The joke in frog eye salad’s name is a pasta shape, not an ingredient. The dessert-like side dish is built from tiny round noodles, pudding, whipped topping and mini marshmallows, and it turns up on Thanksgiving tables in Utah and Nevada, according to The Takeout and Marriott Traveler.
The Takeout, which ran the dish in a Nov. 16, 2025 list of 13 regional Thanksgiving sides, ties it to the western states where members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints live in large numbers. Marriott Traveler’s holiday food guide names Utah and Nevada directly, along with Wyoming.
What Goes Into the Bowl
The Takeout describes frog eye salad as a mix of custard or vanilla pudding folded with whipped cream or Cool Whip, canned fruit, mini marshmallows and shredded coconut. It compares the dish to ambrosia and to fruit salads made from canned fruit and whipped cream, and notes that it brings a level of sweetness not usually seen at Thanksgiving before the pie course.
Marriott Traveler lists the mix-ins as varying but possibly including vanilla pudding, sweetened coconut flakes, mandarin oranges and mini marshmallows. It says the finished dish resembles rice pudding. The guide’s author, Sowmya Krishnamurthy, wrote that the popularity of the dish is attributed largely to Mormon cuisine, where recipes often lean on convenience foods such as Jell-O or pudding mix.
Wikipedia’s entry on frog eye salad describes it as a sweet pasta salad, served as a dessert, made with small, round acini di pepe pasta, whipped topping and egg yolks. Fruit such as mandarin oranges and pineapple is often mixed in, the entry says, and it is sometimes topped with marshmallows. The three descriptions differ in details, which fits a dish passed along in family recipe collections.
Why the Little Pasta Gets the Name
The name comes from the noodles. Wikipedia’s entry on acini di pepe lists the pasta as Italian in origin and translates the name as “seeds of pepper.” The Takeout says the pasta supposedly resembles reptile eyes, and Wikipedia’s frog eye salad entry says the humorous name refers to the pasta looking like a frog’s eyes.
Marriott Traveler describes the pasta as bulbous and similar to orzo. Wikipedia adds that the salad also goes by the names fish-eye salad and fish’s eye salad, and the dish is sometimes written as frogeye or frog’s eye salad.
From Potlucks to the Thanksgiving Table
According to The Takeout, members of the Latter-day Saints church live in concentrated numbers in Utah and in surrounding states such as Nevada and Colorado, and LDS food culture thrives there. Casseroles are shared among families, along with sweet, creamy desserts that double as side dishes, and frog eye salad moved from family meal rotations and potlucks to a place at Thanksgiving dinners.
Wikipedia places the salad’s strong regional presence in Idaho and Utah and surrounding states, a stretch it calls the Mormon Corridor, and says recipes are often found in ward cookbooks, collections compiled from a single congregation. The entry also notes that in 2021 the Utah Museum of Contemporary Art in Salt Lake City displayed photographs of frog eye salad alongside other foods in a showcase of Mormon cultural dishes.
The sources do not agree on exactly which neighboring states belong on the list. The Takeout names Utah, Nevada and Colorado; Marriott Traveler names Utah, Nevada and Wyoming; Wikipedia names Idaho and Utah. Utah appears in all three and Nevada in two, which is why those two states carry the headline.
Regional Thanksgiving sides are a deep subject, and a list of strange Thanksgiving traditions that everyone pretends are not weird covers more of the odd corners of the holiday table. Family habits tend to stick, as a piece on people who keep the exact same holiday traditions every year observes.
Canned fruit and pudding salads belong to a broader nostalgia for older kitchens, a mood captured by a list of foods from the 1960s that most boomers loved and by a roundup of things found in nearly every American kitchen of the 1970s.
Thanksgiving sides of every kind compete for oven space, and a comparison of appliances that free up the oven this Thanksgiving is one way cooks plan around it.

Where to Taste It Without Cooking
Marriott Traveler recommends sampling frog eye salad at Chuck-A-Rama, which it describes as one of the oldest buffet restaurant chains in the Mormon Corridor. Dessert salads suit the communal gatherings, such as potlucks and buffets, that are central to Mormon culture, the guide says.
Wikipedia’s Chuck-A-Rama entry says Don Moss opened the first restaurant on September 7, 1966, in Salt Lake City. As of January 2022, the entry says, the company ran nine restaurants in Utah and two in Idaho. The menu leans toward American comfort food, including baked and fried chicken, carved turkey, ham, roast beef, mashed potatoes and gravy and deep-fried scones, with a salad bar included with every meal. The entry does not mention frog eye salad specifically, so the Marriott recommendation is the only source here for finding it on that buffet line, and locations and menus change.
For anyone who wants to try the salad on a Thanksgiving table, the sources agree on the core ideas: little pasta rounds, a creamy pudding base, whipped topping, canned fruit and marshmallows. Exact recipes vary by family and congregation, according to Wikipedia, which explains why the sources describe it a little differently.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Dvortygirl – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons