It happens in kitchens every holiday season. The cookie dough is half mixed, the oven is preheating, and the recipe calls for baking powder, but the only tin in the cabinet says baking soda. They look the same, they sit side by side on the grocery shelf, and it is tempting to just scoop one in for the other.
According to King Arthur Baking, that shortcut is one of several leavening substitutions that can quietly ruin a batch. In a September 2021 guide by contributor Justine Lee, the Vermont flour company explains why baking soda and baking powder can’t be swapped spoon for spoon, and which other swaps fail. Here are 4 substitutions to skip, plus the ratios that do work.
.jpg?width=1600)
1. Swapping Baking Soda and Baking Powder in Equal Amounts
The biggest mistake is treating the two as interchangeable. King Arthur’s guide to baking soda and baking powder substitutions states plainly that equal amounts of one cannot be substituted for the other.
The reason is chemistry. Baking soda is sodium bicarbonate, a base that only releases carbon dioxide when it meets an acid. Baking powder already contains baking soda plus a dry acid, so it can lift a batter on its own. King Arthur notes that double-acting baking powder reacts twice: once when it dissolves in the batter and again when the batter heats in the oven.
The two also do different jobs. According to King Arthur, baking soda mainly drives spread, while baking powder adds height and lightness. Swap one for the other in equal amounts and cookies can puff when they should spread, or spread when they should rise. For more everyday fixes at the counter, Frenz Hub’s list of clever kitchen tricks for home cooks is a handy companion.
2. Leaving Out the Acid in a Baking Soda Recipe
Because baking soda needs an acidic partner, swapping out the acidic ingredient in a soda recipe can leave the leavener with nothing to react with. King Arthur lists wet acidic ingredients such as buttermilk, yogurt, sour cream, lemon juice, vinegar, honey and maple syrup, and dry ones such as brown sugar and natural cocoa powder.
That is why trading tangy buttermilk for plain milk, or brown sugar for all white sugar, in a recipe built around baking soda can change the result. Without enough acid, the batter may not rise as expected. Bakers who make that kind of change often need to rethink the leavening too.
Holiday bakers juggling several recipes at once may also want to check the oven itself. A list of oven checks to make before the turkey goes in applies just as well to a day of cookies and pies.
3. Using Dutch-Process Cocoa in Place of Natural Cocoa
Chocolate cakes and cookies are a classic trap. King Arthur says Dutch-process cocoa won’t contain enough acidity to activate baking soda, while natural cocoa powder does.
According to Wikipedia’s entry on Dutch-process chocolate, the method was developed in the early 19th century by Dutch chocolate maker Coenraad Johannes van Houten. Treating cocoa with an alkalizing agent lowers its natural acidity, making it darker and less bitter. That smoother flavor is the point, but it also means a recipe that counts on natural cocoa’s acid for its rise can come out flat when Dutch-process cocoa is swapped in. Keeping the two cocoas clearly labeled helps, and a list of items that shouldn’t be displayed on a kitchen counter offers ideas on where baking tins belong.

4. Tripling Baking Powder for Baking Soda and Expecting the Same Taste
There is a workable swap in one direction, but it comes with a catch. King Arthur says 1 teaspoon of baking soda can be replaced with 3 teaspoons of baking powder. Because that means using so much more powder, the guide warns the result may have a slightly bitter, off taste. For a recipe that calls for 1 teaspoon of soda, that means a full tablespoon of baking powder, which is a noticeable amount in a small batch of cookies or a single loaf of quick bread.
King Arthur also points out that substitutes “won’t perform absolutely the same” as the original leavener and advises avoiding swaps when possible. Timing matters as well: baking soda reacts as soon as it meets acid, so batters and doughs made with it should go into the oven right away rather than sit on the counter.
The Swaps That Do Work, and How Long the Tins Last
For bakers who run out of baking powder, King Arthur offers tested replacements. For 1 teaspoon of baking powder, use 1/4 teaspoon baking soda plus 1/2 teaspoon cream of tartar plus 1/4 teaspoon cornstarch. Another option is 1/4 teaspoon baking soda plus 1/2 teaspoon lemon juice or white vinegar. Self-rising flour, which already contains baking powder and salt, can also stand in for all-purpose flour.
Freshness matters just as much as ratios, since leaveners lose strength over time. North Dakota State University Extension’s guide to storing canned and packaged food lists baking powder at six months unopened and three months after opening. Writing the opening date on the tin makes it easy to tell. Frenz Hub’s guide to seasonal storage and Frenz Hub’s tips on storage hacks that maximize every inch of space can help keep baking supplies organized and easy to rotate.
The simplest rule from King Arthur’s guide: read the recipe and the label, use the leavener it calls for, and save substitutions for real emergencies.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Miansari66 – Public domain/Wikimedia Commons