiving and Christmas invitations? According to the Dear Abby column run by the Philadelphia Inquirer on Oct. 19, 2026, the columnist told him he is in charge of his own choices and offered two ways forward: step into the conversations, or stop by briefly, greet the relatives and head out to friends or home.
.jpg?width=1600)
A Table for 15 to 25 That Breaks Into Cliques
The letter writer signed off as “Invisible in the Crowd.” By his own account, he is happy with his life and has plenty of friends and family. He is invited to Thanksgiving and Christmas gatherings of 15 to 25 people, and he sees many of those relatives only once or twice a year.
The trouble, he wrote, is that the crowd splits into cliques and no one engages him in conversation. He said he had mentioned it to family, who acknowledged the problem, yet nothing changed. The same column also ran on the Chicago Sun-Times site under the headline about family holiday gatherings feeling lonely for a single guy, which confirms the details of the letter.
Anyone who has hosted a big meal knows how it happens. The cook is in the kitchen, the cousins who see each other weekly cluster by the stove, and the guest who shows up twice a year has to find his own way in. A recent piece on families that keep the exact same holiday traditions every year shows how deeply these gatherings are woven into family routines, and a look at little rituals from the 1980s and 1990s that faded shows how quickly customs can shift.
Option One: Walk Over to the Group and Join the Talk
Dear Abby’s first suggestion was practical. Rather than sitting alone on the sofa, the writer could walk up to a group and try to join in. A holiday meal gives a guest plenty of easy openings, from offering to carry a dish to the table to asking who made the cranberry sauce.
Etiquette writers tend to point guests toward small, concrete moves. The Emily Post Institute’s table manners tips, for example, suggest asking for dishes to be passed and keeping phones away during the meal, both of which keep a guest at the table and in the conversation.
Hosts of crowded dinners have their own tools. A recent comparison of coffee makers for fall mornings and holiday guests is a reminder that a coffee station can give guests a spot to gather and chat away from the main table.
.jpg?width=1600)
Option Two: Stop By Briefly, Greet Everyone, Then Leave
The second path Abby described is shorter. The writer could attend for a short while, offer holiday greetings to the relatives he wants to see, and then go spend the rest of the day with friends or at home. Many families see the late-afternoon plate-and-dessert hour as exactly that kind of drop-in window.
A short visit also fits the way the holidays are celebrated across the country. Thanksgiving falls on the fourth Thursday of November, a date fixed by federal law in 1941, according to Wikipedia’s entry on the holiday, and the day often stretches across several households. This year it lands on Nov. 26, and many families split the day between more than one table. A roundup of American traditions that puzzle visitors from abroad shows how varied these customs are, and a report on a Georgia restaurant opening on Thanksgiving evening for people who would otherwise eat alone shows another way people find a seat on the day.
For a guest in the writer’s position, a brief appearance keeps the connection with relatives while skipping the part of the afternoon that does not work for him.
No Explanation Owed When a Seat Stays Empty
The writer had asked whether declining would be wrong. Abby’s answer was that he does not owe the hosts an explanation for skipping an event. Politeness, in her view, does not require a long account of why a chair is empty.
Plenty of readers will recognize both sides of this. Hosts who set 25 places have often shopped, cooked and rearranged furniture for days, and an invitation is a way of saying a person is wanted. A guest who feels overlooked is not rejecting that welcome; he is asking for a way to take part. Declining one can feel like a big step.
A warm note ahead of time, thanking the host and mentioning a short visit, is one way to handle it. Dear Abby’s advice leaves that choice with the writer.
A Column That Has Fielded Table Questions Since 1956
Dear Abby began in 1956, written by Pauline Phillips under the pen name Abigail Van Buren, according to Wikipedia’s entry on the column. Its mailbag has long included the small dramas of family dinners, from who gets invited to who sits where.
This letter sits squarely in that tradition. It has no villain. Relatives are not unkind, the writer is not complaining about the food, and nobody is accused of anything. It is just a large group, a long table and a guest who wants to feel included.
For readers heading into the Nov. 26 holiday with a similar feeling, the column offers a short list: join a conversation, drop in for a bit, or stay home without a speech. Meanwhile, hosts could take a cue from the letter. A seat beside the guest who arrives alone, or a question that draws him into the kitchen conversation, may do more than any extra side dish.
The advice from the page is plain, and the letter writer is the one who decides which plate to fill and when to head home.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Paulo O – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons