The two most convenient shelves in a kitchen are the ones North Dakota State University Extension says to avoid for canned and boxed food. In its publication Questions and Answers About Storing Canned and Packaged Food, reviewed in June 2025, NDSU tells readers to keep canned foods and other shelf products out of 2 places: above the stove and under the sink.
The same line also rules out any spot exposed to high or low temperature extremes. Cans of tomatoes, boxes of cereal and packets of baking mix all belong in a cool, dry place, the publication says, and both of those named locations fail that test.

Why the Cabinet Above the Stove Fails
A stove puts out heat every time a burner or oven is on, and the cabinet above it catches much of it. Holiday cooking makes that worse, with long oven sessions and several burners running at once. NDSU’s guidance is to store shelf products away from heat extremes, and a cabinet over a working range is a textbook example.
A Washington State University extension note on how long to keep canned foods, which draws on guidance from the U.S. Food Safety and Inspection Service, uses nearly the same wording. Commercially canned foods should be kept in a cool, dry place, it says, and should never be stored under a sink, above a stove, in a damp garage or basement, or anywhere exposed to high or low temperature extremes.
A short list of things never to leave within 3 feet of the stove makes a similar point from the household-safety side: the area around a range is a working zone, not a storage zone.
Why the Space Under the Sink Fails
The cabinet under the sink fails for a different reason. It sits beside plumbing, where damp is common, and cleaning products often live there too. The Washington State note adds a damp garage or basement to the list of places to skip. Illinois Extension’s guidance on room temperature storage adds that the food storage area should stay dry and that food and cleaning supplies should not be stored in the same area.
That second point lines up with how Wikipedia describes a pantry: a room or cupboard where beverages, food, dishes, household cleaning products, linens or provisions are stored. The online encyclopedia’s definition is broad, but extension specialists draw a firmer line between the food shelf and the cleaning shelf. A piece on 8 things never to store under the kitchen sink covers the other side of the same cabinet.
.jpg?width=1600)
What a Good Spot Looks Like
NDSU’s answer is simple: a cool, dry place. That can be an interior pantry or a cabinet kept well away from the stove, the sink and the garage or basement. Illinois Extension adds that food should be kept off the ground, and that opened food should be covered with a storage bag or a lidded container to keep pests out.
Organizing ideas can help in a small kitchen. Roundups of clever storage hacks for every inch of space and best practices for seasonal storage cover home storage in general, though the temperature and moisture limits above still apply to canned and boxed food.
Date It and Rotate It
Placement is only half of the NDSU advice. It also says to write the date of purchase on packages when they come home from the store and to arrange cupboards in a “first in, first out” order, so the oldest food is used first. Washington State’s note offers a low-effort version: use a marker to record the month and year of purchase as groceries are unpacked, then use the oldest first. Illinois Extension recommends the first-in, first-out method too, to reduce food waste. Households reorganizing a cramped kitchen to make room for a cooler shelf may find ideas in a guide to kitchen remodel ideas on a shoestring budget.
NDSU lists examples of recommended storage times. Home-canned food keeps for one year from the date of canning. High-acid canned foods such as tomatoes and other fruit keep up to 18 months, and low-acid foods such as canned meat and vegetables keep 2 to 5 years. Cereals and cook-before-eating items such as oatmeal last 6 to 12 months unopened and 3 months after opening. Baking powder is listed at 6 months unopened and 3 months after opening, and cake, brownie and bread mixes at 12 to 18 months unopened.
The Washington State note gives matching figures for commercially canned food: up to 18 months for high-acid foods including tomatoes and fruits, and several years for low-acid foods like meat and vegetables. Package dates need careful reading, too. Both NDSU and Illinois Extension say a “best if used by” date reflects when flavor or quality is highest and is not a purchase or safety date.
Cans and Boxes to Skip at the Store
NDSU also lists products to avoid buying at all. Cans or containers with sharp dents, especially in the seam, and cans that are leaking or bulging, should be left on the shelf. So should cracked glass jars, jars with loose or bulging lids, food in torn packaging, and canned food with a foul odor or a container that spurts liquid when opened. Tamper-resistant seals should be intact, and the safety buttons on metal lids should be down. Illinois Extension adds that a container with bulges or dents should be thrown away, and that any product with a broken seal or an off smell should not be eaten.
Once a can is open, NDSU’s advice changes. For best quality, remove the food from the can and put it in another covered container before refrigerating or freezing. The publication also repeats the two-hour rule: perishable food left in the danger zone between 40 and 140 degrees Fahrenheit for more than two hours should be discarded, even if it looks and smells fine.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Born to Barnacle – CC0/Wikimedia Commons