Thanksgiving planning usually starts with food questions: who is bringing the pies, who has the biggest oven, how big a turkey is needed. For one TikTok creator, the planning took a different turn when a phone call revealed that the family dinner she attends every year had a new guest list.
TikTok creator Liv, who posts as @thespicygworl, says her mother-in-law decided that only her sons could come to the family’s annual Thanksgiving dinner, and that her husband’s answer was to suggest spending the holiday with her own parents. The Daily Dot reported her account on Nov. 17, 2026, and noted that it could not independently verify the claims, which rest on her telling in the video.
.jpg?width=1600)
What Liv says happened
According to the Daily Dot, Liv says her sister-in-law called to ask whether she had heard the news about this year’s Thanksgiving. The plan, as relayed, was that only the mother-in-law’s sons would attend dinner, and the daughters-in-law were encouraged to spend the holiday with their own families, without their husbands. Liv says the change was unusual, since she had celebrated the holiday with the family before and there had been no previous issues.
The Daily Dot said the video had 149,900 likes and 1,818 comments at the time of writing. The clip can be seen on TikTok, where the caption asks who comes first, a mother or a wife. The outlet’s account is based on her version only. The mother-in-law’s side has not been reported, and her reasons are unknown.
How the husband responded
After the call, Liv says she phoned her husband. He told her that his mother was going through something and was not listening to what she was saying, the Daily Dot reported. Rather than go along with the plan, he suggested that the couple travel to visit Liv’s parents instead. Liv said that made her happy and that she was glad to have a partner who advocated for her.
The picture was different for the other couple, she said. Her sister-in-law’s husband decided to follow his mother’s plan. Liv said the contrast showed why it matters to marry the right person. Even so, the outlet noted that she remained hurt about being left off the guest list. Teamwork between spouses is a theme in Frenzhub’s unspoken rules of a successful marriage.
What commenters said
The Daily Dot said many viewers supported Liv’s husband for backing his wife, while others criticized the mother-in-law’s plan. Some wondered why the mother-in-law could not have set up a separate day for just her sons. One commenter suggested there might be more to the situation and that something unreported could be going on in the mother-in-law’s life. Another commenter, who said she is a mother-in-law herself, described her own daughter-in-law as her child and praised the husband for putting his family first, per the outlet.
Those reactions show how divided online opinion can be on holiday guest lists, and they are comments rather than facts about this family. Nobody beyond Liv has described what the mother-in-law intended, and the family members involved are private people, so readers should hold the story lightly.
Holiday plans often shift, and the food side is the easy part. Frenzhub’s look at odd American traditions and the strange Thanksgiving traditions that everyone quietly accepts show how much of the day is habit. When a habit changes without warning, the surprise can sting more than the menu ever would.
Craftingyourhome has also covered mistakes a husband can make during holiday in-law visits and the things families quietly argue about at Thanksgiving dinner. Common themes include who hosts, who is invited, how the work is split and when to arrive, and the answers are rarely as tidy as a recipe card.
_Thanksgiving_Dinner.jpg?width=1600)
Why the guest list matters at Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving is a federal holiday celebrated on the fourth Thursday of November, which became the uniform date in 1941, according to Wikipedia’s entry on the holiday. This year it falls on Nov. 26. Wikipedia adds that the centerpiece of most celebrations is a Thanksgiving dinner with family and friends, which is why the question of who gets a seat can feel so loaded.
Etiquette guidance leans on clarity. The Emily Post Institute’s party tips for hosts and guests advise hosts to invite clearly and to take care creating a guest list. NPR’s Life Kit, in a 2022 segment aired by KAXE, quoted a New York-based marriage and family therapist who said fairness in holiday plans does not have to mean equal time, and that couples should be clear with family about the choice made for the year and be open to trying something different next time.
What couples can learn from it
For anyone in a similar spot, practical steps are simple. Ask the person who made the decision directly, rather than hearing it secondhand. Agree as a couple on a plan, and offer an alternative day for the extended family if possible. Keep the turkey, the sides and the pies on the original schedule, because the food will still need cooking somewhere. The family at the center of this story has not been identified beyond a first name, and the Daily Dot did not report any reply from the mother-in-law. Holiday plans, guest lists and family customs vary widely from household to household.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: HaJunkiyada – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons