Baking Soda Reacts Once, While Double-Acting Baking Powder Releases Gas Twice

Baking soda reacts once. Double-acting baking powder releases gas twice, first when it gets wet and again in the oven. That difference, laid out by Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, explains why cookies made with one leavener come out denser and cookies made with the other rise higher and bake up cakier.

The explanation comes from the university’s AnswerLine, in a Nov. 21, 2023 post by Marlene Geiger titled “How Ingredients Affect ‘How the Cookie Crumbles.'” Its short version: the two powders are not the same thing, and swapping one for the other is a misconception.

A group of chocolate chip cookies on a wooden cutting board, with chopped chocolate scattered beside them
Mshuang2 – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

Baking Soda: One Reaction and Done

According to the Iowa State AnswerLine post, baking soda is sodium bicarbonate, and it needs an acidic ingredient to release the carbon dioxide that leavens dough. The acids named include vinegar, sour cream or milk, brown sugar, lemon juice and chocolate. The post calls the result a single reaction, which leads to a denser cookie, and it advises mixing doughs leavened only with baking soda quickly and baking them right away for the most rise.

That timing advice shows up in a story from Science Meets Food, a site run by the IFT Student Association. In a Jan. 23, 2019 post, author Angelina Schiano explained that her cookies came out flat because the baking soda had already reacted during an overnight rest, leaving little leavening for the oven. In cookies, the acid often comes from the molasses in brown sugar, she wrote, and gas has to form while the gluten is still flexible.

The chemistry is old and well documented. Wikipedia’s entry on sodium bicarbonate says baking soda releases carbon dioxide when it meets an acid such as cream of tartar, citric acid, lactic acid or vinegar. Heat alone also releases some gas above 80 °C, but only half of the available amount, and the leftover sodium carbonate leaves the baked product tasting bitter and turning yellow. The first American factory for baking soda opened in 1846, founded by bakers John Dwight and Austin Church, according to the same entry.

Anyone planning a cookie marathon for the holidays will want oven space sorted out first, which is the focus of a comparison of COSORI versus Ninja air fryers and toaster ovens for freeing up the oven this Thanksgiving, and a checklist of five oven checks to make before the turkey goes in applies equally to a tray of cookies.

Baking Powder: Two Releases

Baking powder carries its own acid. Iowa State describes it as a chemical leavener containing sodium bicarbonate and acids, and it is double acting: it begins leavening when wet and again when heated. Most of the reaction happens in the second stage, so the dough stays stable and does not have to go into the oven the moment it is mixed. The post says baking powder gives cookies more rise and a cakier texture.

Wikipedia’s article on baking powder adds the ingredients list. It is a dry mix of a bicarbonate base, usually baking soda, one or more weak acids and a desiccant such as cornstarch, which keeps the parts from reacting before use. Single-acting powder releases all its gas as soon as it gets wet, while double-acting powder releases some when wet and more in the oven. Double-acting is the type most widely sold today and is more forgiving when mixing and baking are separated by a delay.

A small pile of fine white sodium bicarbonate powder on a round glass dish
Tszrkx – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

The same entry traces the history. The earliest commercially sold baking powder was Borwick’s, launched in England in 1842, and in 1843 English chemist Alfred Bird developed a single-acting version. Harvard’s Eben Norton Horsford patented a phosphate-based acid in the 1850s and 1860s and developed the first double-acting baking powder. Kitchen staples have histories of their own, and a post on five things found in nearly every American kitchen of the 1970s and still remembered fondly is a reminder of how long some have lasted.

Smaller cookie batches suit a countertop oven, and rankings such as the 5 best air fryer toaster ovens of 2026 cater to that kind of baking. A day of baking also fits the mood of a roundup of positively simple cozy crafts for a very hygge winter.

Why the Two Are Not Interchangeable

Iowa State states it plainly: it is a misconception that the two can be used interchangeably. The post adds that it is quite common for recipes to use both leaveners.

Utah State University Extension’s list of ingredient substitutions shows how much has to change to swap one for the other. To replace 1 teaspoon of baking powder, it calls for 1/4 teaspoon of baking soda plus an acid: 5/8 teaspoon of cream of tartar, 1/2 cup of soured milk or buttermilk, 1/2 tablespoon of vinegar or lemon juice with enough milk to make 1/2 cup, or 1/4 to 1/2 cup of molasses. The page covers only that direction. It gives no ratio for replacing baking soda with baking powder.

What the Difference Looks Like on the Cookie Sheet

Put together, the sources describe two clear outcomes. A soda-only dough with brown sugar bakes into a denser cookie, and a powder-leavened dough rises more and eats cakier. Science Meets Food adds that shape depends on more than leavening, since fat melts in the oven and causes spreading, butter spreads more than shortening and chilling the dough delays melting.

The Wikipedia article on leavening agents notes that chemical leaveners release gas when their ingredients react with each other, with moisture or with heat, and that they are used in quick breads, cakes and cookies, where long fermentation is not practical. It also recalls that Amelia Simmons mentioned chemical leavening with pearl ash in American Cookery in 1796.

For a cook who finds a recipe asking for both, the sources point to the same lesson: neither powder is a stand-in for the other, and the order of mixing and baking matters most when baking soda is working alone.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Evan-Amos – Public domain/Wikimedia Commons

Author

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *