A block of farm cheddar is one of those groceries that tends to hide in the back of the cheese drawer for weeks, waiting for a cracker plate or a grilled cheese night. This week, shoppers in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic have a good reason to pull that drawer open and read the label.
Family Farmstead Dairy of Worcester, New York, has recalled its 8-ounce Raw Mild Cheddar and Raw Sharp Cheddar, covering every lot code with a best-by date of 10/16/27 and earlier, because the cheese may be contaminated with Listeria monocytogenes. The cheese went to retail stores in 12 states, and the company says shoppers can return it to the store where they bought it.

Exactly Which Cheddar Is Recalled
The company announcement posted by the FDA on Nov. 10, 2026 lists two products, both sold as 8-ounce, plastic-wrapped pieces under the Family Farmstead brand:
- Raw Mild Cheddar, 8 oz, plastic wrapped: all lot codes dated 10/16/27 and prior
- Raw Sharp Cheddar, 8 oz, plastic wrapped: all lot codes dated 10/16/27 and prior
In practice, that means any piece of either cheese with a best-by date of Oct. 16, 2027, or earlier belongs in the recall. The dairy put it plainly in the notice: all cheddar products with an expiration date of 10/16/27 and prior are being recalled. The company added that no other Family Farmstead Dairy products are included unless it specifically names them.
The agency’s one-line reason is short and clear: the cheese has the potential to be contaminated with Listeria monocytogenes. Food Safety News reported the recall on Nov. 11, 2026, describing it as a recall of all of the dairy’s raw cheddar products.
The 12 States on the List
According to the FDA notice, the cheese was distributed through retail stores in these 12 states: New York, New Jersey, Vermont, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Connecticut, Delaware, Virginia, West Virginia and Tennessee.
One detail is worth flagging for shoppers comparing reports. Some early coverage listed Maryland in place of Massachusetts. The company’s own notice on the FDA site names Massachusetts. Maryland did appear in the distribution list for the dairy’s earlier October recall, so anyone in Maryland who bought Family Farmstead cheddar this fall still has every reason to check the label. Holiday travelers who stock up on farm cheese at roadside stops, a ritual that ranks right alongside the famous American tourist stops that rarely live up to the hype, should check any block that came home in a cooler.
Holiday cheese boards are a big part of the season in many homes, a habit that sits right alongside the other American food traditions that puzzle visitors from abroad. That makes this a smart week to look before slicing. A quick sweep fits neatly into the fridge and freezer checks worth doing before the big Thanksgiving grocery run.
What to Do With Recalled Cheese
Shoppers holding the cheese have three simple options, based on the company notice:
- Return it: take the cheese back to the place of purchase.
- Throw it away: do not serve it, slice it for a platter or melt it into a casserole.
- Contact the dairy: Family Farmstead Dairy takes questions at (607) 397-4044, Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., or by email at [email protected].
Anyone who cut the cheese on a shared board can wash the board, knife and any containers it touched with hot, soapy water before using them again. It also pays to keep a tidy cheese drawer, the sort of habit covered in these kitchen organization ideas, so recalled items are easy to spot. Hosts running through a kitchen checklist before Thanksgiving dinner can add one line: no Family Farmstead raw cheddar dated 10/16/27 or earlier on the appetizer tray.
This Follows an October Recall
This is the second time this fall that the Worcester dairy has pulled cheddar from shelves. On Oct. 15, 2026, the company recalled a single lot of Raw Mild Cheddar with a lot code and best-by date of 7/22/27. The first FDA bulletin, sent Oct. 16, named E. coli O157:H7 and listed distribution to grocers in New York and New Jersey.
Days later, an updated FDA bulletin sent Oct. 19 corrected both the strain and the map. It named E. coli O26:H11 and O45:H2 and widened distribution to New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Connecticut, Maryland, Virginia and Massachusetts, noting the cheese may also have reached other states through downstream distributors. That October lot is dated 7/22/27, so it also falls inside the new 10/16/27 cutoff.
Timeless Dishes covered that first round in its piece on the raw cheddar recall that hit New York and New Jersey. The November action is broader: instead of one lot, it now covers every raw mild and raw sharp cheddar lot through the October 2027 date.

Why Raw Cheddar Is Its Own Category
Raw-milk cheddar is made from milk that has not been pasteurized, which is why it carries “raw” right in the product name. Cheddar itself is one of the most familiar cheeses in American kitchens, a firm cheese that originated in the English village of Cheddar in Somerset and is now made in many countries, with flavor that ranges from mild to extra sharp the longer it ages.
Small farmstead makers like this one sell their cheese through regional grocers and specialty shops, which is why the distribution map reads like a road trip through the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic. Worcester is a small town in Otsego County in central New York, a dairy-farming part of the state.
The FDA keeps its full list of current food notices on its recalls, market withdrawals and safety alerts page, which is the best place to look for any update to the product list or states.
The Short Version for Shoppers
Look for Family Farmstead Raw Mild Cheddar or Raw Sharp Cheddar in an 8-ounce plastic-wrapped piece. If the date reads 10/16/27 or earlier, it is part of the recall. Return it to the store or throw it away, and call the dairy with any questions about a refund.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: CNEcija12345 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons