Every Thanksgiving table seems to have a pie debate, usually between the pumpkin loyalists and the pecan crowd, with someone at the end of the table quietly guarding the apple. A few state legislatures settled the argument for their own residents years ago.
Florida made Key lime pie its official state pie in 2006, Illinois picked pumpkin pie in 2016, Texas named pecan pie in 2013, and Vermont chose apple pie back in 1999. Each of those four states has a law or resolution on the books, and a handful of neighbors have their own official pie-adjacent desserts, too.

Florida: Key Lime Pie, Written Into State Law in 2006
Florida’s version is short and to the point. Section 15.052 of the Florida Statutes says Key lime pie is designated as the official Florida state pie, and its history line traces the law to chapter 2006-236.
The pie had a long road to that honor. The Key lime pie entry on Wikipedia notes that a 1965 bill would have fined anyone $100 for advertising Key lime pie that wasn’t made with actual Key limes. That bill failed. The small limes behind the name are more aromatic than common Persian limes and have yellow juice, which is why a real Key lime filling looks pale yellow rather than bright green. The traditional base is a graham cracker crust.
Florida’s official pie fits neatly with the state’s road-trip reputation, and travelers who have survived a few of the worst American tourist attractions, ranked in order, know that a good slice of local pie can rescue a disappointing stop.
Illinois: Pumpkin Pie, Named the State Pie in 2016
Illinois added pumpkin pie to its list of state symbols in 2016, according to the list of U.S. state foods on Wikipedia, which cites the Illinois State Designations Act. The same act also names an official state fruit, the GoldRush apple, and sweet corn as the state vegetable.
It’s an easy choice to understand. Pumpkin is the pie most people picture on the last Thursday of November, and a look at which pie tops Thanksgiving searches state by state shows how often pumpkin wins that contest. Illinois simply made it official.
The pumpkin pie also sits squarely among the odd American traditions that confuse the rest of the world, since a sweet, spiced squash custard baked in a crust can surprise visitors who grew up eating pumpkin only in soups.
Texas: Pecan Pie, by Resolution in 2013
Texas went the resolution route. The Texas State Library and Archives Commission lists pecan pie as the state pie under Senate Concurrent Resolution No. 12 of the 83rd Legislature, Regular Session, in 2013. The same list includes the jalapeno as the state pepper, so Texas covers both sweet and spicy.

The pecan pie entry on Wikipedia describes it as a pie made mainly with corn syrup and pecans, with roots in the Southern United States. Texas isn’t the only state that claims it, either: the Wikipedia state foods list shows pecan pie as part of the official Oklahoma state meal, adopted in 1988 alongside chicken-fried steak, fried okra, cornbread and black-eyed peas.
Families who remember a pecan pie on the sideboard every year will recognize it among the Thanksgiving dishes families served in the 1980s, a reminder that the pie was a fixture long before any legislature voted on it.
Vermont: Apple Pie, With a Serving Suggestion
Vermont was first of the four. Section 512 of Title 1 of the Vermont Statutes reads simply that the State Pie shall be apple pie, and the note below it says the section was added in 1999 and took effect May 10, 1999.
The fun part is the serving guidance. According to the Wikipedia state foods list, the designation calls for the pie to be served with a glass of cold milk, a slice of cheddar cheese weighing at least 1/2 ounce, or a large scoop of vanilla ice cream. Apple pie with cheddar can sound odd to outsiders, which makes it a natural fit for a list of strange Thanksgiving traditions that everyone pretends aren’t weird.
The Neighbors: Peach, Wild Blueberry and a Pie That Is Really a Cake
Several other states stopped short of a “state pie” title but still put a pie in the law as their official dessert. Delaware’s state symbols page says peach pie became the official state dessert on July 30, 2009. The state was the country’s leading peach producer for part of the 19th century, shipping 6 million baskets to market at its peak in 1875, and the idea came from fifth and sixth grade students at a school in Dover.
Maine’s law, Title 1, Section 226 of the Maine Revised Statutes, names blueberry pie made with wild Maine blueberries as the official state dessert, added in 2011. The same year, Maine gave the whoopie pie its own separate official title, so Maine bakers have two state-approved choices for the dessert table.
Massachusetts has the most famous twist. Section 41 of Chapter 2 of the Massachusetts General Laws makes the Boston cream pie the official dessert of the commonwealth, a designation dating to 1996. Yet the history of the Boston cream pie shows it is really a cake: two layers of sponge cake filled with thick custard. It is most commonly credited to French chef Augustine Francois Anezin at Boston’s Parker House Hotel, who reportedly made it for the hotel’s opening in 1856.
Why State Pies Still Get Attention Every November
None of these laws changes what lands on anyone’s holiday table. They are mostly a way for states to celebrate a crop, a local favorite or a bit of history, from Florida’s limes to Delaware’s peach orchards. Still, they make good conversation when the dessert plates come out.
Anyone hosting guests from Florida, Illinois, Texas or Vermont this Thanksgiving has an easy icebreaker. Serve the visitor’s state pie, and in the case of Vermont, keep a block of cheddar nearby just in case.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Evan-Amos – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons