There’s something comforting about opening the freezer on a Friday night and discovering a pizza waiting inside. No delivery fees, no complicated recipes, and no arguments about who’s cooking dinner. Just turn on the oven, grab a baking sheet, and dinner is practically handled.
But anyone who’s tried different frozen pizzas knows they’re not all created equal. Some deliver a crispy crust, generous toppings, and satisfying cheese. Others leave you wondering whether you should have ordered takeout.
Frozen pizza remains big business in America. According to Yahoo Shopping, U.S. frozen pizza sales exceeded $8 billion in 2025.
So which brands deserve space in your freezer? This editorial ranking draws on published taste tests, product details, price examples, and overall value. It isn’t a new hands-on taste test, and individual varieties can perform differently. Here’s how 12 familiar brands compare, starting with the least compelling picks and working toward the strongest contenders.
Related:5 Frozen Pizzas You Should Avoid Due to Serious Cancer Risks
Tombstone
Tombstone has been a familiar freezer-aisle name for years, and its relatively affordable price remains part of its appeal.
The Original Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza comes in a 19.3-ounce package, with Walmart listings placing it around $5.
But affordability doesn’t guarantee a memorable pizza night. In a 2025 Washington Post blind taste test, Tombstone’s five-cheese variety tied for sixth place among 11 pizzas. Reviewers had mixed feelings about the cheese and were less impressed by the crust.
For shoppers who prioritize price, Tombstone still has a place. Those expecting an especially crispy or substantial crust may want to compare alternatives.
Related:10 Best Pizza Peel of 2026: Ultimate Guide for Home Chefs
California Pizza Kitchen
California Pizza Kitchen brings restaurant-inspired flavors into the frozen food section, including its popular BBQ Chicken Pizza.
The 14.7-ounce pizza is listed at Target for about $7.89.
Instead of a traditional pepperoni-and-tomato combination, this variety leans into barbecue flavors, making it a different choice for pizza night.
That creativity can also be its weakness. Families expecting a classic pizza may not appreciate the sweeter sauce and unconventional toppings.
It’s worth considering for barbecue chicken fans, but less versatile for households that prefer traditional pizza.
Related:12 American Foods Named After the Places They Come From, From the Philly Cheesesteak to Key Lime Pie
Red Baron
Red Baron proves that a familiar supermarket pizza doesn’t need a premium price tag.
Its Classic Crust Pepperoni Pizza, weighing about 20.6 ounces, is listed at Walmart for around $4.25 to $4.85.
The combination of tomato sauce, cheese, and pepperoni keeps things simple.
Interestingly, Red Baron performed exceptionally well in Yahoo’s June 2026 blind taste test. Its Classic Crust Four Cheese Pizza won the cheese-pizza category.
That result doesn’t automatically make the pepperoni version a winner, but it suggests the brand deserves more attention than its modest pricing might imply.
Could Red Baron be one of the freezer aisle’s most underrated names?
Related:9 Best Outdoor Pizza Ovens: Top Picks for 2026
Home Run Inn
Chicago-based Home Run Inn offers a different experience from the thick, bread-like pizzas found in many freezer sections.
Its Classic Cheese Pizza features a thin, crispy crust, and the research brief lists a 27-ounce package around $7 at Walmart.
The brand is especially interesting because published taste tests have produced sharply different reactions.
In October 2025, The Washington Post conducted a follow-up tasting based on reader favorites. Home Run Inn finished first, beating DiGiorno.
That result makes its lower placement here debatable. People who enjoy tavern-style pizza could easily rank Home Run Inn much higher.
Freschetta
Freschetta appeals to shoppers who want a frozen pizza with a thick, substantial crust.
Its Naturally Rising Crust Pepperoni variety weighs approximately 27 ounces and has been listed at around $5.82.
The crust is the main attraction, offering a different texture from thinner frozen pizzas.
In The Washington Post’s 2025 tasting, Freschetta’s Four Cheese version ranked fifth among 11 contenders. Some reviewers appreciated its fluffy crust, while others considered it overly doughy.
That disagreement captures Freschetta’s biggest selling point and potential drawback.
If your family enjoys thick crust, it’s worth considering. Thin-crust loyalists may disagree.
365 by Whole Foods Market
Whole Foods might not be the first place budget-conscious shoppers look for frozen pizza, but its 365 store brand is worth considering.
The Thin Crust Four Cheese Pizza appeared in The Washington Post’s 2025 tasting at $5.49 for a 12.5-ounce package.
It finished second among 11 pizzas, earning positive feedback for its crust and tomato-forward sauce.
The smaller size matters, however. A pizza that looks reasonably priced on the shelf isn’t necessarily the most economical option for feeding several people.
For smaller households or shoppers who prefer thin crust, this one has considerable appeal.
Kirkland Signature
Costco shoppers already know that buying in bulk can make family meals easier.
Kirkland Signature’s frozen cheese pizza comes in a four-pack, with the tested package containing four 18.25-ounce pizzas.
The Washington Post reported a $11.79 package price during its 2025 evaluation, placing Kirkland third in that tasting.
Having several pizzas ready in the freezer can be convenient for busy families, particularly when unexpected guests arrive.
The trade-off is freezer space and the commitment to buying multiple pizzas at once.
For households that eat frozen pizza regularly, Kirkland Signature deserves a serious look.
Newman’s Own
Newman’s Own offers a more distinctive cheese combination than some basic frozen pizzas.
Its Thin & Crispy Four Cheese Pizza includes mozzarella, cheddar, Parmesan, and Asiago.
A 16-ounce package is listed at about $7.99 at Target.
The thin crust and multiple cheeses appeal to shoppers who want something beyond ordinary mozzarella.
The brand also performed respectably in The Washington Post’s October 2025 follow-up tasting, finishing third among six reader-recommended contenders.
It isn’t the cheapest option, but its cheese-focused approach helps it stand out.
Screamin’ Sicilian
Some frozen pizzas are restrained with toppings. Screamin’ Sicilian takes a noticeably different approach.
Its Holy Pepperoni Pizza features mozzarella, tomato sauce, and generous pepperoni.
A 22.3-ounce package is listed at about $6.99 at Target.
In Yahoo’s 2026 pepperoni taste test, Screamin’ Sicilian finished third, behind Motor City Pizza Co. and Rao’s.
For families who feel disappointed when a pizza arrives with only a few scattered pepperoni slices, this brand offers an appealing alternative.
Still, generous toppings aren’t everything. Crust and sauce remain important parts of the experience.
DiGiorno
DiGiorno has built its reputation around bringing a restaurant-style pizza experience into American homes.
Its Classic Crust Cheese Pizza weighs approximately 19.1 ounces and was priced at $4.67 in The Washington Post’s September 2025 testing.
That pizza won the publication’s blind taste test, earning 53 out of 70 possible points.
Reviewers particularly appreciated the combination of crust, sauce, and melted cheese.
It also performed well in the newspaper’s follow-up comparison.
Given its relatively accessible price, DiGiorno makes a strong case as one of the best mainstream frozen pizzas.
Motor City Pizza Co.
Motor City Pizza Co. delivers something different from the usual round frozen pizza.
Its Detroit-style pepperoni pizza features a thick rectangular crust, mozzarella, and pepperoni. The included baking tray helps produce the browned edges associated with Detroit-style pizza.
The approximately 26-ounce pizza has been advertised around $8.
In Yahoo’s June 2026 blind tasting, Motor City Pizza Co. finished first among the pepperoni contenders.
That result gives it one of the strongest independent endorsements on this list.
For shoppers who enjoy thick crust and crispy edges, Motor City Pizza Co. may be worth the extra freezer space.
Rao’s Homemade
Rao’s Homemade earns the top position in this editorial ranking, although its premium price may give budget shoppers pause.
Its Five Cheese Brick Oven Pizza combines mozzarella, provolone, fontina, Parmesan, and Romano cheeses on a brick-oven-style crust.
The 19-ounce pizza was priced at approximately $13.29 in research published in August 2026.
That same month, The Kitchn named Rao’s Five Cheese its winner after a blind tasting involving 16 frozen pizzas.
Yahoo also recognized it as a leading cheese-pizza contender.
At more than twice the price of several mainstream alternatives, Rao’s isn’t an automatic bargain. But for shoppers seeking a premium frozen pizza, its strong taste-test showing makes it a compelling choice.
Which Frozen Pizza Is Actually Worth Your Money?
The biggest lesson from these comparisons is that price doesn’t always predict satisfaction.
DiGiorno and Red Baron earned impressive results without requiring premium spending. Motor City Pizza Co. stood out for its Detroit-style pepperoni pizza, while Rao’s attracted praise for its cheese-focused offering.
And Home Run Inn’s victory in a separate reader-inspired taste test shows how much preferences can change depending on the panel.
Ultimately, the best frozen pizza is the one your household actually enjoys.
Now it’s your turn: Which frozen pizza brand would you defend against all the others, and which one will never make it into your shopping cart again?
