Picture a Thanksgiving table with the turkey carved and the gravy boat making its rounds, and then a platter of crab legs arriving right behind it. For some families on the West Coast, that is not a twist on the holiday. It is simply how the meal has always looked.
Turkey still rules on Thursday, Nov. 26, 2026, but in several corners of the U.S. it shares the spotlight with another main dish. The Wikipedia entry on Thanksgiving dinner points to 4 standouts, from Northeastern venison to Puerto Rico’s mofongo-stuffed bird.

1. Venison in the Northeast
The calendar explains this one. Thanksgiving falls squarely within deer hunting season in the Northeastern United States, and the Wikipedia entry on the holiday meal notes that venison is a regular centerpiece there as a result.
For hunting families, a venison roast is a way to put the season’s harvest on the table when the whole family is home. Venison is the meat of deer, and the Wikipedia entry on venison lists it in forms ranging from steaks, tenderloin and roasts to sausages, jerky and ground meat. The same entry notes that venison burgers usually need added fat to match a hamburger in cooking time and texture, a hint at why many cooks braise venison slowly or wrap a roast in bacon.
Venison usually shows up alongside the turkey rather than replacing it. The result is a table with two very different centerpieces, which also means more planning in the kitchen. Hosts juggling a deep fryer for the bird can look over a list of things never to do with a turkey fryer before the big day.
2. Quail in Texas
Texas has its own take on the holiday bird. According to the Wikipedia entry on Thanksgiving dinner, Texas Monthly suggested quail as a main dish for the state’s Thanksgiving tables.
The small game birds fit naturally into Texas cooking, where hunting runs deep and game birds are a familiar sight in home kitchens. Because each bird is small, a plate of quail feels personal, and it makes a striking choice for a smaller gathering that does not need a 20-pound turkey. The Wikipedia entry on quail notes that many of the larger species are farm-raised for the table, others are hunted on game farms or in the wild, and that 40 million quail were produced in the United States in 2007.
Families heading to Texas for the holiday often pack light to dodge airline fees, and a roundup of carry-on suitcases that skip the checked-bag fee lays out some options. Larger households packing for several people may lean toward a 3-piece luggage set for holiday trips instead.
3. Dungeness Crab on the West Coast
In a few areas along the West Coast, Dungeness crab is a common alternate main dish, according to the Wikipedia entry on Thanksgiving dinner. The timing is a big part of the tradition.
The Wikipedia entry on Dungeness crab says the commercial season generally opens in November or December and closes in late August or early September, so fresh crab often lands in markets right around the holidays. The crab’s name comes from the Dungeness Spit in Washington state’s Strait of Juan de Fuca, and its typical range runs from Alaska’s Aleutian Islands to Point Conception near Santa Barbara, California.
Served cracked with melted butter and sourdough bread, a crab feast feels festive without needing hours in the oven. Air travel is expected to be heavy this year, with airlines projecting nearly 29 million Thanksgiving flyers, so plenty of visitors will get a first look at the tradition.

4. Puerto Rico’s Mofongo-Stuffed Turkey
In Puerto Rico, the turkey stays at the center of the table, but what goes inside it changes everything. The Wikipedia entry on Thanksgiving dinner says turkey in Puerto Rico is often stuffed with mofongo and served with arroz con gandules, pasteles and potato salad.
Mofongo itself is built mainly from green plantains, usually fried, then mashed in a wooden pilón with garlic, salt, pork, broth and a fat such as olive oil, butter or lard, according to the Wikipedia entry on mofongo. Pork cracklings called chicharrón are often packed into the mix. The same entry traces the dish to Spanish, Taíno and West African influences and notes that its earliest known written recipe appears in an 1859 cookbook.
When mofongo replaces or mixes with the usual bread stuffing, the result is known as pavochón, a playful blend of pavo, the Spanish word for turkey, and lechón, the roast pork found at so many Puerto Rican celebrations. Puerto Ricans on the island and in the diaspora alike have made the dish their own. Its usual partner, arroz con gandules, combines rice, pigeon peas and pork cooked in the same pot with sofrito, and the Wikipedia entry on arroz con gandules calls it Puerto Rico’s national dish along with roasted pork, served mainly at Christmas and on special occasions. Food customs vary widely from place to place, as a look at food laws and rules in other countries shows.
A Bigger Table Than the Turkey
These 4 mains show how Thanksgiving bends to local seasons and family roots. Hunting season brings venison to Northeastern tables, the start of crab season brings Dungeness crab to the West Coast, and Puerto Rican cooks fold their own flavors right into the bird.
The same pattern runs through the rest of the menu. The Wikipedia entry also describes Mexican American families serving turkey with mole and roasted corn and Cuban American families pairing it with a small roasted pork. The side dishes vary even more, and a state-by-state roundup Atlas Obscura published in November 2021 ties funeral potatoes to Utah and wild rice casserole to Minnesota. However the main course looks, the holiday still comes down to the same thing: a crowded table and a meal worth gathering around.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Lou Stejskal – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons