Texas Roadhouse has confirmed that a diner in Forsyth, Illinois, was handed the wrong steak once, after Kenneth Card posted a TikTok saying he ordered an eight-ounce Dallas Filet at $29.99 and received a sirloin that sells for $19.49. Card says the mix-up happened on three separate visits. The chain says it can verify only one.
The dispute comes down to a $10.50 difference on the menu and to how many times it happened, according to reports from Complex, Fox News and the Fox station in Baltimore, WBFF, published on October 26 and 27, 2026.

What Kenneth Card Says Happened in Forsyth
Card, an Illinois customer, posted his account in a video on his @kennethcard3 TikTok page. Complex reported on October 27 that the video, which it dated to October 5, had drawn more than 31,000 views. Fox News, a day earlier, put the total at more than 30,000.
According to Fox News, Card had eaten at the Forsyth restaurant about once a week for more than a year and had gotten to know the staff. He has worked in hotel and restaurant kitchens that cut steaks, he told the outlet, and he said that experience lets him tell one cut from another. He described the filet as “very tender” and the sirloin as “a little grittier, a little chewier.”
On the first visit, Card said, he told staff he thought the steak was wrong, and the restaurant gave him a filet. On the second, he ate what arrived without saying anything. On the third, he asked for a manager. Complex reported that a server took the plate back for a second opinion, confirmed it was a sirloin, and brought out the filet he had ordered. Card boxed that one to go and posted his video after getting home, Fox News said.
Guides to steakhouse manners cover how a steak is ordered, sauced and sliced, but not what happens when the wrong cut arrives. Card told Fox News he is “done going in there” and does not expect to return to that location. Wrong-order complaints travel quickly on TikTok, as with a mother’s video about a Chick-fil-A sandwich a worker said was too late to swap.
The Two Steaks and the $10.50 Gap
Complex checked the Forsyth location’s online menu and found the eight-ounce Dallas Filet at $29.99 and the eight-ounce sirloin at $19.49, a gap of $10.50. Fox News, citing the restaurant’s website, rounded the figures to about $30 and about $20.
Both cuts are listed at eight ounces, so the price is the plainest difference on the menu. Card said he judged the plate by taste and texture instead. Diners who like to watch for kitchen trouble sometimes use lists of restaurant red flags, such as missing menu items or unclean floors. Others watching a budget turn to frugal living tips, which include skipping pricey restaurants for cheaper outings.
According to Wikipedia’s entry on the chain, the company opened its first restaurant in Clarksville, Indiana, in 1993 and is headquartered in Louisville, Kentucky. It listed 872 restaurants as of November 2025 and became the largest casual-dining chain in the country in April 2025. Bill disputes are a recurring TikTok topic too, including one diner’s account of an 18% gratuity added to a $300 dinner for five.

What Texas Roadhouse Told the Outlets
The company confirmed one wrong steak at the Forsyth restaurant. A spokesperson told People, as relayed by Complex, that the company could not confirm the mix-up happened on multiple occasions and that when Card raised it, the team “made right” the order. Management replaced the sirloin with the filet he had ordered once staff learned of the problem, Complex reported.
The statement to Fox News was similar. The spokesperson said the company had “not been able to track that this occurred on three occasions,” that management corrected the one confirmed mix-up on site by providing a filet, and that the team “quickly made it right.”
Both sides, then, agree on the basic event and differ on the count. Card says three; the chain says it can document one. Neither outlet reported any evidence beyond the video and the company’s statement.
How the Chain Says Orders Are Checked
Texas Roadhouse said it has processes in place to check food “for quality and accuracy before it leaves the kitchen,” according to Complex, and Fox News reported the spokesperson saying team members double-check dishes as they come out of the kitchen. Neither outlet described how steaks are identified for each ticket, and the company did not say whether the Forsyth restaurant changed anything after the video.
The chain also encouraged guests who think they received the wrong item or were overcharged to tell a team member right away so it can be corrected, according to both outlets. On a busy night that can be easier said than done, and Card himself said he stayed quiet on the second visit.
Fox News noted that reaction online was mixed. Some commenters thought the problem might be specific to that location, while others said they would not be able to tell a sirloin from a filet at all.
Where the Story Stands
As of the October 26 and 27 reports, the facts on the record are narrow. A diner in Forsyth received a sirloin after ordering a filet. The restaurant replaced it. The chain disputes that it happened three times, and Complex counted more than 31,000 views on the video.
The menu figures remain the easiest part to check, since both cuts are listed on the restaurant’s website with their prices. Diners who want to compare can look at the eight-ounce sirloin at $19.49 and the eight-ounce Dallas Filet at $29.99 for the Forsyth location, keeping in mind that prices at Texas Roadhouse can differ by restaurant.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Rick Obst – CC BY 4.0/Wikimedia Commons