Tell a room of adults that a chip once tasted like pizza, and somebody will say they remember it. Chip flavors come and go faster than almost anything else in the snack aisle, which is why a bag that vanished years ago can still start a conversation.
Five chips are rarely seen anymore: Keebler Pizzarias, Lay’s Crunch Tators, Black Pepper Jack Doritos, Pringles Memphis BBQ and Lay’s Southern Biscuits and Gravy. Foodie’s list of discontinued snack chips covers all five, with the years and flavors that fans still talk about.
.jpg?width=1600)
Keebler Pizzarias, 1991
Pizzarias were a pizza-flavored chip, launched in 1991 in Cheese Pizza, Pizza Supreme and Zesty Pepperoni. Wikipedia’s entry on Pizzarias says they were made from fresh pizza dough with a new process, and that they reportedly brought in $75 million in wholesale revenue in their first year, Keebler’s most successful snack launch.
The ad campaign introduced two teenage Keebler elves, JJ and Zoot, with the line “Tastes like real pizza, only louder.” The chips earned Keebler a New Product Marketer of the Year award from the American Marketing Association in 1992, per Wikipedia. Three television commercials introduced the elves, and Foodie calls the chip the brand’s best-selling product at the time. It was discontinued in the late 1990s after Keebler was broken up and sold.
No relaunch is confirmed, but fan groups have petitioned Utz for a return. Anyone building a snack table from the past can pair that memory with a list of things every 1990s living room had, since the same rooms hosted plenty of pizza-chip parties.
Lay’s Crunch Tators, 1980s to the Mid-1990s
Crunch Tators were extra-crunchy potato chips that came in Original, Mighty Mesquite and Hoppin’ Jalapeño. Foodie dates them from the 1980s to the mid-1990s.
They are not completely gone: Foodie reports that they return seasonally at Dollar General, nationwide since 2024. That makes them the least absent chip on this list, though a seasonal shelf at one chain is still a long way from the regular snack aisle. Lay’s itself has a long history. According to Wikipedia, Herman Lay opened a snack food operation in Nashville in 1932, and his company merged with the Frito Company in 1961 to form Frito-Lay.
Seasonal snack aisles often reward shoppers who look. A list of everyday products Americans overpay for is a reminder that comparing store shelves before a party can be worth the time, and a list of items that should not be displayed on a kitchen counter helps clear room for the snack bowls.
.jpg?width=1600)
Black Pepper Jack Doritos, 2003 to 2008
Black Pepper Jack Doritos ran from 2003 to 2008, per Foodie, a pepper-flecked corn chip with a black pepper and cheese flavor. Foodie reports no return so far.
Doritos have a flavor history that rewards a look back. Wikipedia says the chip began at the Casa de Fritos restaurant at Disneyland, went national in 1966 in a single Toasted Corn flavor and added Taco in 1967 and Nacho Cheese in 1972. A cheese flavor named Jumpin’ Jack Monterey Cheese arrived in 1990 and was later discontinued, so a cheese-and-pepper Doritos flavor had earlier relatives in the family.
A five-year run is short in snack terms, and the flavor has not been back. Anyone stocking a party table can think about shelf space too: a guide to seasonal storage and a roundup of wallet-friendly life hacks both cover ways to keep a household organized and on budget through the holiday season.
Pringles Memphis BBQ, Early 2010s to About 2021
Pringles Memphis BBQ were sweet barbecue chips with earthy, tomato and smoky notes, according to Foodie, sold from the early 2010s until around 2020 or 2021. The Pringles brand began with Procter & Gamble, which, per Wikipedia’s Pringles entry, first marketed the chips in Indiana in 1968.
Kellogg’s acquired Pringles on May 31, 2012, for $2.695 billion, a date that falls inside the years Memphis BBQ was on shelves. Wikipedia notes that P&G owned the brand from 1968 to 2012, after a 2011 sale to Diamond Foods fell through in February 2012. Barbecue was already a standard Pringles flavor, so the Memphis version was a variation on a familiar theme, and fans who liked its smoky sweetness have had to go without.
Lay’s Southern Biscuits and Gravy, 2015 to 2018
This chip came out of a Lay’s flavor contest. Foodie says it won in 2015 and ran until 2018, tasting creamy, peppery and savory, with a brief return as a social media giveaway in late 2024.
A breakfast-table flavor in a chip bag is a good example of why short-lived flavors stay in memory. Fans vote, a limited run arrives, and when the contest cycle ends the chip is gone. Anyone who tried it can say they were there, and the 2024 giveaway shows the flavor still has fans willing to cheer for it.
Taken together, the five chips span from 1980s Crunch Tators to the Southern Biscuits and Gravy of 2018. Pizzarias ended after a corporate breakup, Black Pepper Jack after five years, Memphis BBQ after about a decade, and Crunch Tators faded and then returned as a seasonal item. The snack aisle keeps changing, and the flavors that vanish often turn into the ones people talk about longest.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Larry D. Moore – CC BY 4.0/Wikimedia Commons