A mother whose daughter hosts Thanksgiving for 12 to 15 people wrote to Miss Manners after the host turned down her own brother’s offer of pasta salad with a blunt “That’s for a picnic.” The etiquette columnist’s answer, published November 13, 2026: the son can simply skip bringing a dish this year.
The letter, which ran in newspapers including The Spokesman-Review under the headline “A potluck Thanksgiving where nobody wins,” lays out a family menu fight that will sound familiar to plenty of households in the two weeks before the holiday.

What the mother described
According to the column in The Spokesman-Review, the letter writer’s daughter is once again hosting Thanksgiving for the writer’s small family plus six people who work for the daughter’s husband and have no family in town. That brings the table to somewhere between 12 and 15 guests.
About 10 days before the holiday, the host texts everyone to ask what they plan to bring. The mother wrote that when guests answer, the daughter often rejects their choices and assigns them something else. This year the letter writer’s son offered pasta salad. The host was angry, said “That’s for a picnic,” and told him not to bring it because no one would eat it. The mother said her son was hurt.
The daughter then got in touch with her mother about it, and the mother pretended she had not already heard from the son. Her own idea for next year is a gentler system: the host would give each guest two dish suggestions to choose from. For this year, she asked Miss Manners whether her son should save the pasta salad for another time and offer to help in some other way, since he works later that day, or let it go and bring nothing at all.
Miss Manners says he can skip the dish
Miss Manners, the column written by Judith Martin with her children Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin, picked the second option. The answer told the mother that her son “can forgo bringing something,” especially given his work schedule. Judith Martin has written the etiquette column since 1978, and her son and daughter began sharing the byline in 2013.
The reply did not pretend that would end the tension. Miss Manners noted that the host might still pick a fight, since she seems inclined to do so either way. The column closed on a lighter note, suggesting that the mother and son “can go enjoy a lovely picnic with his pasta salad.”
The host’s side deserves a hearing. Feeding 12 to 15 people, including six of her husband’s coworkers who have no family in town, is a big job, and many hosts want a menu that feels planned rather than random. Etiquette guides for guests, like these simple tips for being the perfect houseguest, generally say the host sets the menu. The question in this letter is less about who decides and more about how the host says no.

Why the side dish fight is so common
A potluck works only when someone keeps the menu from turning into five bowls of the same thing, so a little coordination makes sense. The friction usually comes when a guest’s offer gets turned down without any warmth. Pasta salad, deviled eggs and other cold sides can feel like summer food to one cook and like a family classic to another.
The calendar adds pressure. In this family, the host’s text goes out about 10 days before the holiday, which is late enough that some guests have already planned or shopped for a dish. A rejection at that point can feel personal, even when the host is only trying to balance a menu for a crowd. The son in the letter also works later on Thanksgiving Day, which is part of why Miss Manners let him off the hook. A cold side that can be made ahead is a common pick for guests in that spot.
Holiday food carries a lot of family memory, too. Lists such as these Thanksgiving traditions that everyone pretends are not weird show how differently families define a proper holiday table, and so does a state-by-state look at how stuffing is the favorite Thanksgiving side in 38 states.
Families can often defuse these moments early. Many of the ideas in these ways to keep holiday disagreements from turning into big arguments apply just as well to siblings, and the old-fashioned approach in these old-school etiquette rules favored giving guests a specific assignment well ahead of time.
A few ways to keep a potluck menu from going sour
The mother’s two-suggestion plan is a good start. Hosts organizing a shared holiday table can also try a few simple steps:
- Send the menu outline first, with open slots such as “a green vegetable” or “a dessert,” so guests choose within a frame.
- Thank anyone whose dish does not fit and offer a swap rather than a flat no.
- Let guests who work that day bring drinks, rolls or ice instead of a cooked dish.
- Keep cold sides cold. The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service says food on the table is safe for about two hours, and leftovers should go into the fridge in shallow containers.
Miss Manners has already found the pasta salad a home. The son skips this year’s dish, and the bowl gets its moment at a picnic with his mother instead.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Selena N. B. H. from Fayetteville, USA – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons