The pies come out after the plates are cleared, and for an hour they sit on the counter, half-eaten and tempting. Then comes the question every Thanksgiving host asks around bedtime: do they go in the fridge, the freezer, or nowhere at all?
The answer depends on the pie. Federal food safety charts and university extension offices give different clocks for different desserts: a pumpkin pie keeps 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator, while a custard pie should never go in the freezer. Thanksgiving falls on Nov. 26 this year, and here is how the dessert table compares, with the date of each source.

Pumpkin Pie: 3 to 4 Days in the Fridge
The federal FoodSafety.gov cold storage chart lists pumpkin or pecan pie at 3 to 4 days after baking in a refrigerator kept at 40 degrees Fahrenheit or below, and 1 to 2 months in a freezer kept at 0 degrees. The University of Illinois Extension’s leftover storage page is a little more precise, putting pumpkin pie at 4 days in the fridge and up to 2 months in the freezer.
A chart from Illinois Extension published Nov. 21, 2025, agrees on pumpkin pie at up to 4 days. A hosting checklist such as this list of kitchen checks before Thanksgiving dinner can help clear a shelf for the pies in advance, and a host comparing counter and fridge space can browse this list of refrigerator staples and these storage hacks. Anyone who needs oven room for a second round of baking can look at this comparison of ways to free up the oven. Dessert budgets matter too, and the 2026 Thanksgiving dinner cost by state shows what the whole meal runs in each state.
Pecan Pie Shares the Same Clock
Pecan pie sits on the same line as pumpkin pie in the federal chart: 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator and 1 to 2 months in the freezer. The University of Maine Cooperative Extension, in a March 30, 2023, article by educator Kathy Savoie, groups pumpkin, pecan and other egg-based pies together as pies to refrigerate and use within 4 days. For the freezer, the same article says pumpkin and pecan pies keep best quality within 2 months and should be thawed in the refrigerator.

Custard and Chiffon Pie: Never in the Freezer
This is where the dessert table splits. FoodSafety.gov lists custard or chiffon pie at 3 to 4 days after baking in the refrigerator and says not to freeze it. Maine Cooperative Extension says fresh fruit, custard, cream and chiffon pies do not freeze well, and that they should be refrigerated promptly, kept chilled until serving and eaten within 4 days.
Michigan State University Extension, in a piece published Nov. 22, 2013, says pumpkin pie should be refrigerated after baking, and that custard pies and cheesecakes follow the same rule. That article is older, so its advice is best read next to the newer charts. It also says store-bought pumpkin pies can sit on shelves because they contain preservatives, and Maine Extension adds that commercial pies should be checked against the label.
Fruit Pie and Apple Pie Break the Pattern
Fruit pies are the exception to the refrigerator-first rule, and the sources differ on the numbers. Illinois Extension’s turkey page lists apple pie at 3 days in the refrigerator and up to 2 months in the freezer. The Illinois chart of Nov. 21, 2025, lists fruit desserts or pie at up to 5 days.
Maine Cooperative Extension offers another route for sugar-sweetened fruit pies without eggs: covered at room temperature for up to 2 days, then in the refrigerator for up to 2 more days, or refrigerated right away for up to 7 days. For the freezer, it says fruit pies keep best quality within 4 months. Pies made with sugar substitutes should be refrigerated and eaten within 2 days.
Quiche and Eggnog on the Same Chart
FoodSafety.gov’s chart also covers two other holiday items. Quiche with filling keeps 3 to 5 days after baking in the refrigerator and 2 to 3 months in the freezer. Commercial eggnog keeps 3 to 5 days in the refrigerator and 6 months in the freezer, while homemade eggnog keeps 2 to 4 days and should not be frozen.
That makes homemade eggnog the one holiday drink that behaves like custard pie: refrigerate it and drink it up. Pie, quiche and eggnog together can crowd one shelf, so the chart is worth a glance before shopping.
A practical note for planning: the charts count days from baking, not from the first slice, so a pie baked on Nov. 24 for a Nov. 26 dinner has already used two of its days by the time the plates come out. Labeling the bake date on the foil is the easiest way to keep track, and a pie that is clearly past its window is not worth the gamble just because it looks fine.
Cooling Rules Before Any of These Clocks Start
All of these times assume the dessert was handled promptly. The USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service says to refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours and to discard perishable food left at room temperature longer than 2 hours, or 1 hour if the temperature is above 90 degrees Fahrenheit. Counting from a Nov. 26 bake, a pumpkin pie refrigerated that night reaches its 3 to 4 day mark on Nov. 29 or 30, and a homemade eggnog on its 2 to 4 day clock is done between Nov. 28 and Nov. 30.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Infrogmation of New Orleans – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons